4 ms·
> a per hour storage cost of $103/kWh Ouch!
by jjoonathan 12y ago
> a per hour storage cost of $103/kWh
Ouch!
- pslam 12y agoThat's got to be a typo, or this story is burying the lead. Is pumped hydro really 30% more inefficient than even that figure? Because that would mean it's almost entirely a waste of money for anyone to store energy by this or other means. If it's $103/GWh, on the other hand, then we're talking about only ~10% overhead on costs.
- al_bundling 12y ago> Is pumped hydro really 30% more inefficient than even that figure? The article states 30% cheaper, not 30% more efficient. > If it's $103/GWh, on the other hand, then we're talking about only ~10% overhead on costs. The article states $103/kWh, not per GWh. To calculate overhead costs you would need to know life cycle costs which were not disclosed.
- Tarrosion 12y agoIn a storage context, quoting a price per kwh is somewhat ambiguous. Does it cost an additional $103 every time 1 kwh i stored, or does 1 kwh of capacity cost $103 with a per-usage cost of ~$0? There's probably a standard interpretation, but it's not obvious to a lay reader like me.
- ghshephard 12y agoSomewhere in the middle - the capital costs are $103/kWh - So, if you want to store 1 MWatt for 1 hour (Large Solar / Wind plant with variable sun/wind, and fixed size upstream transmission), it will cost you $103,000 fixed costs. OpEx is a function of maintenance, operation, life time, and duty-cycle of the plant.
- sengstrom 12y agoI was wondering what that means too - maybe the strange unit ($103 kWh per hour) is a clue to what they are talking about. Remember this is temporary storage for wind or solar energy, presumably to be extracted when the sun goes down or the wind stops turning the blades.
- al_bundling 12y agoIt's not so bad. Less than pumped hydro and conventional batteries and at grid scale. Combined those are big pluses as pumped hybro can't be built anywhere and batteries are not suitable for grid scale. The question is, what are the life cycle costs? If it's on par with pumped hydro, then we are talking.
- mikeyouse 12y agoI think the confusion is that the $103/kWh is the capital cost to build the storage rather than the operating cost to actually recover a kWh of energy. So to provide 10kW for 10 hours (for instance, overnight storage for a large house), they'd need a 100kWh system at a cost of ~$10,000, where they're claiming that a pumped hydro system would cost 20% more. The benefit of course to pumped hydro is that you can have hundreds or thousands of MW in storage. These units would be consistent with other reporting for grid-scale battery systems costing ~$250/kWh to construct: http://cleantechnica.com/2013/12/18/utility-scale-battery-storage-costs-dropping/ http://cleantechnica.com/2013/12/18/utility-scale-battery-st... As for operating costs, I'm assuming that the nameplate storage capacity is the output. So if you have a 100kWh system with ~60% throughput efficiency, you'd need 160kWh of input at your standard energy rates and then the energy coming out would be 'free' -- of course there'd be costs for maintenance and depreciation too though.
- gonzo 12y ago> So if you have a 100kWh system with ~60% throughput efficiency, you'd need 160kWh of input at your standard energy rates and then the energy coming out would be 'free' I think the idea is that this is storage for renewables. As such, you wouldn't need more "input at your standard energy rates" than what it might take to charge the system for overnight use.
- mikeyouse 12y agoRight, I guess I was getting at the 'cost' of energy would be he opportunity cost of not selling it back to the grid which is typically the retail price in areas with net metering. Although in off-the-grid situations, you're right that there wouldn't be any incremental cost to charging the storage.
- jjoonathan 12y agoThat makes much more sense. My unstated assumption was that a decimal place had been forgotten -- thanks for doing my homework for me and clearing things up :)
- Sorgam 12y agoIt's capital cost for providing 1kWh of storage for an imaginary 1 hour. I don't think that makes much sense, since you wouldn't be able to scale down the capital costs in proportion to the storage time. $103/kWh*6h = $618/kW which is on Isentropic's own site describing a turbine rather than pistons: "With a capital cost of only $618/kW for 6 hours of storage ($375/kW power machinery and $40/kWh stored energy) and a round-trip efficiency in excess of 90% this is the cheapest and most efficient form of energy storage." http://www.isentropic.co.uk/Energy-Storage-Systems http://www.isentropic.co.uk/Energy-Storage-Systems
- pkulak 12y agoBatteries are currently at $250, best case. Up to $500, depending on who you talk to.
- dredmorbius 12y agoAs others have noted, this is capital cost per kWh of capacity. Compare against Beacon Energy's 25kWh flywheel storage units, which have a cost of $10,000 per kWh. There are trade-offs. Beacon's system is very highly responsive (flywheels can pretty much take up or deliver as much energy as you want, with response in the second to sub-second level) directly receive and deliver electrical energy, and have extremely high round-trip efficiency (90%+, approaching 99%). As an alternative to spinning reserve they have benefits. http://www.beaconpower.in/html/technology.html http://www.beaconpower.in/html/technology.html http://beaconpower.com/ http://beaconpower.com/ The problems are the limited capacities of individual units (25 kWh isn't that much power at grid scale), engineering problems, notably precession (the Earth's own rotation about its axis is a concern for the units), and interesting failure modes (preferred deployment is burying the units in below-grade concrete containment with massive lids -- you neither want systems flying apart nor wandering about the neighborhood at 16,000 RPM should the come unmoored). Flywheels are among the more expensive energy storage options available, but at least at first glance the cooling option looks reasonable.
- superuser2 12y agoYou don't have to get to grid scale for 25 kWh to seem like not much. Your average, underfunded community or educational theater has 150-200 lighting dimmers, each at 2.4 kW. I can consume half a megawatt (200 circuits x 20A x 120V = 480kW) in 6 keystrokes.
- dredmorbius 12y agoTo be fair, Beacon gangs its units -- you wouldn't have a single 25 kWh module, but an installation of them. The company's demonstration project is a 20 MW capacity plant with 200 flywheels. http://www.energycentral.com/generationstorage/energystorage/news/vpr/11127/Beacon-Power-Flywheel-Plant-in-Stephentown-Reaches-Full-20-MW-Capacity http://www.energycentral.com/generationstorage/energystorage... The other factor is that when you're operating at grid scale, it's overall changes to the grid flow that you're concerned with. A large city might have a peak load of 2000 MW, and the plant here could handle a fluctuation of 10% -- given the law of large numbers, that's a lot. Sure, you might be turning on a slew of light banks in any given period, but someone somewhere else could be cycling down a cooling plant, or resistance heater, or the like. I suspect large rapidly cycling loads might also be at issue -- with electrified transit, light rail and trolley buses make high instant demands on the grid, and then return energy through regenerative braking. I don't know how such loads are managed, but they're substantial and I do know that utilities tend to segregate these from other residential and commercial circuits.