4 ms·
> which disingenuously begs the question "Does God exist?" by insisting that anything we can't positively and fairly certainly explain by physical causes must b
by humanrebar 12y ago
> which disingenuously begs the question "Does God exist?" by insisting that anything we can't positively and fairly certainly explain by physical causes must be due to the Big Guy in the Sky.
I agree with your position, but in my view your summary of some well-considered theological positions undermines your on-topic points. To be sure, there are people with shallow appreciation of the metaphysical implications of the exploration of nature, but people with more rich views are easy to find and the typical viewpoint is probably more reasonable than you give credit to.
I hope you would consider being more measured and even-handed in your critiques of other viewpoints, especially when any responses would be off-topic.
Thanks.
- kbenson 12y agotjradcliffe's comment may have summarily dismissed some "well-considered theological positions" without explanation, but your defense of them with no evidence given is exactly the same but in the opposite direction. Rather than admonish, why don't you engage? If there are well-considered theological positions he's dismissing, I would like to hear them, and I'm sure others here would as well.
- saraid216 12y agoI, for one, appreciate that he did not actually derail the conversation.
- kbenson 12y agoConversations are threaded here. It's not like we are limited to one or a few channels of active communication at a time on this, like when speaking with a group of people. It's very easy to carry on multiple conversations at once and keep track, and only slightly harder to keep track while reading (and that can be mitigated more through one of the numerous browser extensions that add more features to HN, such as collapsing threads). I'm not sure it's possible to derail a conversation here, they just naturally splinter into multiple aspects and tangents, which take differing amounts of time to run to their conclusion. An strong argument can probably be made about how the larger conversations on a page may reduce involvement in some other conversations, but I'm not sure I buy that it's necessarily a bad thing without careful consideration of the pros and cons, and wouldn't classify it as derailment.
- saraid216 12y ago> (and that can be mitigated more through one of the numerous browser extensions that add more features to HN, such as collapsing threads) Yes, you have to be a power-user on HN to not be derailed. Not a UX person, are you?
- humanrebar 12y agobut your defense of them with no evidence given is exactly the same but in the opposite direction I am trying to avoid a digression (1) from the discussion of the Harappan civilization. I thought tjradcliffe might consider phrasing his comments more courteously next time. Of course he doesn't have to, but I believe it would be the right thing to do, especially if someone is interested in healthy discussion and separation of theological and secular issues. Anyway, the underlying questions about the role of God in nature and reality (and the exploration of it through science) are essentially metaphysical questions. Many people take materialism (all reality is physical, people are just fizzing bags of chemicals) as a first principle. Some of these people then dismiss other viewpoints as irrational. A different position would be that proving God exists is hard to impossible and to prove materialism is true is not any easier. Again, it's all metaphysical and a result of what first principles you start from. In a monotheistic view, scientific exploration and discovery only explain how the Designer created things. Even filling in gaps (like the fossil record) doesn't disprove God's existence, it could instead be showing that He created an internally consistent universe. Even old fossils cannot disprove God because He could have created the universe on Nov. 5, 1955 as if it had started with a big bang a long time ago. My point is that, like any metaphysical question, there is no definitive answer that can be reached from physical evidence. ...so I think we should give each other some slack by keeping things civil. This includes forgoing pot shots that can't fairly be responded to. 1. OK, so I digressed a little in hopes of convincing people to be more courteous. I'm not sure how to create a space on HN to discuss the religion and science topic. I'm happy to move this discussion elsewhere if people are interested and if the whole thing results in mutual understanding (as opposed to the typical polemics). EDIT: Wikipedia's summary on some ideas is serviceable: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_and_science#Cooperative http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_a... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_and_science#Perspectives_from_the_scientific_community http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_a... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_and_science#Individual_scientists.27_beliefs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_religion_a... ...and there are summaries of the interaction between science and different religions linked from that page.
- bad_user 12y ago
- Semiapies 12y agoThe God of the Gap fallacy is more or less the opposite of a thoughtful theological position.
- humanrebar 12y agoIt's not a fallacy as much as it's a straw man: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps#Criticism At any rate, I wasn't defending God of the Gaps as much as pushing back on culture of polemics.
