4 ms·
An Overdose of Copernicus? Our Universe Might Yet Be Special (2013)
- Retric 12y ago"Not only that, but make tiny changes in even the initial conditions of the Big Bang and you end up with a sterile universe. Cosmologically speaking, it’s like we won every lottery every imaginable. From that vantage point we are special—crazy special." Assumes life as we know it is the only option. Tweak a few parameters and you could easily have inelegant life growing up in stars or the 'void' between galaxy's. Life might operate at timescales billions of times faster or trillions of times slower etc. But, rarely do such articles consider all the possible universes we don't inhabit. PS: There is something of a reverse anthropic principle at work where observed life adapts to best exploit the physics of it's universe.
- waps 12y agoIn that respect Stephen Wolfram's book "A new kind of science" is kind of interesting. It explores the laws of nature by ignoring the ones we have, instead coupling a numbering system to all possible sets of natural laws, and simulating the resulting universe. It does seem to indicate that what you're saying is wrong. The vast majority of combinations of physical constants would never lead to complexity, and whatever form life takes, I think we can agree a minimum level of complexity is a necessity. That minimum level is quite substantial. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_eC14GonZnU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_eC14GonZnU Most "laws" immediately lead to a universe with a uniform energy level throughout, or lead to complete absense of matter and total darkness. No matter how life adapts, it can't adapt to that. Less common are oscillating universes, that evolve in an entirely predictable periodic pattern. The remainder is mostly total randomness, static. None of these will support life. But ... then there are a few interesting ones. It would be very interesting to explore more of this space. Does "rule 110" contain life ? (it's Turing-complete and chaotic, so it "contains" hello world and windows 95 ... does it contain you & me ?) The Copernican principle is mostly a very useful discipline tool. When you see something weird, whether it's a measurement or output from a computer program, your initial reaction should not be "it's a cosmic ray !", "a coincidence !", or "a miracle !" because it isn't. It's something that's part of the behavior of the measured system. That should be your base assumption. It's a bug, it's a loose wire, it's ..., not a cosmic ray/random/miracle. That's the Copernican principle. But that is entirely different from saying cosmic rays/random chance/miracles don't happen at all. In fact, I'd say it almost proves they do, as we've all seen a program that behaves one way on 9999 out of 10000 cores and yet fucks up on the last one. At some point you just have to give up on Copernicus, and say "Something flipped that (&#@$(#@$ bit, and it wasn't me". It simply shouldn't be your first assumption. As I've seen it put on a colleague's desk : It's perfectly explainable Your calculation is wrong You're reading the wrong file You're reading the right file in the wrong directory You're reading the right file in the right directory on the wrong disk You're looking at the wrong tab You're looking at the wrong side of the screen You're attempting to execute a C++ program with the python interpreter Your "float" is an integer You're reading the file, but overwriting the variable before you calculate on it You're reading correctly, but overwriting the variable after you calculate on it That if says the opposite of what you think it says You have overwritten your input file You have overwritten your output file Your matlab licence has expired (it goes on for quite a bit more, but you get the gist)
- wbhart 12y agoThe issue isn't that there couldn't be life as we know it. It is that life wouldn't have had time to evolve, e.g. the universe would disappear in far too short a time or that the expansion would be so rapid that not even stars and galaxies would form. In other words, no life of any kind is even conceivably possible in those universes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lomnakkus 12y agoIf the constants of nature were completely arbitrary you might be right, but I don't think anyone's suggesting that they necessarily are. Some (combinations of) constants might represent underlying principles that we just haven't discovered yet. The multiverse hypothesis which the article mentions isn't really satisfactory intuitively, but these days particle physics isn't really in the realm of intuition at all. It does run into the so-called "measurement problem". (Which may have a hypothesized solution these days for all I know, I'm not even a layman.) Personally, I think the question of entropy is more interesting and fundamental. It's essentially the question "Why did the universe start with such low entropy?". Sean Carroll has quite a few talks up on "the tubes" about that question, and I find it fascinating. EDIT: Sorry about the rambling, not particularly in a state to talk about big cosmological questions at the moment. Hopefully you'll find it useful nonetheless.
- Retric 12y agoStars and galaxies are not prerequisites for life. So, sure there is probably a much larger set's of universes that can't support life than can. However, if you want to compare {universes that can support life} / {total universes} then you can't just look at carbon based life and assume that's the end all be all.
- iamthepieman 12y agojust the average of multiple universes wouldn't tell you much without the standard deviation. The article didn't go into it at all, but do we have any theories about just how different universes within the multiverse are from each other? In other words, is there any reason to believe that we are on a bell curve vs a truly random distribution.
- moomin 12y agoThe weak anthropic principle (or, frankly, a simple application of Bayes' law) observes that, since it would be quite hard to be a living observer in a lifeless universe, selection bias means that any observable universe you actually live in will appear to be "fine-tuned".
- vorg 12y ago> any observable universe you actually live in will appear to be "fine-tuned" Who is "you"? Monkey, Mankind, Messiah, Mutant, or Machine? To elaborate... Monkey: If chimps or even dinosaurs were sufficiently self-aware, then why did life continue to evolve to humans, and not die off after the first animal conscious of its surroundings. But if such consciousness isn't enough... Mankind: Why did humans multiply beyond the first one to ponder about existence. It seems there might have been only a few thousand humans alive at some point in time about 100,000 yrs ago, so if the first human to draw speculations about an after-life on a cave wall lived before then, why didn't humans go extinct soon after? Messiah: Or was it a the existence of a single special human at some time in the past or future who must observe the universe? Or a single instant in the life of that special human? The instant the Buddha achieved enlightenment, or any number of other examples which make the weak anthropic principle be a religious issue not a scientific one. Could certain fine-tunings of the earth that don't appear related to the evolution of intelligent life, such as the Sun and Moon having the exact same size when visible from Earth, exist to contribute to that moment of enlightenment of such a single human? Mutant: Why does the distribution of the planets in the solar system appear to be fine-tuned for inter-gallactic space travel? There's only about 10 other solar objects with gravity comparable to Earth's and hence suitable for long-term civilization. The Moon has already been walked on, and humans can easily build large contained cities there using telepresent robots with a 1 second response time. Then Mars and Mercury with semi-intelligent robots to cater for the much longer response time, then Jupiter's 4 large moons to provide humankind with experience of much longer travel times, then a single moon of Saturn to eliminate any initial choice of target, then the huge gap skipping Uranus's lack of sizable moons to Neptune's Tritan, and finally the thousands of years needed to terraform Venus. By then humankind will have trained up, apparently serendipitously, for inter-gallactic travel. Perhaps some evolved version of super-intelligent humans will experience some future version of consciousness we present day humans can't conceive of and the Universe is actually fine-tuned for them. Machine: Or perhaps humans build the consciousness the Universe is fine-tuned for.