3 ms·
What an astonishingly vapid and frustrating article. We need to get past these semantic arguments about what constitutes "intelligence." The "do submarines swim
by baddox 12y ago
What an astonishingly vapid and frustrating article. We need to get past these semantic arguments about what constitutes "intelligence." The "do submarines swim" analogy is cliched, but perfectly appropriate. It doesn't matter how you define "swim." Submarines are better at certain tasks than human bodies on their own. Likewise, computer systems that we label "AI" systems are better at certain tasks than human bodies (brains) on their own.
The author seems to use "intelligence" and "autonomy" interchangeably, which is troubling, mostly because he makes no attempt at actually defining either. His claim that amoebas and plants "exhibit an intelligence, an autonomy, an originality, that far outstrips even the most powerful computers" is ludicrous under any remotely plausible definitions of the terms. If humans genetically engineer an amoeba or a plant to change its behavior, is the magical "autonomy" suddenly gone?
Also, his argument is ridiculous even as semantic arguments go, since "artificial" isn't supposed to mean "synthetic." The standard dictionary definitions are "made by humans" and "false or pretending."