I completely agree with you that Lennart scratched an itch, which is the way all good software gets started, and others picked up on it. Where I think the syst

I completely agree with you that Lennart scratched an itch, which is the way all good software gets started, and others picked up on it. Where I think the systemd-naysayers have a valid point is around the tight coupling that has been introduced, and is still being introduced, between systemd and various other components of a fully functional Linux system. To take your "just submit a patch" example - say N years from now I'm unhappy with some aspect of how systemd works. I can submit a patch, or I can rewrite that whole component from scratch. However, it's entirely possible that the piece I'm unhappy with is so tightly coupled to the rest of systemd that I can't rewrite one component of it without rewriting the rest of systemd, or convincing the systemd maintainers to accept my rewrite and bake it in as the new "official" version of that component. Where I think the criticism of systemd is valid is that the idea of modularity has taken a backseat, and the APIs between the different components of systemd haven't been very well-thought-out. The informal spec is "whatever systemd does today is correct", which of course destroys any sort of interoperability. And by way of full disclosure, I'm an Arch user, and run systemd on 4 systems I use everyday - home desktop, home server, work desktop, work laptop. Whatever else I have to say about its design, I use it every day, and actually like the parts of it that I use. eg, the boot time for my desktop is stupidly fast, and if I want to know about some log message, I just run journalctl. I no longer care whether the foo daemon uses syslog, or writes to its own /var/log/foo.log that I should set up rotation for, or handles its own rotation as /var/log/foo/2014-11-20.log, and so on. And just to play devil's advocate with my own position - there's a certain point where tight coupling makes sense. Linux kernel modules, for example, are tightly coupled to the Linux kernel, and don't work unmodified when compiled against a *BSD or Solaris kernel.