6 ms·
Criminalizing everyone - Needed: A 'clean line' to determine lawfulness
- fnid 17y agoA person should not be deemed a criminal unless that person "crossed over that line knowing what he or she was doing." We used to say, "Ignorance is no excuse for the law." The situation now though, is that there are so many laws and regulations that it is impossible not to be ignorant. Not only do we not know the laws, but we don't know how to find out what the laws are. Small business owners are especially prone to mistakes considering there are corporate laws, civil laws, tax laws, employment laws...
- trebor 17y agoI think that there must be an exception for certain crimes, but not all crimes. Otherwise, a murderer, rapist, thief, corporate spy, hacker, etc, could claim that they didn't know it was illegal and probably get off the hook.
- jerf 17y agoThe one being discussed is "criminal intent". It's an admittedly fuzzy term, but clearly if you're murdering someone, you have criminal intent regardless of your knowledge of whether it is illegal. Well... mostly clearly. Clearly enough in the murder case, but there's certainly fuzzy cases. Still, there are an awful lot of crimes on the book that when you lack criminal intent, it doesn't actually make sense to prosecute from either a "rehabilitation" or "punishment" point of view, such as the ones in the article. What did society gain by any useful metric in the orchid case? In fact it lost a lot for no good reason.
- Arkanin 17y agoDisclaimer -- IANAL, so maybe we can all get some elaboration from an attorney and learn something? Let's make a distinction between intent and awareness of the law. For example's sake, let's say you've been trading stock off a tip a company insider gave you, which is illegal. At the same time, you don't know it's illegal, but you are consciously trading the stock. Intent -- You have the intent to trade the stock because you are doing it during the day, awake and fully aware of your actions. You would not have intent if you traded the stock while sleepwalking. Awareness of the law -- You are not aware that your actions are a crime, despite having an intent to perform those actions. This makes no difference -- you are held accountable for your actions whether you knew they were illegal or not, as long as you were cognizant while you were taking those actions. IANAL, so again, the language is probably all flubbed. But it's my understanding that intent matters, not awareness of the law. Can anyone correct me if I'm mistaken?
- moron4hire 17y agoThe concept of "Ignorance of the law is no excuse" (Ignorantia juris non excusat) was really only ever meant in the context of natural laws, e.g. murder, theft, rape, etc. These things are so obviously horrible that anyone should know they are wrong. Hence "crossed over that line knowing what he or she was doing." In the realm of political laws, ignorance absolutely excuses. Why should it be obvious that importing orchids requires certain paperwork?
- aaronblohowiak 17y ago.. and why should the penalty be imprisonment instead of "hey, we know you probably mean well, here is what it takes to do the right thing: x, y, z." I think we need a line between criminality and what i'll call "regulation" -- which, if intentionally ignored should become criminal, but otherwise there services should help people be law-abiding.
- idm 17y agoObligatory Ayn Rand quote (via Dr. Ferris, in Atlas Shrugged): "There's no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren't enough criminals one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws. Who wants a nation of law-abiding citizens? What's there in that for anyone? But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced or objectively interpreted – and you create a nation of law-breakers – and then you cash in on guilt." My personal theory of how this situation came about, however, could be called the "Walker, Texas Ranger" explanation. I think some lawmakers/enforcers turn vigilante when they are convinced a would-be criminal has gotten away with some potentially-criminal act because of how the law is written, so they seek to change the law. As hackers, I assume we all have a lot of experience with [computer] code, and we're aware that a small change "here" can have unexpected side-effects "there." I know that when I learned about SML, Lisp, and functional programming without "side effects" I was blown away that it was possible to formally prove the execution of some functions. In other words, it is possible to write good, clean, predictable code. Nothing like that exists for legal code, however. It's a tangled mass of declarative assertions, nested dependencies, GOTO statements, (naive) version control, and namespaces. A vigilante action to alter some part of the code essentially has unpredictable consequences for other parts of the code. The changes couldn't be measured if you wanted. In a management sense, the project is totally out of control. Big surprise, then, that private enforcement and prisons are a growth industry. Some people see this for what it is: an opportunity. Just make sure you're an investor instead of a "customer."
