8 ms·
Why I do not want to work at Google (2011)
- freedom123 12y agoI agree with you 100%. The struggle however is your good ideas are not popular... Best stated by "Woe to him who teaches men faster than they can learn."
- steven777400 12y agoMaybe tag with (2011)? It's possible some of the institutional issues have changed in the past couple years.
- kragen 12y agoWell, they have changed, but they've changed for the worse. Google has gradually been succumbing to the pressures I identified in that post; witness the move of Android to put gradually more services into proprietary Google Play Services, the ban on disconnect.me, the years-long struggle over pseudonymity on Google+ (finally resolved for the best), the ugly debasement of search results to drive traffic to Google+, the ban on non-Chrome browsers accessing Hangouts, the abandonment of XMPP compatibility by deceptively pressuring Google Chat users to move to Hangouts instead, and so on. These are by no means crimes, but they're more evil than the things Google would have done in 2008 or 2009, and they're certainly not moving the internet in the direction I want to see it move in.
- abraham 12y ago> the ban on non-Chrome browsers accessing Hangouts What do you mean by this? The documentation lists support for Chrome, IE, Firefox, and Safari. https://support.google.com/plus/answer/1216376 https://support.google.com/plus/answer/1216376
- SafdarIqbal 12y agoThere is no way to get notifications if you're using Firefox or Safari.
- abraham 12y agoA missing feature != ban. Plus I'm pretty sure you are wrong. "This setting applies to all Hangouts notifications from Gmail, Google+ and the Chrome extension on the same desktop computer." Gmail and Google+ are both supported in all major browsers. https://support.google.com/hangouts/answer/3111923 https://support.google.com/hangouts/answer/3111923
- kragen 12y agoI haven't tried using Hangouts lately, so maybe it's been fixed. It got broken back in August; http://robert.ocallahan.org/2014/08/choose-firefox-now-or-later-you-wont.html?showComment=1407817453520#c5518384044027599177 http://robert.ocallahan.org/2014/08/choose-firefox-now-or-la... explains: "I can understand asking why Hangouts doesn't work in Firefox. In short, we wanted to transition to WebRTC sooner rather than later, and at the moment there are things holding us back on both our side (e.g. upgrading our ICE implementation) and the Firefox side (e.g. supporting multiple video streams). "But overall, surely you're not arguing that transitioning a major Google application from a proprietary plugin to an open web standard somehow demonstrates that Chrome doesn't value web standards."
- azakai 12y agoIt doesn't look like it was fixed. I tried: 1. Go to http://www.google.com/hangouts/ http://www.google.com/hangouts/ 2. Click "get hangouts" 3. Click "computers" Result is "You'll need to download Chrome before installing the Hangouts Chrome extension. Do you want to download Chrome now?" edit: I think i remember being told on twitter that this was a confusing UI that would be changed. But that was several months ago.
- magicalist 12y agoI think the "confusing UI" thing becomes apparent if you click and try it. By hangouts on "computers" they mean as a desktop-installed app (which is just a wrapper around a Chrome app). I don't know why you'd want that (basically just a bookmark on your desktop?) but that's what it is. If, however, you just start a hangout inside of gmail, it works fine in Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and IE (just hung out with myself on two computers in multiple browsers to test that out) and there was never a time that was broken, contrary to the GP post.
- azakai 12y agoWell, when you click "get hangouts" the options are "Android, iOS or Computers". So anyone that wants to run it on anything but a smartphone gets told that it can only run on Chrome. I don't see it mention anything about an app as opposed to running in a browser. Perhaps this is just a confusing UI, but if so, it would be very easy to fix. If that's the case, I'm puzzled why it hasn't been fixed.
- yuhong 12y agoOf those, the Google+ one is my favorite and I am glad Vic Gundotra got fired.
- joshuacc 12y ago> the ban on non-Chrome browsers accessing Hangouts There is no such ban. I've been using Hangouts with FireFox and IE for months. If you attempt to access a Hangouts url with FireFox, for example, it prompts you to install a FireFox plugin.
