7 ms·
Aaron Swartz shows his FBI file
- tptacek 17y agoSomeone got the backstory here?
- ajju 17y agoHe crawled a bunch (780 Gigs / ~20 million pages) of 'public' court records that were behind some kind of auth (pay) wall via a free trial and opened them up. Likely as a result of this crawling, the free trial was shut down. The pages he crawled constitute 20% of the total records. The feds then started investigating him. http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/steal-these-federal-records-okay-not-literally/ http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/steal-these-fede...
- rguzman 17y agoCourt records are, in general, public. Not 'public'. Just go to the library. However, PACER costs money and so do the favored online vendors (westlaw and lexis-nexis). Even if they aren't public. They should be. This stuff can be used as law -- precedents. The only valid objection I see is that there needs to be some process to protect the privacy of the people involved in the case. But that's second-order concern.
- ajju 17y agoThey should be public but are behind a wall. Thus, the quotes.
- igurari 17y agoPACER records are public, even that they cost money to access. So are most of the records on Lexis and Westlaw. Westlaw has tried to claim a copyright in certain annotations on the court documents, but they have no copyright in the text of the court records themselves.[1] [1] Matthew Bender & Co. v. West Publishing Co., 158 F.3d 693 (2d Cir. 1998) - http://bulk.resource.org/courts.gov/c/F3/158/158.F3d.693.97-7430.html http://bulk.resource.org/courts.gov/c/F3/158/158.F3d.693.97-...
- bbgm 17y agoI don't know much about what PACER includes and what exactly is covered by Westlaw and Lexis-Nexis, but Altlaw (http://altlaw.org http://altlaw.org) is a "free, full-text, searchable database of U.S. case law", and I've heard it being mentioned in the context of Lexis-Nexis. Also has the extra cool aspect of having been done by Stuart Sierra, whom all the Clojure folks around here probably know well.
- dpifke 17y ago"The only valid objection I see is that there needs to be some process to protect the privacy of the people involved in the case." There already is: you can file documents under seal or in redacted form. Most courts require you to do so if you're including information such as social security numbers. See, i.e. http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/invitationstocomment/documents/spr07-19.pdf http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/invitationstocomment/documents/s... Nothing that's available via PACER couldn't be read by walking down to the courthouse and requesting the physical file.
- jpwagner 17y agoBut when lawyers told Mr. Malamud and Mr. Swartz that they appeared to have broken no laws, Mr. Malamud sent Mr. Swartz a message saying, “You should just lay low for a while.” It's not illegal, so what's going on? Trying to collect $1.5MM?
- ajju 17y agoEither they think it is illegal or what is more likely is that anytime a sysadmin at a federal facility sees "atypical" behavior (as defined by them) they contact the feds. It is very unlikely that a sysadmin in the federal court system would think about whether the crawling session overloading his server is legal, forget moral and I am sure if he/she complains, the FBI is obligated to investigate. I am not saying this is what should happen but this is what likely happened.
- eli 17y agoWell, yeah, and those fees they're missing out on indirectly fund that sysadmin's department.
- gojomo 17y agoInterpretation of 'unauthorized access' is murky and there's a lot -- too much -- discretion in how access legitimacy and damages are evaluated. (See also: the submission last week about an author's estimation most people commit 'three felonies a day'.) In this matter, I'd bet the NYTimes coverage was more valuable in deterring prosecution than any legal counsel or even influential friends -- it meant any trumped-up narrative of nefarious intent would be fighting an uphill battle against the story already started in 'the paper of record'.
- falsestprophet 17y agoPACER data is now being collected and made available to the public by the RECAP project run by the Center for Information Technology Policy at Princeton. https://www.recapthelaw.org/how-it-works/ https://www.recapthelaw.org/how-it-works/
- grhino 17y agoHe's letting the report speak for itself. However, to save time, here's the URL to the New York Times article about what Aaron was doing http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html?ref=technology http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html?ref=tech...
- sachinag 17y agoWait, I thought Aaron was still in Cambridge. Did he come back to Chicago?
- aaronsw 17y agoCongratulations, you're better at finding me than the FBI.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoI didn't realize you were on HN. Your blog is an inspiration, and you are a great writer.
- arithmetic 17y agoI wonder if they're watching this HN post and going "Darn it! He's in Cambridge!" :)
- biohacker42 17y agoHouse is set on a deep lot, behind other houses on Marshman Avenue. This is a heavily wooded, dead-end street, with no other cars parked on the road making continued surveillance difficult to conduct without severely increasing the risk of discovery. Good to know.
