2 ms·
Maybe they simply killed all the inhabitants in a more organized way. They were, after all, highly organized. My reading of James C. Scott's work on Southeast
by jessaustin 12y ago
Maybe they simply killed all the inhabitants in a more organized way. They were, after all, highly organized.
My reading of James C. Scott's work on Southeast Asia leads me to suspect a highly-organized state that controlled irrigable valley lands would wage war in order not to kill, but rather to enslave/enserf. (The various kingdoms of what would later become Thailand and Burma he writes about were after the Harrapan, but seem to have been similarly situated.) TFA actually mentions "So the Harappans appear to have been a very diverse lot", which may or may not be credible but is certainly consistent with the regular conscription of agricultural labor from afar. The idea is that in such a situation labor is the limiting resource, not land, water, or military might. The "nobility" always want to have more people at work in the fields than they can really control. Regular promotion of civic-minded peasants to military or bureaucratic service helps to ensure not just that their families will remain peaceable but that more families will be available to work soon.
Of course Scott documents this process more comprehensively for the societies he studies than would be possible for this much more ancient society.