- nowarninglabel 12y agoPrevious discussion from the last time this was posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2933619 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2933619
- kragen 12y agoMuch of that discussion was excellent, although some of it missed the point. I'll try to keep tabs on this thread and answer any questions people may have today.
- byoogle 12y ago> Google [will] delete your account with no recourse if you admit you’re only 10. The US gov is mostly responsible here, not Google: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Protection_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Pro...
- pekk 12y agoThat act was passed by elected officials
- mempko 12y agoAnd google pays for lobbying. Interesting that most bills are written by private companies. I wonder what bills google wrote and gave to these "elected" officials. Google isn't paying millions in lobbying for nothing.
- MBlume 12y agoBet you $100 that if Google lobbied about that bill, they lobbied against it.
- schoen 12y agoThe bill was enacted less than seven weeks after Google was founded, at a time when users couldn't sign in to Google at all. (The Senate had approved it less than a month after Google was founded.) It's somewhat hard to believe that they had a lobbyist working on the issue in the company's first month of existence.
- sgt101 12y agoA serious point here: warehouse scale computing beats p2p in a dsl (or even feasible fttp) environments. Essentially the model of the internet we have is broadcast with decoration from the upstream channel. To change this services using upstream that make money for the pipe providers are required. Otherwise, no upstream. Freeloading cannot work. Repeat CANNOT. Because you need fellas with highschool educations to look after the fibre and the boxes. Downstream will remove the boxes and put them into warehouse scale facilities. So - Haxxors, get yourselves to the internet of things if you wish to see democracy preserved. Freedom is in peril. Defend it with all your might.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoWhy do you think that for FTTP? I do see the problem with ADSL as it is currently implemented (as analyzed very well by kragen in the mail linked to in a sibling post to this), but why would the same problem apply to FTTP? Also, I don't get how you get to freeloading - upstream bandwidth is as much part of the product that the customer is paying for as the downstream bandwidth is.
- sgt101 12y agoDownstream bandwidth is mostly delivered using caches. Upstream bandwidth is not delivered using caches. So to provide the backhaul for upstream bandwidth we will do deep reach into the datacentre <-> home and interconnect in the data centre. Therefore fttp will not provide p2p connectivity unless there is a need for local connectivity because deepreach and datacentre networking is rendered non viable by sheer traffic volume. But the traffic will need to be geographically localised and/or the services will have to provide the economic support for backhaul uplift. I think we can probably do petabits on single mode fibre bundles now with the right boxes but the trick is the right boxes, which are spensive and take lots of electricity to run. So even if you can pony up for an FTTP roll out then the use cases are going to be constrained by the network architecture that is used to support it. Now, for most people this is not a problem as the up channel is basically irrelevant in terms of bandwidth in the current consumer internet, but if you are the sort of person who imagines a decentralised and democratic consumer internet which is not mediated by massive supernational companies, or if you are the sort of person who is interested in where the value is captured in the industry value chain I think this does matter. Sharing other peoples content will not fund a democratic internet even if governments fund and regulate fttp. We need a new class of applications that generate revenue sufficient to pay for the infrastructure that will facilitate them. If we get that then the infrastructure will also facilitate a shift away from the data centre (not it's elimination though as it will be the way that the current usecases are delivered) If you have any ideas please write them up - before the industry dies!
- mszyndel 12y agoThe problem is, all of those guys who were so free in the nineties failed to create any noteworthy online services so Facebook, Google, etc. took up the space. I'm gonna get down voted for that, but maybe if there were less nerd-wars in FOSS community and more thinking about real users the Internet would look differently nowadays.
- fidotron 12y agoIt's a question of timing. We did have social networks in the 90s, but the devices at the edge weren't strong enough to make them compelling, particularly as regards photos. If you rolled back to the 90s you'd also notice AOL were regarded as a giant invincible behemoth in a similar position to Facebook or Google today.
