8 ms·
Go to hell, Comcast. I have a 100Mbps cable Internet connection from them, so I can download about 10MB per second. At that advertised speed, I could burn throu
by kstrauser 12y ago
Go to hell, Comcast. I have a 100Mbps cable Internet connection from them, so I can download about 10MB per second. At that advertised speed, I could burn through a 300GB cap in about 8 hours.
I used to work for an ISP and I totally get the concept of oversubscription. But they're saying I can only use my paid account for about one-seventieth of the month without paying extra, all while advertising all the great streaming services I can use through my account.
I could not possibly be more wholeheartedly supportive of reclassifying Comcast as a common carrier. Using fines to maintain a 70:1 minimum oversubscription model is all the proof I need that this is sorely needed.
- gojomo 12y agoIf you're in the top 1% of non-stop bandwidth users, shouldn't you pay more? Why is it OK for AWS & Google Cloud to meter by the GB, but not Comcast?
- Afforess 12y agoIf Comcast charged the same rates as AWS, I probably wouldn't mind. But Comcast charges ~1000x more per GB. In addition, with AWS I can always switch to a cheaper provider. I can not switch to a cheaper cable company.
- gojomo 12y ago1000X more? Not by the source article: 50GB/$10 is $0.20/GB which is less than 2X AWS/Google's wholesale $0.12/GB. And that only kicks in after the first 300GB.
- No1 12y agoWell, AWS doesn't charge at all for inbound traffic, so you're looking at even worse than 1000x in one direction.
- al_bundling 12y ago> 1000X more? Not by the source article: 50GB/$10 is $0.20/GB which is less than 2X AWS/Google's wholesale $0.12/GB. AWS/Google retail bandwidth prices are a bad comparison, as they are ridiculously expensive compared to wholesale bandwidth prices. Wholesale bandwidth costs about 0.1 cents per GB. Not quite 1000X what Comcast charges, it's "only" 100X the wholesale rate. To give you some perspective, Dane Jasper, CEO of Sonic.net said they spend about 3% of their costs on bandwidth. Please consider that Sonic is a small actor and at scale costs will be less.
- iamhamm 12y ago> Wholesale bandwidth costs about 0.1 cents per GB. Source? I've often wondered what this number is when viewed in aggregate across carriers - I can just never find it.
- MichaelGG 12y ago$0.003/GB is what $1/1Mbps is, at 100% utilization. 324GB is what 1Mbps can do in a month. Perhaps a bit less but low quality providers (HE, Cogent) will do a dollar a Mbps easily. So work backwards. (Another way, you need 3kbps to do 1GB in a month. That times 333 is about 1Mbps, so $1. I'm ignoring 95th percentile billing here.) Better providers like L3 are around $3/Mbps, last I heard. So $0.001 a GB means you'd only pay 33 cents per Mbps, which seems pretty low. But maybe at terabit commits, HE goes even lower.. I've only looked at 10G commits.
- al_bundling 12y ago> Source? http://amazon.com/ip-transit http://amazon.com/ip-transit Just kidding. Seriously though, you are not going to see wholesale rates posted on a website. Contact your bandwidth provider and ask for a quote. For serious volumes and good pricing, expect to sign an NDA. However, to give you an idea of lowend pricing here are some examples from FDCservers. This is not an endorsement, just a site with easily accessible prices that I could remember off the top of my head. In fact, I emphatically do not recommend them. There are much better providers both in terms of price and quality. Remember 0.1 cents per GB equals about $0.30 per Mbps. Asymmetrical 100G at $0.15 per Mbps https://fdcservers.net/ip-transit.php https://fdcservers.net/ip-transit.php Metered 10G at $0.60 per Mbps https://fdcservers.net/colocation.php https://fdcservers.net/colocation.php Unmetered 10G including server $500 https://fdcservers.net/dedicated-servers.php https://fdcservers.net/dedicated-servers.php
- toomuchtodo 12y agoAWS bandwidth costs are grossly overpriced.
- kstrauser 12y agoWhat's the top 1%? Since you're preaching Comcast's virtues in this story, I presume you have the number close at hand?
- gojomo 12y agoComcast has reported ~2% or less of their customers use more than 300GB per month: http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/05/comcast-plans-data-caps-for-all-customers-in-5-years-could-be-500gb/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/05/comcast-plans-data-c... We are the 98%! And charging the heavy users more makes our service cheaper. Some of the people complaining here are elites – in technical and economic terms – and want poorer, less-sophisticated people to subsidize their outlier usage. And they're dressing this desire-for-handouts up in a righteous anger!
- kstrauser 12y agoNo. It keeps our price the same and makes Comcast more profitable. Don't think for a second that savings will ever trickle down to us.
- MrUnknown 12y agoThis right here is the real lesson. Comcast is not going to lower rates for everyone else because of this.
- gojomo 12y agoActually, that depends on whether Comcast has effective competition. If they do, prices for end-users will improve, trending closer to the cost of servicing them. If they don't have competition, regulation can't always simulate the same consumer benefits, for a number of reasons. The regulators are often at the mercy of the regulated company. (The FCC, for example, is all telecom/lobbyist/party-functionary lawyers.) The regulated company tends to do fine, as their model and margins get frozen into slow-moving regulatory law. Smaller/newer companies with other models and technologies can't as easily fit into the regulatory mold, which often even bans them from offering the high-value (differentiated) services that could offer a competitive toehold. Can't have some upstart skimming off the cream from the now-tamed monopolist! Which is why in all cases new competition, not formulaic rules from DC lawyers, should be the policy priority.
