3 ms·
This story was on top of HN a few moments ago and then seemed to drop like a stone while gaining points: currently at 22nd position with 325 points and 10 hours
by bambax 12y ago
This story was on top of HN a few moments ago and then seemed to drop like a stone while gaining points: currently at 22nd position with 325 points and 10 hours old, whereas these stories are above it (all as old or older and with less points):
pos id points hours
6 8632209 292 15
9 8633707 129 10
12 8633683 204 14
13 8632405 139 14
17 8632363 140 15
18 8633286 58 12
20 8632043 161 16
21 8632018 141 16
What's happening?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dang 12y agoYou can't derive story rank from displayed points and times alone. That's on purpose, to make it harder to game HN. The phenomenon you're describing happens routinely, for multiple reasons. One is that we've been experimenting with flushing the front page of older stories periodically when there is a crop of newer ones that, if not for the older ones' inertia, would make the front page. This is related to the work we've been doing to improve the odds for good stories that would otherwise fall through the cracks. We might eventually change the main ranking algorithm to accommodate this, but our approach tends to be to do manual experiments first, software experiments second, and modify the core HN system last.
- bambax 12y agoMany thanks for answering. However, this doesn't seem to explain it > when there is a crop of newer ones that, if not for the older ones' inertia since the stories that were above this one were older stories, some much older (16 hours vs 10): it seems the story wasn't pushed down to make room for newer ones, but to make room for older ones.
- dang 12y agoIt isn't that straightforward; I'm afraid that without going into details the explanation is bound to be less than fully satisfying. Also, there are other reasons why stories fall suddenly. My main point is that it's routine. Sample bias comes into play here in that one mostly notices it with stories one was paying attention to.