4 ms·
It may have been an intentional leak, so "meant to be shared" even if the "confidential & proprietary" labels say otherwise. But also, why would Uber's desire-
by gojomo 12y ago
It may have been an intentional leak, so "meant to be shared" even if the "confidential & proprietary" labels say otherwise.
But also, why would Uber's desire-for-secrecy be given much weight? They're not a private individual that can be embarrassed. I haven't seen anyone intimate that this info is either false or damaging to them in any way. (And if, hypothetically, it were a leak that was true and changes outsiders' behavior enough to harm Uber, that might itself make the case for its release. Uber is a big force affecting a lot of employees and markets – a prominent 'public figure'. Its many counterparties amongst the public want and arguably deserve the best obtainable info about it.)
The sense that "it seems sleazy" thus looks to me like a case of over-anthropomorphizing Uber itself, and thus granting it empathy which it is not due. Even if we think it a useful legal fiction to grant companies all the legal rights of persons, that doesn't mean they deserve all human courtesies, too. (Of course, if the leak were primarily about actual people, and especially if it was using dubious gossip to damage them, then a stricter standard would apply.)
- philwelch 12y agoThere's a fairness argument to be made; Uber is a business and has to make deals in order to carry out its business, be they investments, procurement (they buy a lot of smartphones), commercial real estate, etc. If Uber's internal finances are leaked but the internal finances of their current or potential future business partners aren't, that harms their negotiating position. Journalists shouldn't be stepping in and giving Apple or some local landlord a better negotiation position with Uber by showing them Uber's cards, so to speak. It violates the principle of impartiality.
- rhizome 12y agoIn that case/context, why would a journalist be obligated to consider Uber's business needs at all?
- philwelch 12y agoBecause journalists shouldn't give some businesses advantages in negotiating position over other businesses. If Uber is negotiating with Apple to buy thousands of iPhones, and the press leaks Uber's internal financial data but not Apple's, the press has given Apple an unfair advantage.