5 ms·
The article is slanted so heavily I had to turn my laptop at a 45-degree angle just to read it. Let's review: political speech is protected speech in the Unite
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
The article is slanted so heavily I had to turn my laptop at a 45-degree angle just to read it.
Let's review: political speech is protected speech in the United States. That means speech about how government and the politicians work. That's sacred.
Once you move away from purely political speech, you don't have an iron-clad right any more. There are limits to what you can and cannot say.
I don't think you can make a case that this speech is purely political, even though it involves political protest. So all the "I thought this could only happen in X nation" comments are way off-base. Don't be manipulated by people writing quasi news articles that have an agenda.
I'm sure the government has made the case to the judge that this type of speech is enabling people to commit a crime. I have no idea if that argument is sound or not, IANAL, but I'm pretty certain that the free speech argument here is bogus. He could have tweeted all day long about his political opinions without a problem.
Having said all of that, as a libertarian I'm really concerned about governments trying to control communication around protests. This should be an instructive legal case for those people, like me, that don't understand where the lines are currently drawn.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- steveklabnik 17y agoPeople tend to see it as a free speech issue because he's simply re-sending out public data. Each individual person could have just as easily listened in on a scanner. It's a bit counter-intuitive. The real issue is that scanner data isn't really public. You're allowed to listen to it, but not if you intend to commit a crime.
- tptacek 17y agoHe's not being prosecuted for the speech, he's being prosecuted for the action. You can say whatever you want. You can't intentionally help people commit crimes.
- steveklabnik 17y agoHis actions were speech. I was trying to comment about people's intuitions, not the legal definition. You can say whatever you want, as long as what you're saying isn't helping someone commit a crime.
- bena 17y agoBecause criminals have a great track record of following the law. Or, in other words, that law is only intended to punish people for making the data available via other channels. It explicitly targets people like this guy for simply disseminating public information. A guy who wants to rob a house will not care that using a police scanner to help commit a crime is illegal. He's already robbing a house, by using the police scanner data he can reduce the risk of being caught by incurring the additional cost of the penalty for using the scanner _if he is caught_. It's a non-law. It doesn't stop the criminals and criminalizes innocent citizens. Plus, the people being the government, when is it illegal to tell people what you are doing?
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoNot only that, but 47 CFR prohibits rebroadcasting a non-public signal and Tweets may be considered broadcasting. Even ignoring the reason he's doing this, the act iself may be prima facie illegal. See 47CFR73.1207 following "(c) The transmissions of non-broadcast stations may be rebroadcast under the following conditions:"