3 ms·
My take on this: yes, it is targeted at poor consumers. They're almost certainly going to receive objectively worse terms than people who are smarter, savvier,
by patio11 17y ago
My take on this: yes, it is targeted at poor consumers. They're almost certainly going to receive objectively worse terms than people who are smarter, savvier, and (not unrelated to those two) richer. This happens in many, many things poor people buy.
There are a lot of folks whose actions are responsible for this state of affairs. Its interesting that while responsibility is diffuse, blame gets concentrated pretty acutely on particular participants in the value chain.
For example, I can't remember the last time someone blamed jewelry vendors for the plight of poor people. Poor people spend more as a percentage of income on jewelry than any other socio-economic group. Poor people have more of their assets tied up in jewelry than any other socio-economic group.
Its interesting to me -- and I mean that, interesting, not the passive-aggressive way of saying "y'all are stupid" -- that we go after Cash4Gold for offering $12.50 for $75 worth of gold when we don't go after Kay Jewelers for selling the $300 brooch the gold is in. Cash4Gold is seen as cheating the poor customer out of $62.50, but Kay Jewelers is just an honest businessman who made $225 off of selling the bauble in the first place.
More broadly: a portion of the attraction to jewelry for poor customers is that it is a value store and access to short-term credit for people who are unbanked. (If you own a $300 bauble from Kay's then you have a $100 line of credit at your local pawn shop which charges you APRs of $STAGGERING_PERCENT.) Jewelry is a TERRIBLE alternative to banking services.
Incidentally: jewelry is a consumption item. Don't buy it with the intention of it having resale value. Don't buy it if you can't afford it.
- jacquesm 17y agoOr, even simpler, don't buy it. Real people are more than beautiful enough by themselves and don't need to be plastered with gold. Especially not if the only thing that gold does is show that you now no longer have money. Better spend it on something useful.