- x0x0 12y agoif it weren't a monopoly, I'd agree in swaths of the bay area, there is exactly one high speed provider
- paralelogram 12y agoUnlimited bandwidth is better for me because I can use the connection without worrying that watching too many videos or downloading too many game updates will cause me to lose the internet access for the rest of the month or get an extremely high bill. AWS bandwidth usage is not an issue because when the traffic to my websites increases, my ad revenue increases too.
- ghaff 12y agoI'm no fan of Comcast but you do realize that usage-based pricing is totally consistent with common carrier status? AT&T charged based on usage for years while they were a regulated monopoly. Others may disagree but I'd argue that, to the degree that there's wide disparity in usage, there probably needs to be some way of segmenting that usage whether it's fees paid by the upstream (e.g. Netflix) or by the downstream consumer.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tommccabe 12y agoPeople had to pay long distance fees to call long distance BBSes once. Plenty of power users and hackers came out of that generation.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- spullara 12y agoThere may have been some, let's say workarounds, the long distance charges.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt's videos and bulk photos that rip through data, not hacker software and HTML forums. At $1/GB, your kid can browse forums all night for a nickle. Not to mention, electricity has always been usage-based. Heck, a modern desktop PC probably burns through a nickle or two as he browses as well!
- sliverstorm 12y agoThere's always a vitriolic reaction in geek communities to usage-based billing. I'm used to it by now. My personal conclusion (as much as people shout at me otherwise) is that geek communities quietly realize they are top-1% users and their usage patterns are subsidized by everybody else, so a switch to usage-based billing represents a greater costs to themselves. You see that kind of thing in politics all the time.
- tzs 12y ago> I have a 100Mbps cable Internet connection from them, so I can download about 10MB per second. At that advertised speed, I could burn through a 300GB cap in about 8 hours For most people, higher speed isn't about being able to download more data per month. It's about their data not taking as long to download. Average use is only 50 GB/month, according to data quoted in the discussion on North American usage earlier today [1]. E.g., I have 30 mbps Comcast instead of 3 mbps DSL because when I need a 1 GB file I'd much rather get it in 5 minutes than in 45 minutes. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8635420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8635420
- lostcolony 12y ago'Average use' is 50 GB/month, but note that it went up -5 gigs- in one year, and that that's an -average- across all fixed type lines. I.e., you are averaging people on satellite, grandmothers who just check email and facebook, etc, with the more typical family of four streaming video across multiple devices. I want to know the distribution curve, because I bet it's a pretty flat distribution. Presumably Comcast knows that too, and that's why they even -have- that "use only 5 gigs a month and save $5", which is the biggest ripoff I've ever heard of, but which, for grandma checking her email, might make sense (provided her grandchildren never visit her and use the internet).
- ianlevesque 12y agoGrandma checking her email still uses dialup, or in the case of my grandma, her 3G connection on her iPhone. The 5GB plan makes sense for no one.
- MichaelGG 12y agoYou can get IP transit for under a buck a Mbps. So your 100 meg line has a "cost" of $100 for shit-tier transit. Add better providers, now it's $200. Add last mile, support, etc... All of a sudden, no one wants to pay so much for residential. So it is disingenuous to complain that your top speed means you burn up your allocation. It's unlikely anyone is happy to pay per Mbps, so they gotta work out something which requires compromise. Now, the limits are tiny, the pricing nuts, etc., but it's not fundamentally a terrible model. On cell data, I'm very happy to buy per GB so I can decide how much to spend. The real downside is that capping users or offering low cap plans stifles innovation. It sounds nice to be able to "pay what you use" but that has a negative impact overall.
- al_bundling 12y ago> So your 100 meg line has a "cost" of $100 for shit-tier transit Wholesale rates from quality providers are about $0.30 per Mbps per month at 95th percentile. For paid transit, that is, and Comcast does a lot of peering which brings the cost down for them. So that's $30 per month for your 100M line, even if you run it full tilt all month and manage to hit only paid transit routes all the time. That's not too bad and most people use only a small fraction of their theoretical monthly throughput.
- seanp2k2 12y agoHonest question: what's stopping every larger apartment complex from getting a 10gbps line and paying for bandwidth, then offering that as an Internet option to residents (delivery via cat5)?
- dsr_ 12y agoTwo things: first, the costs cited above are for handoffs at major peering points, private or public. Pulling 10Gb/s across to your apartment complex is going to add a lot to the cost, if it can even be done (right of way issues). second, the expertise needed to realize that you can do this and then provide support for it is neither common nor cheap. If you had a tower on a nice highly-visible location (say, the giant Jesus statue in Rio) and could do line-of-sight laser links, that would be an extremely cost-effective solution. Sadly, that sort of opportunity is rare.
- techsupporter 12y agoThe obnoxious part about all of this is that smaller cable ISPs have been doing this for years so now Comcast has someone to point to and say "why didn't anyone object when these companies did it?" Mediacom has a 250GB rigorously-enforced cap with very high overage rates. Heck, smack in the middle of Seattle is a cable ISP called Wave Broadband. They have 100GB-1000GB usage tiers and even actively market that "more gigs can be proactively purchased each month." (But at least they bought out CondoInternet so the high-rise dwellers and houseboats in Eastlake can have no-quota gigabit fiber service.)