6 ms·
I don't think most people believe in climate change so you'd probably need to convince more people that it's actually a problem. If you read the WSJ, Facebook,
by melling 12y ago
I don't think most people believe in climate change so you'd probably need to convince more people that it's actually a problem.
If you read the WSJ, Facebook, etc, you'll frequently see comments like the following which had nothing to do with climate change and was about the Rosetta probe.
http://online.wsj.com/articles/rosetta-probe-directly-discovers-organic-molecules-on-comet-1416256078?hubRefSrc=email#lf_comment=237691475 http://online.wsj.com/articles/rosetta-probe-directly-discov...
"Lets hope that with our last election that the US can get back to real science instead of voodoo climate change superstitions whose purpose is to enrich Democrats and ecowhaacos and to make poor people's energy costs go up."
The comment was upvoted a dozen times. I took the couple questions that I answered and started my own FAQ: http://thespanishsite.com/faq/climate http://thespanishsite.com/faq/climate
- tthomas48 12y agoI think that's built into this, though. People don't have to "believe" if it's cheaper.
- dubfan 12y agoThe problem is that the American left has decided to make climate change "their issue", which leads the right wing to engage in denialist tactics. It's important to note that both of these positions are not really based in solid scientific understanding, but because they play to their political ideologies. See how the left can simultaneously support climate science but oppose GMOs, which have a beneficial impact on greenhouse gas emissions. It's frustrating too, because despite owning the issue, the left doesn't seem interested in the economic factors that this article highlights are necessary to take into account. The anti-corporate contingent of the left finds it distasteful.
- asgard1024 12y agoI think main driver of why people deny climate change is that the market mechanism cannot deal with that situation. So if someone is a firm believer in market solutions to everything, the climate change reality is a tough attack on that personal belief.
- protomyth 12y agoSure the market can deal with it: someone creates a cheaper, easy to transport, clean fuel ecosystem. Problem is people keep denying they need a market solution and instead look with glee on instituting new regulations.
- jberryman 12y ago> Sure the market can deal with it Sorry, no. Much the costs of burning fossil fuels are externalized and with climate change this is taken to the extreme. This is what cap-and-trade was supposed to be about, but it seems that for the modern right "market solution" is whatever preserves the status quo.
- protomyth 12y agocap-and-trade will not fix the problem with up and coming economies. cap-and-trade is not a market solution, it just taxes the market. you either figure out a equivalent or better cost way - or we have to deal with war or climate engineering. I would prefer we get something that works before we get into "the kill my neighbor to preserve what I have" mentality. (given the voting, nope not going to respond further on this issue - no point in "debate" if silencing is the response)
- anigbrowl 12y agoYou're assuming perfect competition and no switching costs, while ignoring network effects. I like markets but they don't inevitably produce rational outcomes.
- seanflyon 12y agoThe market cannot take into account to cost of externalities, unless there is some mechanism to charge for them (meaning tax them). The other option would be to eliminate the concept of externalities by making everything owned by someone, but I don't see how that could work. You would have to come to an agreement with whomever owns air quality before you polluted and come to an agreement with whomever owns temperature before you caused warming...
- yongjik 12y agoImagine that the American right decides to make, say, ISIS "their issue", which leads the left wing to engage in denialist tactics. That is, the American left denies ISIS. The refuse to accept such a group exists. Sure, some people make the claim, but it's all theory (and some Youtube videos), and there are alternative explanations. In such a case, would you say the problem begins with the American right making it "their" issue?
- VLM 12y ago"their issue" Agreed, and I extend your remarks with its a sign of pessimism and mistrust of government. Its well earned. In an ideal world if our leaders were angelic statespeople, I might trust them not to screw things up even worse or as a smokescreen for political corruption. I don't live in a country like that and I can sympathize with OPs quotation. His description is, unfortunately, the most likely outcome. In all honesty, if we can't fix it ourselves, we're doomed, because the government always causes more problems than it solves, makes things overall worse rather than better, for my entire life. And I'm no young kid and I can't stand the political party OP's quote likely comes from. I might hate what they stand for but I'm objective enough to see common ground when they are, in very small part, correct.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoSo, the right are a bunch of blible-thumping, big-business-loving, climate denialists, whereas the left are a bunch of GMO haters. Maybe this species is too dumb to survive after all.
- fennecfoxen 12y ago1. Internet comments are a poor way of gauging sentiment; they tend to overrepresent cranky nay-sayers, who disproportionately benefit from venting. 2. If people would like to convince more people that it's actually a problem, consider that people have a tendency to recognize when what is touted as a Worthy Cause is actually being used as an excuse to obtain power or distribute political favors. Consider more public critiques of the efficacy of policy proposals -- this will also help you actually achieve your climate goals -- and have a lot more sympathy to the middle class who would suffer a lot more under an $8/gallon gas regime than a typical employed HNer would. Acknowledge the harm that high energy costs (including gas costs) would do to the economy, and consider ways to mitigate that harm by generally improving the business climate, regulatory regimes and tax regimes -- instead of writing it off or, worse, claiming that green energy is a magical job-creation mechanism (tip: spending more time effort and money to obtain the same amount of energy does not actually help the economy). Hold fewer events like the recent Peoples' Climate March in NYC (transparently a leftist platform using climate change as an excuse to protest capitalism writ large), and whatever you do do NOT use propaganda that features the statue of liberty mostly underwater (an accurate rendition of full 100% ice-melt from 33-degree warming but unrealistic as a near-term possibility and probably not the best image to lead with). Drop the caricatures which insult middle America as uncultured fatsoes driving around in SUVs, accurate or otherwise. Question what other ways in which political-party sentiment infiltrates climate-change talk.
- atlantic 12y agoI'm in Europe, and I don't know anyone who does not believe in climate change. In fact it's not considered a faith issue at all; the scientific case is overwhelming. Maybe the sentiment is completely different in the US, because the media is so pro-business that the facts can be safely ignored.
- refurb 12y agoI would have to disagree the evidence is overwhelming. Even climate change scientists acknowledge there is a lot that can't be currently explained.[1] [1]The real holes in climate science: http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100120/full/463284a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100120/full/463284a.html
- crawlsonrocks 12y agoSorry but an article by the same author two years later says it is man made http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/three-quarters-of-climate/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/three-quarters-of-...
- refurb 12y agoI see your article with an even newer article claiming those holes have still not been addressed.[1] http://www.nature.com/news/climate-change-the-forecast-for-2018-is-cloudy-with-record-heat-1.13344 http://www.nature.com/news/climate-change-the-forecast-for-2... Efforts to predict the near-term climate are taking off, but their record so far has been patchy.
- arebop 12y ago"Such holes do not undermine the fundamental conclusion that humans are warming the climate, which is based on the extreme rate of the twentieth-century temperature changes and the inability of climate models to simulate such warming without including the role of greenhouse-gas pollution" [ibid].
- vixen99 12y agoAnd that overwhelming evidence is? And which of the 50 odd reasons put forward, do you favour to explain the hiatus. Apparently nobody takes Feynman seriously in his unequivocal statement that if the theory does not agree with experiment, the theory is wrong.
- Florin_Andrei 12y ago> I don't think most people believe in climate change True in the US. Not true in countries where the political system is not to such an extent corrupted, poisoned and perverted by Big Money.