4 ms·
This is one I've been recommending to "Aunt Tillie"-types, because it involves fairly little computer-savvy: 1. Memorize a single prefix that has at least an u
by Terr_ 12y ago
This is one I've been recommending to "Aunt Tillie"-types, because it involves fairly little computer-savvy:
1. Memorize a single prefix that has at least an uppercase letter, a number, and a symbol, to be used with all passwords. (e.g. j8$F)
2. Use a physical journal or pad of paper to note down each site's password restrictions (e.g. "no symbols") and a personal hint to the rest of the password.
3. Your password is the prefix (minus any unsupported characters) plus the answer to the hint.
So the hint "No symbols, They All Float Down Here" might become j8fPennyWise. "Feet On The Road" might be j8$fFlintstones.
___
This minimizes what people have to memorize, is secure against casual attacks by people in the same physical area, is strong against attackers who might try to replace "password4hn" with "password4reddit", and doesn't require any sort of special software.
- aroman 12y agoThis strikes me as a really good strategy. Thanks for sharing. At first I thought you were going to advocate the "just pick a prefix and then append the name of the site after it", like Go123facebook and Go123gmail. Which is, of course, quite awful because one plaintext reversing of one password may very well defeat all of the other passwords.
- Terr_ 12y agoI figure if people are going to write things down on sticky notes anyway, it might as well be part of the system. Hmmm... also, there's a failure-mode with systems that notice the prefix and reject future passwords as "too similar to one you used before". Users would have to deviate from the strategy somehow.
- diversewhat 12y agoYou just have to watch out for hackers who are also cruciverbalists...
- Terr_ 12y agoTrue, but you're probably safe from hackers XOR cruciverbalists.
- sneak 12y ago"Use a password manager" is so much easier to explain and teach.
- yen223 12y agoA password manager is another tool that the user needs to learn, another moving part in a system that really shouldn't be so complex. It's good advice, but it's by no means simpler than the alternative.
- brongondwana 12y ago"in a system that really shouldn't be so complex" [citation needed] Do you actually have a less complex way to reliably identify a person at the other end of a computer network? (physical keys using NFC stuff are pretty exciting, but the tech isn't in place yet... until then we're stuck with "something you know" and the limits of human memory vs computer power)
- joshjdr 12y agoDid you know that the CIA was one of the early investors in 1Password? Not seriously, but I'm just saying. If you are really concerned about security I have a hard time understanding this concept.
- etha 12y agoMost people aren't worried about being secure from the CIA, we're worried about being secure from random criminals at the airport or the cafe. If the CIA wants you, they can just kidnap you and lock you away anyway.
- Terr_ 12y agoAnd when "Aunt Tillie" installs a keylogging trojan, it's Game Over. Not only that, but she had no idea how to make backups. A paper pad, on the other hand, is extremely secure against cyberattack, and she has tons of experience with managing it and creating backups. And it's almost what she was gonna do anyway.