5 ms·
Most corporations are simply unable to contribute back. But within the IT industry I would disagree that most corporations simply leach. Netflix, LinkedIn, Twi
by threeseed 12y ago
Most corporations are simply unable to contribute back. But within the IT industry I would disagree that most corporations simply leach.
Netflix, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Apple for example have been outstanding contributors to "open source".
- pjmlp 12y agoI work with Fortune 500 companies since the .com days and I can count with my hands, how many times I saw anything being returned back. Yes, there are Netflix, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Apple and a few others. And how many corporations are there in the world?
- _delirium 12y agoI also have rarely seen much contributed back in my limited experience, especially outside of the "tech industry" proper. I've noticed the lack especially in "big engineering" (oil & gas, CAD, aeronautics, etc.), and recently also in "data toolkit" type markets like proprietary bioinformatics toolkits, data-mining toolkits, GIS packages, etc. I don't work there myself fwiw, but for various reasons have spent some time observing development practices. BSD-licensed code is included in tons of profitable proprietary products in those areas that have never contributed back a line to the original project. Much of the time they drag their feet on even giving any acknowledgment to the project they took the code from. Really they would prefer to pretend they invented it all themselves, 100% Custom Proprietary Solution, with no acknowledgement whatsoever. They do typically grudgingly make the legally required copyright acknowledgment, but in the "New BSD" variant of the BSD license that removed the traditional requirement for acknowledgment to be prominent, that's pretty easy to bury in fine print in the most obscure place you can concoct (a random .txt file on the install medium, or somewhere in the fine print at the end of a manual, are two popular options). A plausible counterargument is that these types of companies wouldn't contribute back anyway: they just aren't interested. In that case the practical choice is between letting them free-ride off your code (BSD) or not letting them use it at all (GPL), because they aren't going to make a choice that involves contributing back, regardless of your license. In that case I can see people leaning towards BSD. But I'd personally lean towards GPL, because I think that, at least often, shutting these companies out of the ability to use open-source code would probably be a net win for society. But it's hard to prove that. And this probably depends significantly on your goals and the kind of software you write.
- pnathan 12y agoI observe that BSD/MIT et al are just ways to give away profits to large corporations without returning value to the original developer. I release all my personal code under some flavor of GPL - LLGPL, LGPL, or AGPL3 - because I personally refuse to let my work be exploited like that.
- akerl_ 12y agoDo you have some sort of evidence for that observation?
- pnathan 12y agoRoughly, look at any mobile software you use and look at the open source licenses. Note how much of that code gets pushed back into the rest of the world. For even more excitement, look at major non-tech companies and see how much they contribute back. In my idle memories, I think Walmart might be the only one I've personally seen... The GPL (or its stronger and younger sibling, the AGPL), contractually require release of source to the user.
- emidln 12y agoThat doesn't do anything. Large corporations don't have to distribute your software for internal usage. It can reach hundreds of thousands of employees and still be internal.
- axman6 12y agoLike how Apple, Google, Intel, Nvidia etc. are exploiting the LLVM project? IMO, the need for GPL style restrictive licences isn't backed up by facts; more open licences encourage commercial use and open development.
- lmm 12y agoThere's a game I own that I'm only able to play on my computer because its developer accidentally used a GPLed audio library, and found their best course was to GPL the game engine. Internet volunteers then ported that engine to other platforms. So as an end user the GPL really has made things better for me than a BSD-style license would.
- ekianjo 12y agoIf you put Apple in the list you should probably put Google too. Google has done way more to "Open Source" than Apple ever did.
- Demiurge 12y agoWebKit, llvm, are pretty important in that they altered the fundamental of present day by being so openly used. It's apples ehm to oranges at that level, but what has Google contributes of the likes?
- ekianjo 12y agoEasy. Android (Open Source, while the source is not always released right after a new version is out), running on most Smartphones over the world. Pretty big contribution I'd say, especially in a world turning Mobile-First. Chromium. Go. I'd say their contributions are far from negligible.
- progers7 12y agoUntil they forked Blink, Google was the top contributor to WebKit: http://blog.bitergia.com/2013/02/06/report-on-the-activity-of-companies-in-the-webkit-project/ http://blog.bitergia.com/2013/02/06/report-on-the-activity-o...
- Demiurge 12y agoThey might have contributed the most over time, but we probably don't disagree who was more important to the whole WebKit party getting going.
- icebraining 12y agoThe KHTML developers?
- mda 12y agoAndroid, Chromium, V8, Go, Dart, Guava, Guice, GWT, Angular, Polymer, Blink, WebM, and probably hundreds of libraries.