- kragen 12y agoI don't think it's true that we failed to create any noteworthy online services. We built the internet. Maybe you've heard of it. We also created TCP, UDP, IP, DNS, email, the Web, Usenet, IRC, Git, BitTorrent, Tor, Bitcoin, and Wikipedia. We killed AOL, CompuServe, Encyclopedia Britannica, Solaris, the Information Superhighway, and the Advanced Intelligent Network. We were only unable to do smartphones because the carriers ruthlessly shut us out, demanding insane amounts of control over handset software and using their regulatory capture of the FCC as leverage, until Apple forced the doors open for us — but on Apple's terms. And we built most of the software that runs Apple, Facebook, and Google, too. But how can we build new services to replace Facebook and Google on a decentralized basis, like email and the Web? That's a problem with both technical aspects — how can you build a distributed full-text query processor that runs on the machines of volunteers? — and social/business aspects — how can the people who benefit from these services effectively collaborate to get them created and improved? (Kickstarter and the like show a very promising direction for this.) Those are the problems I want to be working on, not how to persuade Google Drive users to entrust a well-intentioned but unaccountable central authority with all of their family photos.
- mszyndel 12y agoI;m not diminishing achievements you mentioned and I'm very well aware of them. You must admit however that not all of them can be attributed to FOSS, and all of them are quite low-level compared to what average user needs to be able to use it effectively. I just wonder if we need 10 major Linux distros none of which is easy to set up and use to an average user. (sorry, even Ubuntu is still not there) I am a big believer in open web and it makes me cringe every time I see a new cool technology that uses closed protocols (or rather APIs) as it happens with IoT right now. But it's hard for me to attribute it to anything else than lack of leadership from FOSS community.
- mrb 12y ago(Full disclosure: I work for Google. My opinion does not necessarily represent my employer's opinion, yadi yada.) This guy's rant is really about the need for decentralization. I fully agree with him. But I disagree that decentralization is incompatible with Google's primary business model (regardless if the Internet is decentralized, there will always be ways to do advertising.) In fact Google Wave (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Wave http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Wave) was a fantastic and radical attempt at decentralizing common use cases such as email, instant messaging, social networking, etc. Unfortunately this project failed to gain traction due to various reasons. To return to a more decentralized Internet, we need software and network protocols that let people easily host their mail and blog, publish their social pages, and share their vacation pictures, etc, without relying on the cloud but doing it via a device that runs at home. An ideal place to run this software would be your Internet router, as it really is a full-blown computer that is always on, always connected. And, as the router, it conveniently bypasses the issue of masquerading/NATing which is the one reason why non-technical people do not run server software more often. Another advantage is that uploading stuff to your Internet router (eg. sharing pictures) is much, much faster than uploading them to a cloud service (Wifi or Ethernet bandwidth can be 50x-1000x faster than the typical upload bandwidth of a home Internet connection.) It should all work out of the box with zero configuration. That is the only way the idea can gain traction. Not everybody is a sysadmin, so your grandmother should be able to make it work. Want to enable your mailbox? Just tick the appropriate checkbox on your Internet router as easily as you would sign up for some mail provider. Want to follow the social lives of your friends? Your browser can render your custom Facebook-style wall by pulling posts and pictures feeds directly from your friends' Internet routers. We already have most of the technologies needed to implement such decentralized features: HTTP with cross-origin resource sharing, SMTP, automatic registration of DNS names to make you discoverable on the net, OpenID authentication, etc. Maybe some other needed bits can be pulled from the Wave protocol. But the sad thing is that I am not aware of any attempt to implement any of what I described above. Perhaps it is a vision too ahead of its time. Or perhaps it is because there are 2 important problems that are very hard to solve in a fully decentralized way: (1) search, and (2) spam. You can easily search for and find your friend's blog via Google web search because it has an index of the entire web, but how do you provide this level of quality if the search engine is your Internet router? As to spam, you can easily filter email if you are the Gmail team running sophisticated analysis on the billions of emails processed daily because the more data you have the easier you can classify it, but how do you implement this filtering quality on an Internet router that does not have access to such a data set? Perhaps the solution is to run most of the services in a decentralized way (email, instant messaging, social networking, etc) while at the same time relying on a few central services for some features like search and spam filtering. Edit: thanks for the pointers to FreedomBox and Sandstorm, I will look into them.
