4 ms·
While this is an interesting analysis, I don't think you should be labeled "racist" if you aren't attracted to people of races other than your own.
by tlrobinson 17y ago
While this is an interesting analysis, I don't think you should be labeled "racist" if you aren't attracted to people of races other than your own.
- mlinsey 17y agoAgreed. Are all non-bisexuals "sexist"? Maybe by some strict definition they are, but not in the ordinary sense we use the term, and to expand its definition to include those sorts of preferences might dilute the moral case against racism and sexism.
- emmett 17y agoThere's a clear difference between sex and race when it comes to, um, sex. Conflating the two doesn't make much sense in this instance.
- rsheridan6 17y agoWhat is that difference? It's ok to discriminate based on sex but not on race? Why or why not?
- codexon 17y agoSo it's equally ok to discriminate on child bearing abilities and race? Hint: one of these attributes has a practical purpose in the perpetuation of human society, and the other does not.
- rsheridan6 17y agoThat would only apply to people who intend to bear children. What if you're childfree and intend to remain that way, beyond your childbearing years, or you've had a vasectomy/tubal ligation? By your logic, would it not then be ok to discriminate based on race?
- codexon 17y agoIf you are going to make a sweeping argument with such specific circumstances, it is up to you to prove that it applies to the majority.
- rsheridan6 17y agoI'm not the one who said it wasn't ok to discriminate based on race when you choose who you're going to date. Fuck or don't fuck whomever you want, it's none of my business (FWIW I am white and married to a white woman, but would not have automatically rejected someone for being of another race). I was just asking asking a question. Nobody here has attempted to prove that anything - that it's ok or not ok to discriminate based on race or gender. I'm just asking, what's the difference? It seems to me that the same principle of equality that says it's not ok to have a preference in partners based on race should say that it's not ok to have a preference based on gender, assuming that discrimination based on gender in general is not ok. This is the logical consequence of the position that discrimination is not acceptable. Your first attempt to show the difference, based on procreation, was a failure, so you're reduced to calling the next logical step "ridiculous," which is not really an argument. I don't think there is a good argument for your position. 20 years ago, people would have said that the idea that not dating people of a particular race makes you racist was ridiculous, but here we are.
- codexon 17y ago> It seems to me that the same principle of equality that says it's not ok to have a preference in partners based on race should say that it's not ok to have a preference based on gender, assuming that discrimination based on gender in general is not ok. Applying the "principle of equality" with a total disregard for the facts is fallacious. Why stop at race and gender? Why do we discriminate against corpses (necrophiliacs) or even different species (zoophilia)? This is the ridiculous argument you are presenting. A line has to be drawn somewhere and the tone of your skin should be a far less compelling characteristic than gender.
- 17y ago
- rictic 17y agoOk, if that's the basis of your objection then the situation of dating a woman who is physically unable to have children is analogous to dating a man?
- codexon 17y agoThe point is that using gender preference as an excuse for race preference is ridiculous.
- hughprime 17y agoGender preference is certainly non-equivalent to race preference. On the other hand, it does show that certain forms of discrimination which would be wrong (and just plain illegal) in other settings are perfectly okay in a dating setting. As a better example, I'm not interested in dating women who are old, ugly, fat, or have children, and that's perfectly okay. If I were not interested in hiring women who were old, ugly, fat or have children then I'd have a serious lawsuit on my hands. Now personally, I think that refusing to date someone based on their race is both regrettable and closed-minded, but it's not detestable the way that actual racism is.
- codexon 17y ago>"As a better example, I'm not interested in dating women who are old, ugly, fat, or have children, and that's perfectly okay. If I were not interested in hiring women who were old, ugly, fat or have children then I'd have a serious lawsuit on my hands." If you looked at the other OkCupid chart, it shows that race has little impact on interracial match %. It's fairly certain that "old, ugly, fat, have children" are all characteristics that would lower the match %, therefore you argument of equating these different traits is debunked. Your bit about hiring is also suspect. Think about 50+ years ago when minorities such as blacks really weren't up to standard due to years of slavery and persecution. Back then it was also seen as "legitimate" (using your argument) to not hire black people in the same way that people aren't dating minorities today. >"Now personally, I think that refusing to date someone based on their race is both regrettable and closed-minded, but it's not detestable the way that actual racism is." What is this "actual" racism? Since when is there "actual" racism and "fake" racism? I'm amazed at how many upvotes you have received with what is basically a No true Scotsman fallacy comment.
