5 ms·
The unfortunate reality is that there are no INTELLECTUALLY gifted and talented students in most schools. There are only slightly more who are musically or oth
by bilbo0s 17y ago
The unfortunate reality is that there are no INTELLECTUALLY gifted and talented students in most schools. There are only slightly more who are musically or otherwise artistically gifted and talented. Truly gifted students should be moved to schools specifically catering to their needs. As there are so few of these students nationally, it would need to be a boarding school in my opinion.
The students being discussed in this article and in the response are just AP. Not gifted. We throw that word around too much, and it has come to mean nothing now.
- tokenadult 17y agoAs there are so few of these students nationally This seems to imply a definition. What definition are you talking about here? What is the source for the definition and the estimate of the frequency of such students? P.S. As a point of information, I will mention that I have one child in the Davidson Institute for Talent Development Young Scholars program, http://www.davidsongifted.org/youngscholars/ http://www.davidsongifted.org/youngscholars/ which has its particular definition of eligible students. To the best of my knowledge and belief, a typical school district in Minnesota (where school districts are considerably smaller than counties, unlike Maryland) has no more than one or two students who have gone through the enrollment steps for the Davidson Institute Young Scholars program. How many theoretically eligible young persons any one place has is unknown, as far as I know.
- asmithmd1 17y agoHere is a place that has a good definition. http://cty.jhu.edu/ http://cty.jhu.edu/ They have 7th graders who test at 95% percentile or above take the regular SATs - not PSATs - and those 7th graders who are above the average for college bound high school seniors obviously need something besides normal high school. They define kids that score above 700 on math or verbal SAT before they are 13 as truly gifted.
- tokenadult 17y agothose 7th graders who are above the average for college bound high school seniors obviously need something besides normal high school Yes. Those middle-school-age young people who take Talent Search testing through Northwestern University's Midwest Academic Talent Search http://www.ctd.northwestern.edu/numats/ http://www.ctd.northwestern.edu/numats/ receive a booklet of academic planning advice after receiving their scores. Many of the specific points of that advice are impossible to implement in most states in the Midwest.
- briansmith 17y agoWho pays for it?
- asmithmd1 17y agoI agree "he scored in the 92nd percentile on the PSAT" - seems like a rather ordinary genius to me. At 92% percentile he is smarter than 11 out of 12 kids in his grade. Maybe the school should just tell his parents - chill, your kid is not all that.
- mmt 17y agoI was fortunate that, when I was of school age, I absolutely adored standardized tests. Something about them tickled a compulsive, pattern-recognition part of my brain, linked to delight. I scored extremely well. Recently, however, I find that taking multiple-guess tests or evaluations seems much more like the waste of time that it is. I still get some pleasure from a few questions, but, like Mr. Owl, I get bored after 3 licks. Not all gifted students are good at standardized tests, possibly because they can't be bothered to care enough to pay attention to something so trivially easy. All that said, I think the student in the OP is foolish for trying to insist he have the experience of being a part of a system while, at the same time, receiving exceptional treatment from that same system. Any stifling is self-inflicted.