- Htsthbjig 12y ago"and the evidence suggests that it is to that that we owe the collapse of oppressive regimes throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa" Never mind that those oppressive regimes got replaced by...new oppressive regimes. I beg to differ that is Internet what makes a regime fall in North Africa. What makes regimes fall is people who can't buy food going from 30% to 75% because of inflation of commodities(created by OUR WESTERN central banks). Probably you think revolution is great, but I have been in Libya and Syria, before and in the wars and it is horrible. A civil war is the worst thing that could happen to a country, Americans could idealize it as they have forgotten what a real war is(fighting against non developed enemies 8000 miles away is not alike seeing your home in flames, your daughter raped or your brothers killed). I would love to use decentralized tools, but they are so bad. They have lots of features, but they are incredible hard to use. People will start using decentralized products when they are as easy to configure and install like a mac. Only centralized tools like facebook or Google provide easy of use that my grandpa could use.
- kragen 12y agoI agree. Well said. In 2011 the new oppressive regimes had not risen yet. Even today the one in Tunisia seems better than the old one. If you are interested in more detail in what I thought about the revolution in Egypt, http://canonical.org/~kragen/egypt-massacre-sotu.html http://canonical.org/~kragen/egypt-massacre-sotu.html goes into more detail from January 2011, just after #Jan25. The situation in in Egypt is terrible today. Violent revolutions have a tendency to submerge their revolution in their violence, because violence leads to rule by the most effectively violent. Those are not the people whose rule I want to live under. I tweeted about this in May 2011, a few months before the decentralization post we're discussing, when the Syrian opposition was still mostly nonviolent: https://twitter.com/kragen/status/65789586269421568 https://twitter.com/kragen/status/65789586269421568 "@shadihamid Well, it [violent rebellion] hasn't worked out so well for the movement to overthrow Gaddafi so far, has it? Lots more dead than Bahrain or Syria."
- laxatives 12y agoThe scale of centralization is a bit overwhelming. Check out some of the things Google is hoping to get in to: http://www.google.com/ideas/projects/ http://www.google.com/ideas/projects/
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoGiven the article is from 2011, but did this: > and the evidence suggests that it is to that that we owe the collapse of oppressive regimes throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa actually happen? I mean to say: Sure, oppressive regimes collapsed, but to be replaced with what? Take the 'Arab Spring' countries Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Yemen - are they better off for having traded security and stability for (attempted) democracy. > Google, of course, wants to solve these problems too. But it has a different, less-democratic approach in mind. No company is a Democracy in the sense of dēmos 'the people' + kratia 'power, rule', where 'the people' are you, me and the next person. Maybe companies are democracies where 'the people' are the shareholders, at least to some extent, for some definitions of 'shareholder'. Often we see "The Democratisation of x" bandied about as though it has to be a good thing, but I'm left wondering what the term actually means if the consequences are typically a tradeoff between security + stability vs. democracy. From what I've seen the media has portrayed Twitter, Facebook, YouTube (etc.) as playing a role in the Arab Spring demonstrations, yet these are exactly the sort of 'unaccountable intermediary' you're railing against. I think the reference to the Arab Spring without qualifying the consequences of the whole scenario from the vantage point of history is dishonest. Democracy isn't synonymous with Security and Stability, and we should all probably have a long hard think about Security and Stability before we promote disruption. (Edit: fixed a thing where I'd written the opposite of what I meant).
- kragen 12y agoI wrote the article you're calling "dishonest" in 2011. The Syrian civil war was still mostly Assad bombing his citizens. It would not have been possible for me to "qualify[] the consequences of the whole scenario from the vantage point of history" in a document written before that history happened. I agree that Egypt, Libya, and Yemen (and also Syria and Bahrain) are worse off now than before the Arab Spring. I agree that companies aren't democratic. I think that's a good reason not to hand our government to companies. Historically I don't think there is a tradeoff between security and stability versus democracy. http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-faq/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-fa... goes into some detail about the unstable, insecure history of undemocratic governments, specifically to rebut neoreactionaries who are calling for an end to democracy in order to return to an illusory imagined past of security and stability. Democracies usually don't make very good decisions. They do seem to make many fewer catastrophic decisions than non-democracies, though.
