2 ms·
A major argument against making bicycle helmets compulsory is that it would make people stop cycling (helmets destroy your hair, and where would you store your
by Someone 12y ago
A major argument against making bicycle helmets compulsory is that it would make people stop cycling (helmets destroy your hair, and where would you store your helmet when parked?), and that would cause more deaths due to cardiac arrest and the like than helmets would prevent. Hard to test, but IMO not an unreasonable argument (I think there are scientific papers on this, too)
And of course, the infrastructure is way different in the Netherlands, as is the culture. The fraction of car drivers that has regularly ridden a bicycle through traffic probably is very close to 100%; the fraction that has done so recently or has a kid that has done so probably still is over fairly high.
Net effect is that, despite all those helmetless cyclists (many of which break traffic laws many times a trip), dutch traffic is one of the safest in the world.
- dbdr 12y agoA scientific paper on this topic: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1368064 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1368064 Its conclusion: "In jurisdictions where cycling is safe, a helmet law is likely to have a large unintended negative health impact. In jurisdiction where cycling is relatively unsafe, helmets will do little to make it safer and a helmet law, under relatively extreme assumptions may make a small positive contribution to net societal health." The negative health impact is "increased morbidity due to foregone exercise from reduced cycling" as a consequence of mandatory bicycle helmet laws.