6 ms·
The Cat Went Over Radioactive Mountain
- jgeorge 12y agoA good page with discussion of how to built a 10,000 year warning monument is at http://www.wipp.energy.gov/picsprog/articles/wipp%20exhibit%20message%20to%2012,000%20a_d.htm http://www.wipp.energy.gov/picsprog/articles/wipp%20exhibit%... - I remember seeing this link a while ago and it's creepily interesting, it's a collection of ideas on how to mark Yucca Mountain for the long haul.
- lavitt 12y agoAn episode of the podcast 99 Percent Invisible is about this. They talk more about how you would communicate what this place is 10,000 years in the future, however. http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ten-thousand-years/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ten-thousand-years/ really good, nonetheless.
- chowyuncat 12y agoThe disagreement about universal iconography in that episode is great. I think Carl Sagan's idea was immediately shot down.
- trhway 12y agojust dump the nuclear waste into the Sun (Sun's gravitation will even do the most part of the job once the cargo is out of Earth's gravitational well). If in the next couple hundred years we wouldn't come up with easy means of interplanetary travel inside Solar system this civilization will be facing much more serious issues than how to communicate into 10000 years future about that nuclear waste. They gathered $30B dollars into the fund - would be enough to build an electrically driven cargo catapult/gun to throw cargo from Earth's surface into the orbit.
- jwilliams 12y agoBecause launches have a probability of exploding, which would dust/litter the planet with pretty nasty debris. Getting to the Sun isn't actually that easy. You also need to counter Earth's orbital velocity. That's takes a lot of energy - a lot more than leaving the solar system. It would be easier to fling it into interstellar space than to get to the Sun.
- trhway 12y ago>Because launches have a probability of exploding, which would dust/litter the planet with pretty nasty debris. it is chemical rockets what explode. The rail/gun systems my potentially have crashes, and the cargo shells designed to sustain 5000g acceleration should go through crashes just fine. Anyway, it willn't be like an atomic explosion, and we did have a share of it :) >It would be easier to fling it into interstellar space than to get to the Sun. nope. The Sun's escape velocity from Earth's orbit is 42km/s. While Earth's orbital speed is 30km/s, and you actually don't need the full 30km/s - Earth's gravitation escape is 11km/s, so those 11km/s pointed opposite Earth's speed will result in cargo getting "free" from Earth and having 19km/s on the Earth's orbit - that's would result in the cargo going down toward the Sun at it is obviously less than required orbital speed at the Earth's orbit of 30km/s. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_velocity#List_of_escape_velocities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_velocity#List_of_escape_...
- mikeash 12y agoYou've got some confusion there. The 11km/s escape velocity from Earth is how much the Earth's gravity slows you down as you leave it. When you reach escape velocity, it doesn't mean you leave the Earth's influence with 11km/s. It means that if you're going 11km/s near the Earth, you'll leave the Earth's influence before you fall back down. If you just barely escape, your velocity relative to the Earth will be small. What does matter is Earth's orbital speed, though. That counts towards the 42km/s you need to escape from the Sun, assuming you're smart enough to launch in the direction of the Earth's motion. That means you only need 12km/s additional velocity, whereas you need to cancel out virtually all of that 30km/s velocity to fall into the Sun.
- colinshark 12y agoSounds like Riddley Walker.
- maaku 12y agoOr, you know, we could reprocess (recycle?) the waste into much shorter lived compounds and fuel for 2nd generation breeder reactors. Then there wouldn't be a problem in the first place.
- saalweachter 12y agoYeah, I have a certain sadness regarding nuclear waste. It's dangerous, yes, but it's also one of the rarest things in the world. Trying to throw it away seems so wasteful.
