5 ms·
I don't know if someone has submitted the original BuzzFeed report and it's just been buried/flagged...but let's give credit where credit is due: http://www.bu
by danso 12y ago
I don't know if someone has submitted the original BuzzFeed report and it's just been buried/flagged...but let's give credit where credit is due:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/bensmith/uber-executive-suggests-digging-up-dirt-on-journalists http://www.buzzfeed.com/bensmith/uber-executive-suggests-dig...
BuzzFeed's editor attended this dinner that was apparently "off-the-record", but such terms were not made clear to BuzzFeed, which is why we're even hearing this story. A few prominent journalists/publishers were in attendance, including Arianna Huffington, and I'm interested in what they have to say now that the horse is out of the barn.
But what really fascinates me is that even if Uber made clear that everything was off-the-record...what kind of batshitty, drunken affair was it such that an Uber executive could even think it'd be worthwhile to loudly muse about such a plan, as if no one present would ever leak such an abhorrent discussion. Either everyone was giving off a similar elitist vibe of hear-no-evil-speak-no-evil, or the Uber exec was saying these things jokingly while doing his impression of Richard Nixon. Or this exec is just incredibly stupid.
Edit: Also, Uber investors should take note of how wasteful this exec is. The Church of Scientology did the exact same thing in 2010...but they were able to hire a Pulitzer Prize winner, a former 60 Minutes producer, and the former executive editor of the top investigative news organization...all for less than $10,000 apiece (or at least the editor was, I'm assuming the other reporters received roughly the same rate)
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02/21/AR2010022103692.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02...
- guelo 12y agoIt was up twice and disappeared https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622003 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622003 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622088 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622088
- balladeer 12y ago> disappeared Down-voted or removed?
- lolwutf 12y agoI suspect there is a pro-Uber force on HN that downvotes any anti-Uber sentiment on HN, based on my own past experiences posting anti-Uber commentary. Whether or not that pro-Uber force is controlled by Uber, themselves, is unclear. One example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8328493 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8328493 ...notice 2 of 3 replies indicate surprise at how much I was being downvoted.
- narrowrail 12y agoI'm not pro-Uber; these services are irrelevant where I live. I just hate gossipy toxic threads, so I flag.
- balladeer 12y agoBut the article we are talking about are about something which is actually damaging and appalling. As for the truth or source, well, that is sth we always have to go with the journalist's integrity and then rely on analysis and discussion which we contribute to.
- 001sky 12y agoSometimes life is messy. Can't sweep everything under the rug. If nothing else, this is a good reminder to never trust the press. Too bad the press is the only tool we have to keep an eye on the other people you should never trust (politicians, ceos, etc). Instead, you should trust the anonymous internet commenters ! Oh, shit...what just happened?
- narrowrail 12y agoI like to browse HN via https://news.ycombinator.com/newcomments https://news.ycombinator.com/newcomments So, I just saw the comment and told why it may have "disappeared." I never read the OP, and don't intend to waste my time reading it. Apparently, many people don't like that I don't care about Uber. At all. Ironically, that just removed my flagging ability.
- deleted 12y ago
- ProAm 12y agoNo one has an "off-the-record" event and invites people from the media. Just saying.
- derwiki 12y agoWhich leads to the more interesting question: what is the angle to be played from leaking this?
- drivingmenuts 12y agoMaybe it's about shedding light on the pyschopaths that are running Uber?
- rhizome 12y agoI think the angle might occur earlier in the process. Saying something like this to a crowd containing journalists gives them initial targets when they see who writes about the story. That is, it's not so much that they could, it's that maybe it starts now.
- snowwrestler 12y agoPageviews.
- kylebrussell 12y agoThis is totally inaccurate. Members of the press are invited to off the record events all the time.
- ProAm 12y agoYou are 100% correct and the people inviting you know there is a slim chance everything heard will stay on the down low.