- joev_ 12y ago> Apple wants to relegate websites to second-class status on their popular computers, and exercises viewpoint censorship on what “apps” they allow in their “app store”. I don't remember it that way all. Does anyone else? From what I remember, there was a very heavy consumer demand for the App store, meanwhile Apple was telling everyone just to make web apps. They actively developed WebKit into a cutting-edge, standards-oriented, developer-friendly browser. I don't see how you could say they wanted to "relegate websites to second-class status".
- sneak 12y agoWebsites can't send notifications on iOS, for one. (They can on Mavericks and Yosemite.)
- 0942v8653 12y agoThat's a design/ideology conflict and not something that can be fixed. On OS X, you can leave a webpage open, and it must be open in order for the notifications to be sent. On iOS, you cannot (terminated whenever there is memory pressure). Push notifications are just way beyond what a website should be able to do, and scheduled ones aren't really all that useful except for a handful of apps.
- parisidau 12y agoWeb pages do not have to be open to send notifications on OS X.
- kragen 12y agoOriginally Apple did tell everyone just to make web apps. Renegade hackers made native apps for iOS anyway, creating consumer demand, and Apple relented. All this happened before I wrote that message in 2011. By 2011 webapps were already second-class. (Not as second-class as they are on Android, though!)
- zmmmmm 12y agoThat seems to me now like it was just a ruse to buy them time. They went on to hamstrung the browser from attaining native performance and never added all the direct hardware features you could get at with apps - which is what they would have done if they really intended the browser to be an app platform.
- sneak 12y ago> My friends Len Sassaman (who committed suicide in the first few days of July), Bram Cohen, Jacob Appelbaum, and Zooko O’Whielacronx have made substantial contributions. One of these things is not like the others. Three of these people have made significant contributions, in code. One of them has talked a lot and claimed the work of others as their own.
- Patrick_Devine 12y agoMy startup has been trying to make decentralized computing easy, but I'm just not sure there's a huge market for it. We took OpenStack and made it so you could connect nodes from anywhere on the net and rent them out, whether it was a server in a datacenter or even someone's desktop machine. I'm just not sure there's a huge demand for it though; originally we were thinking that people would care about price, but it turns out most companies don't care that they're being fleeced by AWS. If they do care, they're probably using DO. Anyway, here's a demo of everything working: http://youtu.be/998IYD_WomY http://youtu.be/998IYD_WomY It connects a bunch of desktop machines around the Bay Area on different networks (Comcast, Sonic.net) and blends them in with a "dataceter grade" cloud server. The real problem with decentralization though is that the asymmetric nature of the first (last?) mile makes it really hard to do anything useful with individual nodes. If we all had symmetrical gigE FttH/FttP everything would be a lot more rosy, but so far that's really only been happening in a few places.
- kragen 12y agoI'm not sure that's "decentralization" in the sense that I mean. A "decentralized" system, to me, is one where no single person or group of people can deny others access to it, for example by deleting their accounts or turning the system off. Decentralized systems allow distributed innovation more robustly than centralized or merely distributed systems, and so they tend to outcompete centralized and distributed systems when they clash economically. I haven't watched your video, though.
- Patrick_Devine 12y agoYes, it's only part of a solution. It's a decentralized platform, and what you're asking for are truly decentralized applications. The platform can potentially enable decentralized applications while letting you manage them in a centralized way. I'm just not sure about your economics argument though; convenience usually trumps any kind of economic reason for using a distributed system over a centralized one. This is particularly so with most internet services because the cost for most things always approaches free. I mean, we're reading HN on a website, and not through alt.hackernews, right?
- spiritplumber 12y agoI don't want to work at Google because a Google project manager told me to my face that my product didn't exist. So I wrapped his hand around it. It was a PCB with a lot of through-hole pointy bits, so it hurt him a satisfactory amount. I wouldn't work at a company that hires people who deny basic reality, so that works out.
- Immortalin 12y agoOne reason why companies would rather get fleeced by aws etc. is that hosting your own server is both troublesome and expensive. This isnt much of a problem if you live in the temperate region but it is a HUGE problem if you live near the equator. Temperator can easily rise up to 33 degrees centigrade and beyond and maintaining a server without round-the-clock cooling in an air-conditioned room is close to impossible(unless your server is a single raspberry pi). That's why people would rather pay for Iaas services, sometimes it is simply cheaper for someone else to host it.