- maaku 12y agoYeah it's basically an assortment of radiation sources, e.g. the things we routinely use in medicine and obscure industrial cases. The short-lived stuff could see immediate use in various contexts that need access to radioactive sources, or in RTG batteries. The long-lived stuff (plutonium, mostly) can be used as fuel in reactors that currently exist mostly on paper, but would work if there was money to build them. There isn't a radioactive waste problem. There's an anti-nuclear political problem :(
- shutupalready 12y agoA far more important issue that the article doesn't explain is why the Yucca Mountain repository was shut down. It had nothing to do with technology or safety, or even money. It was the NIMBY-mentality -- Not In My BackYard -- of a population that can't assess or compare risks[1]. I wonder which the average Joe in Nevada thinks is worse: nuclear weapons (of which Nevada has plenty and a history of unreported accidents) or Yucca? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_repository#Opposition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_re...
- derekp7 12y agoIt wasn't just Nevada -- it was any major city which would have the waste material transport through or near it. Some cities would have a couple shipments a day for months or years on end, or at least that's what the news media was reporting at the time.
- shutupalready 12y agoThat brings up another thing that the average Joe doesn't think about: that nuclear weapons are transported on unmarked trucks right along major highway routes. For all we know, a couple shipments might pass certain cities every day for months or years on end. Nuclear weapons have to be initially deployed, moved for repositioning, maintained, repaired, upgraded, and retired. All this is done in secret. If only nuclear waste had also been handled in secret, the masses would have turned their attention to protesting chemtrails or something, rather than derailing the well-thought-out Yucca plan.
- Ma8ee 12y agoYes, demokracy is a mess. Better not tell the the stupid populace about important decisions, they'll just interfere. /s
- ObviousScience 12y agoYou say that sarcastically, but isn't that the very basis of using a republican system rather than a direct democracy, and a well known problem with direct, majority-wins democracy?
- deadfall 12y agoSide note: I found out a while back that 47,500 55 gallon barrels were dumped off the California coast near the Farallon Islands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farallon_Islands#Nuclear_waste_dump http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farallon_Islands#Nuclear_waste_...
- michaelochurch 12y agoThe thing that sticks out in my mind is that no "warning" is going to allay curiosity. If technological progress continues unabated, we won't have to keep nuclear waste on the planet for 10,000 years because we'll have safe, economical ways to dispose of it in interstellar space before then. We need the 10k-year warnings to account for the situation in which our civilization declines, is forgotten, and later humans come upon it. So, let's say that it's 6500 AD and what we are now is an ancient civilization. If you come upon a sign that says something like this (from the article): This place is a message…and part of a system of messages…pay attention to it! Sending this message was important to us. We considered ourselves to be a powerful culture. This place is not a place of honor…no highly esteemed deed is commemorated here…nothing valued is here. What is here is dangerous and repulsive to us. This message is a warning about danger. What are you going to do? Some of us would avoid it, but there are others whose curiosity would lead them to explore. Think about it: a warning from a 4500-year-old advanced civilization. How does that mystery box not get opened?
- Maxious 12y agoThe ray cats might be bad as well, in the Goiânia accident, many people were exposed to the radioactive material because it's "deep blue light" glowing was curious https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident
- Ma8ee 12y agoYes, if I were a teenager and there were rumors that if you brought a black cat to the mountain it would change color, I know where I would spend my weekend. Combined with legends about horrible deaths to anyone who tried, it would be completely irresistible.
- Houshalter 12y agoThis is basically the main concern of the paper. There were all sorts of proposals, from leaving giant thorn shaped sculptures, coming up with universal symbols for death and danger, and just leaving it unmarked.
- 12y ago
- jimmcslim 12y agoThe idea that we would need to warn a civilization 10,000 years in the future to stay away seems quite fatalistic to me... what about the alternative of assuming that we do survive climate change/global thermonuclear war/comet strike/overpopulation; and the regular mechanics of bureaucracy ensure that all documentation relating to such a site is transferred onto the latest media/storage formats over the ages... so that future humanity is accessing the files off crystal holographic storage via neural links, stored in Microsoft Word 12000.
- jgh 12y agoI suppose if the second scenario is correct and the bureaucracy lasts 10,000 years into the future there's not really any harm in having developed the signage anyway. But on the other hand, if we just assume that the knowledge will be passed on via bureaucracy or some other means and don't develop the signage and then those methods of transmitting the knowledge fails, it could be bad for people in the future.
- judk 12y agoThis was covered on 99pi and discussed here earlier this year.