4 ms·
"Public information is public, I'm interested to see how they plan on proving the charges." Well, I think they intend to prove that he was not merely making pu
by ubernostrum 17y ago
"Public information is public, I'm interested to see how they plan on proving the charges."
Well, I think they intend to prove that he was not merely making public information public, but also directing people in how to evade arrest for what was -- rightly or wrongly -- illegal behavior.
I should note here that I don't particularly care what people think about whether it should be illegal to continue protesting after the cops order you to stop, all that matters in this case is that it is. I do, however, feel obligated to point out that going to jail has always been a part of civil disobedience, and people who refuse to face up to that strike me as a bit cowardly.
- steveklabnik 17y agoYeah. I typed poorly. Even then, the thrust of that sentence is legit: I'm not sure how they can prove that he intended to aid criminal activities. Even then, there are all kinds of shades of grey. I personally wanted to spread information about the event to as many people as possible. Would that enable people to protest longer by evading police? I guess so. Would it enable people who just wanted to stay away from any trouble to not come near? Yeah. Additionally, I'm unsure as to what the law says in this situation: if a policeman gives me an unlawful order, and I don't follow it, is that illegal? I was under the impression that it's illegal to disobey a lawfully given order. In any case, this whole thing is one big giant mess.
- Alex3917 17y ago"jail has always been a part of civil disobedience, and people who refuse to face up to that strike me as a bit cowardly." This sounds like something they teach in government-run schools...
- anshulk 17y agoI do, however, feel obligated to point out that going to jail has always been a part of civil disobedience, and people who refuse to face up to that strike me as a bit cowardly. So all those Iranian protesters should have simply courted arrests? No. There is a particular type of civil disobedience that requires not evading of arrests. Then there are some whose explicit purpose is to fill up jails (jail bharo andolans, literally "fill the jails protests" are an occasional feature in civil disobedience in India, a relic from the British era). I do not agree with your sentiment. I think you decide whether or not you court arrests based on the goals of the movement and the perceived progress of that goal based on doing so.
- ubernostrum 17y agoI wasn't saying they should actively seek to be arrested. I was saying that engaging in an illegal act -- even if you believe that act is justifiable and that your actions will help to bring about the end of something you view as evil -- carries a risk of arrest and jail time. People who aren't willing to accept that shouldn't engage in such acts, because in the real world there isn't always (and in fact often isn't) a happy ending.