- gojomo 17y agoGood thing it was just the FBI. The BATF might have classified this mysterious residence as some sort of cult compound and executed a no-knock raid with automatic weapons drawn.
- mattculbreth 17y agoAnd burnt down his house for good measure.
- dfranke 17y agoand then found a rubber band amid the rubble and seized it as an unregistered exotic firearm.
- kirubakaran 17y agoWell, I would too if a rubber band survived even when the whole house was burnt down.
- billswift 17y agoIt's the FBI that does the burning.
- lg 17y agofunny, this reminds me of the typical series of bugzilla comments i make when I'm debugging something. although this is a lot more detailed and thorough than I ever am...
- jyothi 17y agoand guess there is opportunity here. FBI agents can be excellent trainers for issue tracking and documenting projects. One of them should start a blog.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoThis is a case where I want to upvote you if you were being sarcastic, and downvote you if you were not. :)
- grhino 17y agoI'm curious about the entry "March 23, Manassas, VA". Did somebody from the FBI wonder why the case hadn't been closed yet?
- aaronsw 17y agoIt looks to me like the FBI was wondering why exactly this was a crime.
- ivankirigin 17y agoThe two accounts were responsible for downloading more than eighteen million pages with an approximate value of $1.5 million. Ha! Just because they charge $0.08 a page doesn't mean millions of page views online cost the same amount. This reminds of big drug catches that bring in tons of a controlled substance. The value is always given in street value, to make the efforts seem more substantial. Too bad they never publicize stats that show the police and FBI catch an infinitesimally small percentage of narcotics.
- borism 17y agoyeah, but I thought that's how judicial system in the US works - they add listed value of every single stolen/smuggled/whatever piece without any respect of mark-to-market for the whole batch? and that's kind of understandable - court has no time/expertise/willingness to figure out what "market" value of stuff should be.
- cliffy 17y agoYes, but if they determine punishment based on the value of 'goods' 'stolen', then hopefully they would get an accurate estimate of their value, not values inflated by law enforcement.
- qeorge 17y agoThe value of the 'stolen goods' here is easy to peg - it would have cost $.08 per page to obtain it legally. Whether or not the item is "worth" the price charged is not a matter for the court to decide. But in another way you're right - piracy is closer to counterfeit than theft. The original item is still available to its rightful owner to sell, although the copy arguably dilutes its value. (An old roommate of mine got busted by the FBI for large-scale piracy, so I'm more familiar with it than I want to be.)
- jonknee 17y agoNo, it would have (and did) cost $0 to access legally since it was accessed during a free trial.
- bootload 17y ago"... NCIS report for Aaron Swartz was negative ..." excellent. the other thing I don't get is flags should be going up if nothing bad is being turned up. as for being legal? I bet Pacer didn't think/want 20% of their records searched even if they opened them up. It's unstated but it would be fair to assume this.
- rglullis 17y agoPresumption of guilt?
- bootload 17y ago"... Presumption of guilt? ..." From what I've read here they (fbi) are doing simple background checks and want to talk. An interview/Talk doesn't imply a presumption of guilt. Having said that the fact that the "pacer" usage may have been excessive & someone has complained means anyone with excessive usage is going to be looked at. There is no black and white here but shades of grey. The records probably should be in public hands. The means used so far might be illegal. The tussle is "public access" vs "payment" and the action taken is making the right waves to hightlight the need for the former ~ http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html
- bootload 17y ago"... In his call to action, Mr. Malamud pointed to the free trial Pacer was offering and called for a “Thumb Drive Corps” to go to libraries with small-but-capacious “thumb drives,” plug them into computers, download as many court documents as they could, and send them to Mr. Malamud so that he could translate them them into a format that Google’s search software can read and put them on line. ..." There's a bigger picture (activism) here & maybe that's why the fbi has some interest. Having read this article ~ http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/us/13records.html I can now see why.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI learned a new word: exfiltrated http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/exfiltrated http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/exfiltrated
- LeChuck 17y agoDid you know of defenestration? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestration http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestration
- drenei 17y agoBill Waterson's Calvin & Hobbes poem introduced "defenestration" to me when I was young young young: "The monster, in his consternation, Demonstater defenestration". Its such a great word, and he was such a brilliant person, and a great inspiration. (sorry, completely off topic)
- shiranaihito 17y agoWho was a brilliant person?
- dmoney 17y agoI think he is currently alive. Cursory googling didn't reveal a death date.