- wtallis 12y agoIt's not a straw man - tjradcliffe wasn't misrepresenting the religious beliefs of any participant or subject of the discussion, just making an analogy between beliefs some people hold about history and beliefs some people hold about religion. And there are definitely plenty of flesh-and-blood people whose religious beliefs and arguments are that ill-founded.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoFor some reason I can't reply to your longer comment below, where you say: > I thought tjradcliffe might consider phrasing his comments more courteously next time. That actually was my more courteous phrasing :-) But I appreciate your civility, and in retrospect I should have left out "disingenously", which is needlessly inflamatory and distracting. I'll edit the comment to remove it. [Edit: unfortunately I guess there is a time-limit on the editability of comments, which has passed, so it'll have to stand as a permanent monument to my inherent irritability.] However, I do believe "the God of the Gaps" is an instance of question-begging: people who use it attempt to build the assumption "anything that cannot be explained by current physics must be assigned to God" into the mutually accepted context of the argument. They assume--and ask their opponent to assume--what they are setting out to prove, which is what "question begging" is. This is very much the mode of argument used by people promoting peaceful ancient civilizations, which only crop up in areas of ignorance, and which have a tendency to be proven false when more information becomes available--the Maya are not unique in this regard, but merely the most prominent example. This makes the point relevant to the article under discussion. I'll plug my book here as you sound like the kind of reader I was aiming for: http://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Theorem-TJ-Radcliffe-ebook/dp/B00KBH5O8K/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1416339457&sr=8-1&keywords=darwin%27s+theorem http://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Theorem-TJ-Radcliffe-ebook/dp/... , which as well as engaging in some egregiously speculative biology was written in part as a (hopefully) respectful attempt to engage intelligent and humane believers with alternative viewpoints on the relationship between science, religion, scripture and God (which was a struggle for me... I'm not an inherently respectful person, and clearly have more work yet to do.)
- DanBC 12y ago> For some reason I can't reply to your longer comment below, HN has built-in time delays that get longer for deeper threads.
- humanrebar 12y agoFair enough. I'll forgo rebutting except to say that "science or it doesn't exist" (not that you believe it) only works if you have a fully materialist viewpoint, which is another form of begging the question. It also precludes the possibility that the Creator likes internally his physical reality internally consistent. I mention that to say that I think a bit of humility about the limits of our "proof" helps us treat each other better. Which has to happen if we're going to have productive conversation. Anyway, thanks for listening. P.S. You might know where the term God of the Gaps came from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps#Criticism
- Alex3917 12y agoAgreed. As a rule of thumb, if you're arguing with someone about something they've spent more time learning/thinking about, you're probably wrong. While it's often said that reality has a well-known liberal bias, I find that this rule tends to apply equally across the aisle. This is also the problem with the Skeptic movement, in that it's fundamentally about discouraging people from reading books. (And note that I'm not saying the other person is probably right, only that you're probably wrong.)
- DanBC 12y ago> This is also the problem with the Skeptic movement, in that it's fundamentally about discouraging people from reading books. Where do you get the idea that scepticism is about discouraging people from reading books?
- Alex3917 12y agoTake a look at any of the popular skeptic publications, e.g. skepdic.com or sciencebasedmedicine.org, or at many of the numerous 'takedowns' of popular books that get posted on sites like HN or BoingBoing. The thing that most of these articles have in common is that they're generally designed to discourage people from reading the actual original sources. The whole value proposition is basically "you don't have to read this book about X, because we'll read it for you and tell you why it's wrong." The problem is that skeptics themselves are wrong as often as not. And worse, the people reading these blog posts and articles never figure it out because they've bought into the idea that the original sources aren't worth reading. And the skeptics know this, so often they wildly distort the arguments of the original authors since they know they can rack up millions of pageviews from people who will never be the wiser. Worse still, these people claim to be well-educated, when in reality they're basically destroying the Internet and undermining democracy. One site that I think gets it right is Amazon, because when people leave 1-star (or 5-star) reviews of a book without having actually read it or are wildly misrepresenting the ideas within, it's at least significantly easier (if not always easy) to tell this because of the surrounding context. But in general, while the ideas that skeptics profess to believe may be laudable, ultimately the whole worldview is like a game of telephone; even if the original analysis of any given subject was correct, once it's filtered through a dozen people who don't read books listening to other people who don't read books, all that's left is hollow dogma.