3 ms·
>In essence, you're also making claims about the state of the poor In essence, I'm not. I'm responding to a bad argument. You can't just go on a rant about uni
by pessimizer 12y ago
>In essence, you're also making claims about the state of the poor
In essence, I'm not. I'm responding to a bad argument. You can't just go on a rant about unicorns on the South Pole, and when people tall you you don't know what you're talking about, ask them all to prove you wrong. That's not how reason works.
edit:
>Why not start the discussion by asking him what he means by "poor choices and personal vices"?
Because there's nothing in this ancient, stereotypical rant of the comfortable since antiquity that gives me the indication that I have something to learn about the poor from the person who happens to be reciting it in this thread. I've been poor, and I know poor. If there are some statistics that tell me that I've just accidentally been in a bubble of the wonderful, hardworking, generous, and thoughtful poor (mixed with a few spoilers) I'm open to it and happy to read it.
- zo1 12y ago>"In essence, I'm not. I'm responding to a bad argument. You can't just go on a rant about unicorns on the South Pole, and when people tall you you don't know what you're talking about, ask them all to prove you wrong. That's not how reason works." And if I had no prior-opinion OR evidence on unicorns in the South Pole, I'd equally be skeptical of your claims that there aren't any, as I'd be of the guy that claims there are. I'd ask you both for some basic stats/research on the matter, which is what I tried to point out.
- dkhenry 12y agoExcept in this case we have clear evidence for one side ( which is now provided ), but we still live in the internet where no rational conversation can take place.
- zo1 12y ago>"but we still live in the internet where no rational conversation can take place." Agreed, especially if you have a more controversial viewpoint. I know that all too well.