- randallsquared 17y agoMore of an artistic death. :/
- kirubakaran 17y agoHow do you know that he is not secretly creating something amazing, to be released later? (This is my fantasy anyway)
- 17y ago
- babyshake 17y agoFor any of us using hosting services from Amazon, Google, Microsoft, etc. this should be a wakeup call. Next time we should coordinate, and pull a "Spartacus".
- tsally 17y agoBalls of steel mate. Respect. EDIT: Apparently your webserver is a little less resilient though. :-p
- jrockway 17y agoI love how the case was closed as soon as his lawyer got involved. "Oh damn, now we have to decide which law he broke."
- Luff 17y agoI'm mostly fascinated by their attempt to trick him to give up compromising information about his actions, by asking him for help on how to secure the system. If they would've asked me before reading this, I would've probably been too naive to ask for assurance that what I said wouldn't be used against me.
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, the police are good at this. I was investigated by the Secret Service once. Long story involving a sarcastic non-anonymous slashdot comment that was misinterpreted as a threat on the President's life. (Yeah, America is a strange place.) Anyway, the agents came to my house, made a vague accusation, and asked me if I knew anything about this. Having watched a bit of Law & Order, my answer was, "I think I need to talk to my lawyer". They persisted, and provided me with a lot of false information. At this point, I was annoyed at how wrong they were and said "yeah, I wrote this" and pulled up the comment in question. (Resolution: they read the comment, realized that someone Higher Up totally overreacted, and went away.) Basically, detectives are trained to extract information, and they are good at doing so. (Worth noting that after they got the information they wanted, they were generally pleasant people. Real life can be very much like television. :)
- kirubakaran 17y agoDon't talk to the police : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc [just in case there is someone who hasn't seen this before]
- DanielStraight 17y agoWhy does the guy sound like it's all a joke though?
- apollo 17y agoMr. Swartz is known to frequent "Hacker News," an underground forum operated by the "partner in crime" of convicted computer criminal Robert Tappan Morris.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- kiba 17y agoWhere did it say that in the FBI report? I took a look over it like 2-3 times and I can't find such mention.
- markerdmann 17y agoApollo is just making a joke.
- anovaskulk 17y agostill I dont't see why kiba should be down voted for not getting it, huh
- redcap 17y agoBased on the FBI's discovery of the subject's Facebook and LinkedIn profiles, they haven't yet found the subject's interest in the underground BBS known as 'Hacker News'.
- ttol 17y agoIf you would like to request your own FBI file, if you have one, the link with step-by-step instructions are: http://www.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/fprequest.htm http://www.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/fprequest.htm
- pyre 17y agoI had to request my FBI file once, and there was none. But the papers they send you are woefully misleading. It says something to the effect of 'Below are all the documents:' and under the rest of the page is blank. A 'None exist' would have been a little helpful. I kept thinking that they forgot to mail me some other page, but I was able to get by with what they gave me. IIRC the cost was $18. But don't send a personal cheque, or you'll get a call from some FBI processing person directing you to fax them credit card authorization or to completely refile the request. Mine took like 7 or 8 months to process. It was 3 or 4 months after I sent off the request before I got the call about the issue with payment through a personal cheque, which gives you an idea of what the backlog was probably like. This was around 2 years ago.
- there 17y agoand you have to give them your fingerprints which i'm assuming will then be on file for any other law enforcement agency to use.
- pyre 17y agoNot sure what the point of this comment is. Fingerprints are one of the requirements for requesting any law enforcement records (not court documents) so far as I know. It's not like this is some sort of insidious process where you don't realize they are going to take your fingerprints until it's too late for you to back out because there is a gun against your head. The entire process is basically: 1. Get fingerprints on a card of acceptable format by a 'professional.' 2. Send in fingerprint card, request and payment. As for me, it's hard to go through the immigration process without proving that you're not a criminal in your country of origin. That, and I have my fingerprints on record anyways. I had a class 3 gaming license in NY state. The NY State Police took my fingerprints for that.
- aristus 17y ago"A search for wages for Swartz at the Department of Labor was negative." :) I wonder how they will deal with more and more hacker-type people of independent means.
- joseakle 17y agoWhat´s the Long-Term Planning Committee for the Human Race ?
- arithmetic 17y agoThe Big Brother is watching. Who'd have thought?
- zandorg 17y agoI'm a UK citizen and I apparently have none, because I requested for me and Don Simpson (the deceased film producer), and they only said 'No file on Don Simpson' - didn't even say 'No file on [Zandorg]'.
- eli 17y agoWow, that's quick. I thought it typically took years to get a file out of the FBI.