- te_platt 17y agoThe cases cited in the story are more in line with bureaucrats maintaining budget. By that I mean you have an agency that needs to justify their budget of X dollars with Y convictions to show for it. It's hard to imagine any of the agents mentioned being much concerned about orchids. It's easy to imagine them being concerned about their careers.
- idm 17y agoAgreed. Whatever the motivations of the agents referred to in the article, it is still the case that "inappropriate" laws were applied to (presumably) non-criminal activity. It's just speculation on my part, but my theory had to do with those how those laws came to exist. Once the laws exist, then it's just a matter of any agent sufficiently familiar with those laws to apply them. By that point, it doesn't need to be vigilante activity. An agent with only the best intentions can end up causing harm (i.e. convert a free citizen into a criminal) simply because the laws are flawed.
- DanielStraight 17y agoThere are times I think the number of laws should be fixed... at say 1000. If congress wants to make a new law, they have to remove an old one.
- tc 17y agoThat's a good idea, though the constant should be lower. Human societies survived for thousands of years with on the order of 10 (very popular) to a few dozen criminal statutes.
- DanielStraight 17y agoWell, we do have a lot more to make laws about now. Internet privacy law was clearly not a concern for cavemen. If you make the law too general, you'll have the same problem.
- tc 17y agoThere's a legal scholar (and I'm blanking on the source at the moment) that makes a very convincing point that a small handful of laws (against violence, fraud [1], etc.) covers 95-98% of all cases. The other 2-5% of cases are necessarily judgement calls. What's interesting is that the percentage of cases requiring judgement calls doesn't decrease as you go from N laws to 10,000N laws. [1] To your point: it's true that we have more things we can make laws about, but I suspect that it isn't true that we should make laws about every specific thing. Fraud is fraud, murder is murder. It shouldn't matter whether you use the internet, a telephone, or pencil and paper to defraud someone, in the same way that we don't need a separate murder statute for each choice of murder weapon.
- iron_ball 17y agoAnd the exact application of those few laws in nearly infinite situations would require first a caste of extremely powerful judges, and later an accumulation of precedents which would effectively become a massive and complex legal code in itself.
- redsymbol 17y agoIt's easy to have an emotional reaction to this. But maybe it's smart for us to think coolly and practically for a moment. This trend is probably unlikely to reverse in the short term. Until then, how can those of us in the USA protect ourselves and those we care about? The two examples in the article were both entrepreneurs and small business owners. Would it have helped them to have better legal representation from the beginning? If so, exactly what form? The article didn't mention their legal structures used; the fuel cell fellow may have been incorporated somehow, but I'd bet the orchid importer's vehicle was a sole proprietorship. Would operating as a corporation or LLC have helped? I doubt this is something we can answer fully in this thread. But maybe we can get started. -Aaron
- DanielStraight 17y agoI don't see how there's much you can do. It is probably impossible to go a day without breaking a law unknowingly. The law is so big that it is impossible for a single person to know all of it. In other words, even if you did nothing all day but study law, you could end up unknowingly breaking a law and going to jail. The problem is with the law, not with people.
- pyre 17y ago> The law is so big that it is impossible for a single person to know all of it. You're also forgetting case-law here too. It's possible for someone to read all of the laws on the books, but not realize what the current interpretation by the courts of those laws is (or will be).
- noonespecial 17y agoI think the opposite is true here. Inspector Javer will always make it his career and his life to chase Jean Valjean. It doesn't matter whether there's 5 laws or 50000. There are certain people in the world like this. There always have been. Unfortunately, they seem to be drawn to law enforcement. The best any system can hope for is to minimize their impact. I do agree that our current system does a very poor job of it.
- isamuel 17y agoAnd that's why you should never talk to the police. Really. Ever. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4097602514885833865 http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4097602514885833865 http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/07/why_you_should.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/07/why_you_should...
