4 ms·
If what she reports is how things developed, I think things look bleak for public discourse. It's as if we'll all have to censor our thoughts before pronouncin
by mc32 12y ago
If what she reports is how things developed, I think things look bleak for public discourse. It's as if we'll all have to censor our thoughts before pronouncing them. Sure, we can learn to think before we speak and have a lot of internal monologues, but, in the end it's the same. We internalize the thoughts and process them internally without being able to think out loud.
I think it's a shame one cannot think out loud for fear things will be taken literally. Yes, we can mask things by 'anonymizing' the conversations, so instead of using a real person as an example, just say someone or 'journalists'. but it's a shame people's dinner conversations or even pub conversations will be taken as their official edicts and sanctioned pronouncements --when lots of times there is boasting, bravado, nervousness and other times there are threats and other unsavory conduct. However, it's unfair to see it all as the latter kind.
- alexqgb 12y agoIt's as if we'll all have to censor our thoughts before pronouncing them. You know, this really isn't a problem for people who don't have thoughts about silencing critics by intimidating their families.
- nailer 12y agoFrom the previous discussion PandoDaily is a ValleyWag-type gossip site. If someone was writing about your own personal relationships, would you ever think you "might be justified" in doing the same?
- selmnoo 12y agoWhat do you mean "ValleyWag-type gossip site"? ValleyWag was actually calling out Valley companies for the misogynistic shit they should be called out for, while everyone else was sitting quietly on the side.
- mc32 12y agoI can't speak for the OP. What I think the OP is saying is that some outlets thrive on being sensational --one thrives on Hollywood sensationalism, this one may thrive on valley sensationalism --it just so happens to coincide with a social issue in this case, but that may just be coincidental --that is, do they take on all social issues whether they drive page views or not, whether they create outrage or not? In other words, they both serve their own brand of red meat to their audiences.
- alexqgb 12y agoI'm sorry nailer, but do you honestly think that what you've just proposed proposed is an accurate reflection of the situation with Pando and Uber? Because there's a world of difference between journalists reporting on companies under clear bylines, and companies attempting to silence journalists through acts of personal intimidation that have their precise origins concealed. Forget apples to oranges. What you're describing is (possibly rotten) apples to hand grenades. But since you asked, no, I wouldn't dream of behaving this way. If a reporter published something demonstrably false, I'd demand a correction. If the pattern persisted, I'd take them to court. You know, like a civilized human being, not some goddamned Mafioso or a member of the KGB.
- mc32 12y agoIf that's what is was, yes, i'd be a problem. But it appears, from this witness, it was not. So let's suppose this witness is a good witness. In some cultures it's natural to only say things out loud that one has thought of 'thoughtfully'. In others you say a lot out loud but without meaning much. Just imagine a conversation between two sorority sisters or two fraternity brothers. They can have some pretty horrible things they say about other people --it's quite disgusting; I've overheard them. Would it be fair to bring those conversations up later in life, or as they're being considered for a job? should those conversations be "wrong"? I'd rather people be free to have all kinds of nasty thoughts --but provide disincentive upon acting them out --not just thinking them. Another question. Now, let's say said reporter might say something under her breath to confidants. Let's suppose she's happy to see some unraveling, and let's suppose the reporter/journalist even says some hyperbolic things --should such a reporter now be attacked for expressing such feelings? People are people and I think should be free to feel enmity against others --we can't pretend we like everyone out there.
- thesteamboat 12y ago> Just imagine a conversation between two sorority sisters or two fraternity brothers. They can have some pretty horrible things they say about other people --it's quite disgusting; I've overheard them. Would it be fair to bring those conversations up later in life, or as they're being considered for a job? should those conversations be "wrong"? I think it's fair to judge the conversants to the extent you think it provides information about their current character. If it was a conversation years ago, well people change. If someone can't keep themselves from maliciously gossiping a week ago, then I might be reluctant to work with them. N.B. I'm solely responding to your hypothetical here, rather than the uber situation, for I don't think your analogy fits well.
- mc32 12y agoIt may or may, not, I think. The reason I say that is that in some specific social situations it's expected/acceptable to say some outrageous things which the speaker(s) do(es)n't actually believe in. It's part of people's bonding 'rituals'. When you're with your friend(s) you may say something which if published could put you in bad light. If that were not the case, I'd be afraid that university campuses or company water-coolers are overrun by psychopaths. We cannot take people literally at all occasions. I'm afraid I cannot trust people who have an interest (whether it be page views or even a social cause, etc.) to discern the situation in a disinterested way. The dynamics are too complicated. Unfortunately it ends up being a situation where we have multiple interpretations of something. For example, I might say "I'm very happy for you" to someone, they may retort "no, you are not, you are just saying that". Who's right?
- zorpner 12y agoIt's as if we'll all have to censor our thoughts before pronouncing them. Thinking about the consequences of your speech before speaking aloud is almost literally the least people can do as a part of society. No one except the absurdly privileged could think that they somehow have any kind of right to consequence-free speech.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agoThis does not seem to be a situation where purely hypothetical comments were taken out of context, but rather one where someone is being criticized for what serious hypotheticals revealed about their through process and beliefs. Yes, it's fair to criticize someone for what they think and believe, or what their comments, taken in context, indicate about what they think and believe.
- alexqgb 12y agoAs Ben Johnson so famously said "Language most shows a man, speak that I may see thee."
- king_jester 12y ago> but it's a shame people's dinner conversations or even pub conversations will be taken as their official edicts and sanctioned pronouncements --when lots of times there is boasting, bravado, nervousness and other times there are threats and other unsavory conduct. Here's the thing. As someone who hears that conversation, I can't tell if you are just running your mouth or serious. Moreover, for someone who could feel unsafe in a space because of that, they can't tell if they really are safe or not. Lastly, if things like gamer gate show us anything, there are a whole host of people who will act on what you say when they hear it and hearing those things reaffirms their worldview and actions. Making idle jokes or claims about harassing a someone isn't appropriate.