3 ms·
I'm absolutely not a designer, but I have serious issues with many tips in the first half of this article and the design trends that they support. They're all a
by skrebbel 12y ago
I'm absolutely not a designer, but I have serious issues with many tips in the first half of this article and the design trends that they support. They're all about putting text over images and keeping it readable.
So basically, you're first going to increase my cognitive load with a big flashy unrelated photo, and then you're going to blur and dropshadow and opacity-gradient it just so much that I can kind of read the text again? What for?
Fullscreen photos are nice, but they're just a picture. Very nice blurred bridge there in the background, but how is that going to sell me a route planning app? I feel like a lot of these examples are aesthetic-only designers gone wild without any place for feedback from their peers.
Is it good when it's pretty and you can just about read the text without squinting your eyes? No! It's acceptable at best. But if you try, and I bet if you actually do user tests, then you'll find that you want to ditch the image. Or at least put a big black box around the text (admittedly, also listed as an example).
Can we stop the cognitive overload already? Don't make me think! Don't make me search past the blurs and the street lights and the flowers to find the text I'm supposed to be reading.
(unless, of course, you sell a blur plugin, a street light or flowers)
- freebs 12y agoI'm not a designer either, but I also prefer the solid colors with illustrations to boot. At least they recommend using an overlay with the image, many don't do this or don't tint it enough to make the text readable.
- joopxiv 12y agoThe whole point of good UI design is that it should be pleasant to look at (and images can help with that) WITHOUT having to put much effort into searching what you're supposed to be reading.
- skrebbel 12y ago> WITHOUT having to put much effort into searching what you're supposed to be reading. Agreed, and I think my opinion differs from that of today's design crowd in what is "much effort". For me, any effort is too much. If I have to do effort to actually understand your landing page, I'm out.
- resu_nimda 12y agoMost people aren't software developers (or similar types), their browsing habits aren't grounded in their continually-honed digital search and retrieval skills. They like pretty pictures. They don't mind being distracted as much (all those news websites we find god-awful, with tons of display ads and flashing colors - do you assume those businesses don't know what they're doing?). They don't always visit a website with a singular intent to extract the relevant data as quickly as possible and move on. There is so much UI/UX-related ranting on HN from the power user perspective; a lot of people just can't believe how amazingly stupid these companies are, how they haven't done any research or testing, how some exec just wanted to fuck with the design for the hell of it. The reality is, they just aren't optimizing for you, especially if advertising is their main source of revenue. I do think it's important for them to make the power users happy enough, because they are the influencers and early-adopters that the others will follow, but they're going to have a hard time putting some nerd rage before the piles of cash flowing in. (This post wasn't specifically aimed at you, I do agree with much of your argument, but we have to keep in mind that we aren't the only user class, we're actually a relatively small one.)
- skrebbel 12y agoCool point, thanks.