3 ms·
Given the article is from 2011, but did this: > and the evidence suggests that it is to that that we owe the collapse of oppressive regimes throughout the Midd
by TheSpiceIsLife 12y ago
Given the article is from 2011, but did this:
> and the evidence suggests that it is to that that we owe the collapse of oppressive regimes throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa
actually happen? I mean to say: Sure, oppressive regimes collapsed, but to be replaced with what? Take the 'Arab Spring' countries Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Yemen - are they better off for having traded security and stability for (attempted) democracy.
> Google, of course, wants to solve these problems too. But it has a different, less-democratic approach in mind.
No company is a Democracy in the sense of dēmos 'the people' + kratia 'power, rule', where 'the people' are you, me and the next person. Maybe companies are democracies where 'the people' are the shareholders, at least to some extent, for some definitions of 'shareholder'.
Often we see "The Democratisation of x" bandied about as though it has to be a good thing, but I'm left wondering what the term actually means if the consequences are typically a tradeoff between security + stability vs. democracy.
From what I've seen the media has portrayed Twitter, Facebook, YouTube (etc.) as playing a role in the Arab Spring demonstrations, yet these are exactly the sort of 'unaccountable intermediary' you're railing against.
I think the reference to the Arab Spring without qualifying the consequences of the whole scenario from the vantage point of history is dishonest.
Democracy isn't synonymous with Security and Stability, and we should all probably have a long hard think about Security and Stability before we promote disruption.
(Edit: fixed a thing where I'd written the opposite of what I meant).
- kragen 12y agoI wrote the article you're calling "dishonest" in 2011. The Syrian civil war was still mostly Assad bombing his citizens. It would not have been possible for me to "qualify[] the consequences of the whole scenario from the vantage point of history" in a document written before that history happened. I agree that Egypt, Libya, and Yemen (and also Syria and Bahrain) are worse off now than before the Arab Spring. I agree that companies aren't democratic. I think that's a good reason not to hand our government to companies. Historically I don't think there is a tradeoff between security and stability versus democracy. http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-faq/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-fa... goes into some detail about the unstable, insecure history of undemocratic governments, specifically to rebut neoreactionaries who are calling for an end to democracy in order to return to an illusory imagined past of security and stability. Democracies usually don't make very good decisions. They do seem to make many fewer catastrophic decisions than non-democracies, though.