- rwallace 12y agoBloody hell, talk about rose-colored glasses. No, back in the nineties, you could not do any of the things he talks about. Not unless you were a high-status employee of a handful of major corporations or universities. Most people couldn't get online at all, and those who could were lucky to have client-only access to e-mail and the web. Nowadays, anyone with a credit card and an Amazon account can set up an always-online server running pretty much any software they choose. The Internet is far more decentralized, by the criteria he invokes, then it was back then.
- dasil003 12y agoHe never said it was cheap and accessible, what he said was that it was decentralized. In other words, no one could stop you from doing any of those things, the fact that it was harder to get online is beside the point. The vast majority of services were running open protocols, and there were really no gatekeepers except for DNS I suppose, but even that is a decentralized protocol even if the registry is centralized by necessity.
- kragen 12y agoYour experience may have been limited, although I am not going to claim that mine was typical. As I explained in the article, I did the things I talked about (running online services, including email and web pages, accessible from the entire internet) with a US$20/month dialup internet account on an ISP run by a group of MUDders who ran the ISP as a way to play MUDs, starting in 1997. I installed my first web server (from EIT's Webmaster's Starter Kit) temporarily on an IRIX workstation in a university computer lab, in 1994. I was an undergraduate student at UNM, a state university in the second-poorest state in the US, although I admit UNM was unusually progressive. The year before, I was an unpaid student system administration intern, with a user account on all the Suns at the math department, assigned tasks like "please get tvtwm to compile on SunOS 4.1.4; Prof X wants to use it". I agree that it's pretty awesome that anyone who wants to pay Amazon or DigitalOcean US$5 a month (and can get access to a credit card they'll accept) can run any internet-facing server software they want. Unless they're WikiLeaks, say. Or infringing on an invalid Amazon software patent. Or just want to not have random employees have hardware access to their machine for reasons of security and privacy. So I don't think the internet is far more decentralized. It's bigger, which is pretty great, and it's a lot cheaper, which is even better, but it's also more centralized.
- pmoriarty 12y agoBecause Google makes its money by spying on its users. It's also an advertising company, which means it brainwashes and deceives people in to buying garbage. Both activities are unethical, and I wouldn't want anything to do with ether.
- notacoward 12y agoMaybe if Google actually open-sourced as much software as they consume, that would offer a way out. Some people would still want to run the centralized as-a-service tools because it's on a huge professionally-run infrastructure and because of network effects. Others might want to run the same services locally, to support privacy/decentralization goals like the OP's. Google's main revenue stream (ads) shouldn't be affected, and they'd even benefit from outside contributions. So why don't they do this? Because of the difference between "shouldn't" and "wouldn't" at the end of the last paragraph. What if code to support ads - or other invasions of privacy - were embedded into every other thing they might open source? Then the sheer difficulty of refactoring to "sanitize" everything else would probably create a sufficient barrier to opening it up, and revealing how all of that ad infrastructure really works might hurt their business in other ways. When Google continues to run as the new AOL (closed source, walled garden) I don't think it's part of a deliberate philosophy. Nor is it an accident. It's because their continued uber-prosperity, if not their actual survival, depends on it.
- kragen 12y agoI don't think it has to be that extreme. They do have a corporate culture of extreme secrecy, which I think comes from growing up in the shadow of Microsoft, Yahoo, and other much bigger companies. But I don't think their survival or even prosperity depends on secrecy any more. However, it's deeply embedded in their corporate culture, and I think it's actually spreading to other Silicon Valley companies. There is an issue of incentives, but I don't think it's as strong as you think. I think it's just that running services makes them money, while releasing open-source software doesn't, so they devote lots of effort to running services, and comparatively little to releasing open-source software. It would be very challenging for them to open-source "as much software as they consume." That would be a many-billions-of-dollars effort. But it wouldn't be necessary — the great thing about software is that you can copy it, so even if you only release a tiny fraction of the amount of software as you "consume", everyone still benefits.