- cschneid 17y agoWhile excellent advice, that's not the issue that the article is talking about. You can be the most silent, rights knowledgeable person and still get screwed by Federal law. I'm currently reading a book titled "Three Felonies a Day" which details how the federal criminal system is broken. The book itself unfortunately is a series of anecdotes, rather than a deeper analysis of how we got to this situation. If you can find it at the library, I recommend skimming a few of the stories to get a feel for what's going on. I'm obviously not a lawyer, but as far as I understand, federal law does not require a "guilty mind" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea), at least not to the same degree that traditional state law requires. In addition, many federal crimes are written very vaguely, sometimes to good effect (handling unforeseen criminal acts, obviously wrong, but not specifically banned by law), but more often to ill effect (yeah, that's fraud!). Then, finally, there is the issue of the approach federal prosecutors take in pursuing cases, in which the push for convictions is more important than the push for justice. This results in approaches to cases such as "ladder climbing", where you indict the lower rungs of an organization (mayor's aids for example) with the threat of years of jail, and have them plea bargain out to almost nothing in exchange to testify against the person above them. Often, the choice for the person being accused is so obviously one sided that they'll creatively spin their testimony so that innocent behavior suddenly because "fraud" or "obstruction of justice" or similarly vague crimes. One more sneaky thing that federal prosecutors do is that certain things are crimes, even where not obvious. For instance, lying under oath is obviously a crime (perjury). Lying to a federal officer while not under oath is also a crime (a felony no less). So basically, federal prosecutors can pin very serious crimes on almost anybody they wish, as this article pointed out with import/export restrictions about flowers.
- wheels 17y agoThis was killed the last time it was here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=722676 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=722676 That time via Fox News: http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2009/07/21/heritage-house-law/ http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2009/07/21/heritage-house-law... They're essentially identical and both written by the same partisan think tank dude.
- blasdel 17y agoAnd this one's in the Washington Times -- the shittiest partisan rag in the country, run at a massive loss by the Moonies. Whoever's funding this set of talking points clearly wants to push deregulation of some sort using it as pretext.
- electronslave 17y agoObligatory comment: keep the right-wing news off of HN, please. Scare quotes don't mean it's important.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI had a high-ranking local police official tell me over 30 years ago that there were so many laws that the police could basically control whoever they wanted by selective enforcement of the legal code. Of course that wouldn't work for a rich or famous person -- the cops would be embarrassed -- but for the rest of us we've been in a situation for many decades where there are so many laws that we're basically in a police state. The only reason more folks don't rise up is that so far, mostly, it's a benevolent dictatorship. I love the analogy between code and the law, because it's so true. We in the IT industry have a unique insight into how complex systems are created and maintained. Our current legal system is way out of whack. But politicians get elected for doing something -- and that means spending money, passing laws, or fighting wars. That's about all the options they have. So the system continues to spend more and more money, create more and more complex laws, and we end up with "wars" on poverty, drugs, and carbon emissions. All laws should have an expiration date.
- tc 17y agoOf course that wouldn't work for a rich or famous person Martha Stewart might disagree. In many ways, the rich and famous actually make perfect targets. Prosecutors and politicians can stir up some of the general contempt that many people still quietly harbor against the wealthy. It can be a great way for a budding prosecutor to break into higher office (c.f. Eliot Spitzer). Your observations are otherwise completely sound.
- jonny_noog 17y agoYeah, and in many ways, they don't make perfect targets. In the case of Martha Stewart, it seems she only got taken down because there were vested interests more powerful than her interested in that goal. I agree that rich/famous people certainly can make a good target, but whether a particular rich/famous person will make a good target depends on the power to which that individual has access to, obviously. Money talks, regardless of how many people hate you for having it. I would suggest that the amount of wealth an individual has access to would be a far more accurate predictor of whether that individual will be taken down in court as opposed to celebrity. It just so happens that many famous people are also wealthy. Sure there's always going to be exceptions, but you can't seriously be suggesting that rich/famous people in general make perfect targets in court? I'm thinking a famous, yet poor person might be the best kind of target.
- TravisLS 17y agoConsidering how much trouble people have navigating even the simplest computer interfaces, sometimes I wonder how anyone could possibly understand all of the laws that impact their daily lives.
- Adam503 17y agoThe Washington Times is owned by Rev. Moon.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]