3 ms·
> This part, I absolutely agree with; I feel like you > just took it in sort of a weird direction. Fair enough. We all read the article that is posted at t
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
> This part, I absolutely agree with; I feel like you
> just took it in sort of a weird direction.
Fair enough. We all read the article that is posted at the top right? A long discussion about Super Smash Brothers and how all of its characters were ranked by players, and how the rank of the characters changed over a long period of time as players figured out how to play them and interact with the environment? The author of that piece used that definition of unbalanced. I just happened to like it, or resonate with it as I wrote, because in my experience playing World of Warcraft for years and years. Changes that the developers made in the character abilities, primarily it seemed to address player vs player perceptions of "balance" (which was the term the WoW developers used), made all of the characters nearly uniform in their effective capabilities. So when the WoW developers said "the character classes/races/roles are more balanced in this patch" the experience was that the game was "less interesting" to me. There was an interesting metric for that which was a characters "rotation" which was code for the sequence of commands the character would use in battle, which the more "balanced" the game became, the more uniform/boring that sequence became[1].
That said, it sounds like Guilty Gear is a lot of fun. And yes, that sort of global diversification is something I really like in a game and it keeps it interesting to me. And to your point having diverse capabilities that do not map 1:1 on the characters is part of the charm. And that is part of the charm of Super Smash Brothers which started this conversation. So after all this wonderful discussion I think we just figured out we agree with each other :-)
[1] Jokes about Paladin's having a single 'i win' key they just pounded again and again, or simplifying the user interface to three buttons, 'fight', 'farm', and 'cyberz'
- CocaKoala 12y agoRight; I think part of the confusion is that the author talks a lot about 'balance' in Smash but never actually defines what he means by it. I got the impression from the article that when he talks about "balance", he means "constant and ongoing change to reduce options which players feel are overpowered, and enhance options which players feel are underpowered". He talks about Smash being "unbalanced", and then immediately explains that it's a console game which has never been patched. He then follows up by contrasting it with LoL, and the constant state of patching that LoL exists in. Treating "balance" as a verb, rather than an adjective. That's a very different interpretation of the concept than what I'm used to thinking, and so I think you're right that we ended up talking past each other a bit and ended up at the same place anyways. Guilty Gear is a lot of fun, and if you're interested in checking it out, you're in luck! A brand new game in the series is coming out in just a few weeks (Guilty Gear Xrd, pronounced "Ecksard"), for ps3/ps4. A bunch of people are really looking forward to it and it seems like it'll be a lot of fun. It's a very different style of game from Smash, but if you like one, you may well like the other.