- 001sky 12y agoNot true at all. POTUS does a lot of off the record or background briefings. Its legit, mainstream media culture. "White House background briefings: Good journalism or anonymous government spin?" http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/white-house-background-briefings-good-journalism-or-anonymous-government-spin/2014/11/06/c4a45b58-65d3-11e4-836c-83bc4f26eb67_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/white-house-ba... This is all 'don't quote me on this' stuff. Attaching names to quotes in these situations is condisered unethical. Seems no different from an ethics perspectiv e than other types of "off the record" commenting (ie, "you can reveal X but not Y). But maybe somebody can school us (all) on the finer points here if we're reading it wrong.
- legohead 12y agocontext is key. someone could have asked him what is the most evil thing a company could do to journalists.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoOk, I'll ask the obvious question. Why is this "abhorrent"? Is it also "abhorrent" that Sarah Lacy and others at Pando report on the personal life of Uber and other tech execs? http://pando.com/2014/02/27/we-call-that-boob-er-the-four-most-awful-things-travis-kalanick-said-in-his-gq-profile/ http://pando.com/2014/02/27/we-call-that-boob-er-the-four-mo... http://pando.com/2014/10/06/venture-capital-and-the-great-big-silicon-valley-asshole-game/ http://pando.com/2014/10/06/venture-capital-and-the-great-bi... tl;dr; Why isn't turnabout fair play?
- rsobers 12y agoTo start, the Uber exec was suggesting that they do their dirt-digging anonymously ("Nobody would know it was us."). Also, those articles you linked to are examples of journalists providing commentary around direct quotes or facts/reports about the company. AFAIK, Sarah Lacy didn't dig up and expose personal information about people at Uber nor their families.
- klochner 12y agoI'm not sure if you really don't understand or are just arguing to be provocative, but I'll play along to make the point. It's morally equivalent to saying that you would fund a smear campaign against a judge or juror that ruled against you. It's one small step from making threats of physical violence to silence negative reporting. The press is considered an independent 3rd party bystander that is a crucial underpinning of any functioning democracy. Making aggressive threats against the press threatens the roots of civilized society, and is "abhorrent" because it's a tactic used by nearly every oppressive/fascist regime.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoAre journalists who dig up dirt without making threats a "small step" from people who use violence against people without making threats first? There is a core difference between threats of violence (such as what is done by oppressive regimes) and threats of telling the truth. And it's a bit silly to call Pando and Sarah Lacy an "independent 3rd party bystander". The entire enterprise is an extremely opinionated anti-tech enterprise - kind of like what the Uber execs proposed building, just with a slightly different target. It sounds like you are saying the people who call themselves independent media deserve special privileges that the rest of us don't get. Is that correct?
- the8472 12y ago"what kind of batshitty, drunken affair was it such that an Uber executive could even think it'd be worthwhile to loudly muse about such a plan" CEOs are just humans harboring things commonly called "emotions" just like everyone else. They are not the flawless machines that PR wants you to believe. That's why they and everyone else needs some privacy, to just entertain idle thoughts that are neither politically correct nor moral to implement. Those "could spend a million dollars" are basically a white collar version of "I'd love to take them out to the back alley and punch their faces because they make me angry". Even when you know that it would be stupid, criminal and in no way a good way to resolve an issue such thoughts still may pass everyone once in a while. I generally don't think that holding "public figures" to flawless standards is a good thing, it just asks for them to play a game of pretend, putting up a facade all the time. The moments they think they are in private those fake masks fall. Remember for example the event were Obama and Sarkozy call Netanyahu a liar when they think the microphones are off.
- robgibbons 12y agoIt's one thing to afford a public figure some margin of fallibility for being human. It's another thing entirely for that executive to publicly express authoritative, aggressive behaviors towards potential dissidents. This is some dictator shit right here.
- the8472 12y agoBut it wasn't publicly. That's why I said that everyone needs some privacy and it certainly is also an aspect why the notion of "off the record" exists. And while I wouldn't call it "dictator shit" since a CEO is not a government official with direct power over his targets, it would certainly be a smear campaign which I wouldn't condone. I'm operating on the assumption that people say many things that they do not intend to follow up with deeds, especially when they think they are not talking publicly.
- robgibbons 12y agoPrivate expression is fine in your own home. When you spout off about attacking journalists, in front of journalists, you are asking for it.