2 ms·
We're not talking about arbitrary control; we're talking about one specific set of restrictions designed specifically for the protection of freedom. It's quite
by dllthomas 12y ago
We're not talking about arbitrary control; we're talking about one specific set of restrictions designed specifically for the protection of freedom. It's quite possible they fail at that, compared to alternatives, but it is not at all incomprehensible that they might succeed - restricting some behavior often leads to more freedom in general, especially when that behavior involves exercise of power over others. Proof of existence, by example: Selling a knife with a "this can't be used for mugging" clause - in a world where mugging wasn't illegal - restricts the freedom of the purchaser but only when you don't consider those they would impact if they exercised that freedom. To be clear, I'm not saying "selling proprietary software is exactly like mugging"; I'm just saying your general "restrictions always mean less freedom" doesn't hold up.
All of this is not to say that I think it's entirely clear that copyleft licenses do lead to more freedom overall. My initial statement was precisely that it's not particularly clear. My personal expectation (which I'd argue for if we want to go down that path but hold weakly in that I consider other views reasonable) is that it varies from case to case.