5 ms·
I heard her make remarks in a similar vein at the Washington State Book Awards in 2006: http://jakeseliger.com/2006/10/28/le-guin-at-the-seattle-public-library
by jseliger 12y ago
I heard her make remarks in a similar vein at the Washington State Book Awards in 2006: http://jakeseliger.com/2006/10/28/le-guin-at-the-seattle-public-library http://jakeseliger.com/2006/10/28/le-guin-at-the-seattle-pub... .
Incidentally, though, I think this no longer true: "Developing written material to suit sales strategies in order to maximize corporate profit and advertising revenue is not quite the same thing as responsible book publishing or authorship."
It's now easier than ever for writers to answer to no one but readers; the Internet in general and Amazon in particular are tremendous open platforms that let writers decide what to publish without the need for a conventional publisher.
See further http://www.vox.com/2014/10/22/7016827/amazon-hachette-monopoly http://www.vox.com/2014/10/22/7016827/amazon-hachette-monopo... .
- Booktrope 12y agoThe problem with Le Guin's position is that it's so Manichean, a world composed of good guys and bad guys with no ambiguities. To her, it's either sell books like deodorant or some ideal system where it's quality, not marketability, that makes books sell. This sounds good, but it's tripe. As you say, the Internet in general and Amazon in particular have opened up publishing -- Amazon getting huge credit because it not only allows freer publishing, but has set up a system that allows many thousands of new authors to actually connect with readers. Yet, Amazon is also a business focused on selling products at high volume with tight margins. These two goals aren't opposed, they're different aspects of a complex business. Amazon can be both a great contributor and profit-motivated, it's not that hard to see how. Who defines quality, anyway? The tastemakers, like newspaper reviewers, who nobody much pays attention to anymore? Or Le Guin -- she seems to think she knows what's good. I imagine, what if John Kennedy O'Toole had the opportunity to self-publish A Confederacy of Dunces, instead of facing despair when all the traditional publishers turned him down. What if he'd been able to sell his work like toothpaste on Amazon, even if the tastemakers thought it wasn't worth publishing. To Le Guin, this would somehow violate the ideals the publishing world ought to aspire to. To me, I wish the opportunities offered by Amazon had been around back then.
- WalterBright 12y agoHerman Melville's "Moby Dick" was a complete failure when published in 1851, and was essentially forgotten. It was rediscovered after WW1, becoming a great classic of American literature. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moby-Dick#Later_reception http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moby-Dick#Later_reception
- jseliger 12y agoIt was rediscovered after WW1, becoming a great classic of American literature. There's also an open question about the book's intrinsic merit versus the need at the time to "discover" American literature and find exemplary American texts of the sort that were needed to instil a sense of unity in a country of disparate immigrant groups. Menand discusses some of this in The Marketplace of Ideas: Reform and Resistance in the American University, which is an interesting and wonderful book. I wrote more about the book here: http://jakeseliger.com/2010/01/21/problems-in-the-academy-louis-menands-the-marketplace-of-ideas-reform-and-resistance-in-the-american-university-2 http://jakeseliger.com/2010/01/21/problems-in-the-academy-lo...
- WalterBright 12y agoHaving read the book myself, I'm confident it has a lot of intrinsic merit.
- Uhhrrr 12y agoYeah - I avoided it for a long time because of its reputation as a paperweight, but it's a great, multilayered, witty book. And it's unencumbered by copyright, so there's little reason not to give it a go.
- WalterBright 12y agoOne thing I like about Amazon is their large selection of classics like this, formatted for the Kindle, at $0.00.
- biot 12y agoDespite Amazon's open platform, I'm fairly sure that her phrase: "We just saw a profiteer try to punish a publisher for disobedience..." refers to Amazon's conflict with Hachette.
- WalterBright 12y agoThe irony is the statement applies equally even if you switch the roles of Amazon and Hachette!
- zzzeek 12y agoAmazon intentionally delayed/prevented the shipment of Hachette books to customers. What actions did Hachette take that would be similarly punitive (or punitive at all)?
- WalterBright 12y agoHachette demanded certain prices as condition of allowing Amazon to carry them.
- firebones 12y agoFalse. Hachette didn't have a contract with Amazon, and therefore Amazon wasn't under any obligation to pre-stock (i.e., donate warehouse space to) Hachette books. There was no prevention of shipments. Any delays were due to Hachette not having the same responsive fulfillment capacity that Amazon has. Similarly, offering Hachette books at Hachette's list prices is being spun by Author's United as something negative. If Hachette wanted competitive prices--change the list price.
- tehwalrus 12y agonot if you want actual wide readership, as opposed to theoretical wide readership. Ask a blogger!
- DennisP 12y agoA friend of mine self-published her first novel early this year, sold 40K copies so far, and is doing very well with presales for the next. Most of her sales are on Kindle. She's friends now with a lot of other self-published authors who are also doing quite well. So I wouldn't say people need publishers anymore for wide readership.
- tehwalrus 12y agoIt is possible, I'm not convinced it's probable.
- DennisP 12y agoSelling books in large quantities isn't all that probable with a traditional publisher, either. Even if they publish you, they usually don't market your book near as well as you'd hoped, and your royalties are a much smaller percentage of the sales price. With Amazon you can publish a book at $2.99 and keep 70% of that. I've seen a fair number of articles by people who'd published several books with traditional publishers, then decided the self-publish route paid more and got more books in the hands of readers.