- emmett 17y agoWhen it comes to sex, it's ok to discriminate on the basis of sex, because when it comes to sex the different sexes are very different. Their sexual characteristics are different, they produce different sex hormones, and they even participate in the act of sex in completely different ways. Were there to be some activity where your melanin levels were critical (hard to think of a realistic one, but say you were going to be sent on a space journey where extra melanin would be a grave disadvantage nutritionally) then race (or really, skin color - I can't even think of a ridiculous example for race) would be extremely relevant. In that instance, discrimination based on skin color would make perfect sense whereas discrimination based on sex would not have any such obvious connection. Does it make sense now?
- mlinsey 17y agoYes, and? In this post and your next one you present an argument for why discriminating on the basis of sex is more rational than discriminating on the basis of race in terms of who you are attracted to. You seem to think that I was arguing that discrimination on the basis of sex is exactly like discrimination on the basis of race when it comes to picking romantic and/or sexual partners. Perhaps I was unclear due to brevity but that's not what I intended to say at all. My point was that we should refrain from judging people for having racial preferences in who they want to date for the same reason that we should refrain from judging people for having sexual/gender preferences in who they want to date: because nobody really controls who they are attracted to, because attraction is a very personal thing that is based on a whole host of factors, some less rational than others, because there is no basis for saying that any particular set of sexual preferences is "right", and because saying that people ought to be attracted to people who they aren't just leads to alienation and unnecessary grief. All of these preferences probably meet the technical definition of various forms of discrimination, but the words we have for those types of discriminations (rightfully) imply a certain moral judgment about the person being described which I think is inappropriate in this instance.
- emmett 17y agoThat's a perfectly legitimate argument for why a race-preference in dating should not be considered racism. I do not object to it now, nor have I ever. What I do object to is conflating sex and race when it comes to questions of sex. The previous claim, which I objected to, was that there's no difference between a sex preference in dating and a race preference in dating. That's definitely not true, for the reasons I've outlined twice now. Personally, I agree with you - a race preference in sexual attraction is not something you really have control over, any more than most other sexual preferences.
- kscaldef 17y agoI think there's a classic nature vs. nurture question here. Is there inherently something that causes people to be attracted to people who look like what they see in the mirror; or is it influenced by the media, your peer group, your parents, etc. Personally, I suspect the latter plays a much larger role, but I don't have any solid evidence to back that up. And, let's face it, there's probably some degree of it just being easier. Your friends and your family are never going to give you any hassle about dating someone of your own race (). You're never going to have to worry about some bigot yelling at you, or worse, walking down the street. Is that sort of calculation racist? Probably a little, although of a mild sort. In my mind, though, these sorts of mild racisms help to perpetuate the more serious manifestations. They limit interracial interactions; they perpetuate the myth that there actually is significant genetic basis for the concept of race; and they give comfort to racial-purity bigots. The delicate thing here is to recognize this sort of feeling without beating yourself up about it too much. But, to start, just try to make the transition from thinking "I'm just not attracted to people who aren't the same race as me, and there's nothing wrong with that" to "I'm not attracted to people who aren't the same race as me, and I'm not really sure why that is". () This probably applies to religion too.
- rokhayakebe 17y agoIt suspect it is a matter of "social comfort". In general men can easily be attracted to women of different races. I think it is in their nature to be broad in their selection. Nearly every men I know have or have considered dating outside his race. Most women I talk to can find someone of a different race attractive. But they will not date them.
- dusklight 17y agoYeah but the article had some other interesting points, like how black females are less desired by every other race, including black males, and how females in some non-white races prefer white males over males of their own race.
- psyklic 17y agoYears ago I thought this as well. However, once I became good friends with people of different races, I started to become attracted to more people of those races as well. So, I definitely do think that there is some component of "racism" to this, even though it may be subconscious.
- stcredzero 17y agoI need to be thankful for the song "The Lakes of Pontchartrain." If it wasn't for the line "handsome young creole girl" I wouldn't have been curious enough to date my present girlfriend, who is African American. We've now been going out for almost 3 years, and I'm happier than I've ever been. I've also discovered a lot about what subconscious racism I've been carrying around in my head. There is racism. You can't be black and have a conversation with your sons and your brothers in a parking lot. The police will come by and harass you. This despite the fact that my girlfriend's uncle is a wonderful, industrious, upstanding ex-military man. You can be white and do this, though. (This was not some seedy parking lot in a run-down neighborhood in the big city. It happened in a rural town of only 16,000.)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]