3 ms·
I dislike Al Franken's politics greatly, but I think it's every bit his right to use the bully pulpit this way (I mean this sincerely). If Uber did track a jour
by tomcam 12y ago
I dislike Al Franken's politics greatly, but I think it's every bit his right to use the bully pulpit this way (I mean this sincerely). If Uber did track a journalist it is reprehensible.
But how Uber could benefit from answering this fishing expedition? If I were Uber I'd simply stonewall. They are under no legal compunction to answer, and virtually no answer would help them.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> If I were Uber I'd simply stonewall. The federal government can make your life extremely difficult, fully funded startup or not.
- smt88 12y agoThis is an irrelevant point, but it's a stretch to call a 5-year-old company with $2B in revenue a "startup".
- toomuchtodo 12y agoYou're an experiment/startup until you're profitable, at which point you become a real business.
- smt88 12y agoThat's absurd. By that definition, Amazon, a 20-year-old company with $74 billion in revenue, is a startup. Profitability has a lot to do with how you spend your money. "Startup" is commonly used to connote a small, new business. The dictionary says it is a "fledgling" business. If Uber's revenue were the GDP of a nation, it would have 40 countries ranked below it. That's not a "fledgling" business, even if it isn't profitable.
- rtpg 12y agoLoads of real businesses are not profitable (and will eventually fall over).
- brianpgordon 12y agoI imagine this is just a courtesy; if they decline to answer, then the committee can issue a subpoena and compel them to. Here's a nice white paper on Congress's subpoena power: http://www.mayerbrown.com/files/Publication/ec1203b2-a787-44ac-8344-5d5fab374ffa/Presentation/PublicationAttachment/11509b8b-df81-4db6-9e89-1d1b16c20856/White-Paper-Congressional-Subpoena.pdf http://www.mayerbrown.com/files/Publication/ec1203b2-a787-44...
- msherry 12y agoThat was really interesting, thanks. In particular, "The Enforcement Process. Congressional investigations often begin informally, with the interested committee or subcommittee first seeking information on a voluntary basis (i.e., by sending a letter request or asking for an informal interview), rather than by issuing compulsory subpoenas. Although there is no legal obligation that a party comply with such a request, it is typically in the responding party’s best interest to do so"
- andrewpi 12y agoFranken will no longer be Chairman of this committee in January when the Democrats are no longer in control of the US Senate.
- hudibras 12y agoEven if this is a Democratic-only concern (which I don't think it is), this would be an easy one for a Senator in the minority to sell to the Chairman as a personal favor. It would just be a subpoena to answer some questions; the Chairman wouldn't be signing up to actually do anything like sponsoring legislation.
- tomcam 12y agoFascinating! So the letter is probably a veiled threat. I hope the Senate has better things to do with its time, though a debate of much stronger privacy laws would be a healthy outcome of this mess.
- WildUtah 12y ago"But how Uber could benefit from answering this fishing expedition?" It's an opportunity to establish publicly that your company won't be engaging in any of the kind of shenanigans that can cost you customers in a competitive industry.