6 ms·
Unraveling NSA's TURBULENCE Programs
- fit2rule 12y agoThis is so disturbing. I honestly feel that with every one of these revelations, my interest in the technology world is degraded more and more. The existence of such heinous things as the TAO, and its tendrils, brings on a serious depression. Just who do these people think they are, to defeat our lives so completely, for their own sakes? Despicable.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThey have a very pro-end-justifies-the-means attitude. Just listen to DoJ defend most of the illegal spying they get caught with. They keep saying "...but it's effective!". As if that makes it less illegal. The sad part is the mass surveillance done by the NSA, by and large, isn't even that. Maybe it's effective for economic spying, or spying on political leaders, or hacking into other countries infrastructures, or even helping to assassinate random people in Middle East who happen to be in the area of "terrorists", who may or may not be guilty of terrorism. But it's so easy to just press that drone's button, especially when it happens so far away from home and with nobody to hold them accountable...so who cares, I guess? It's easier and cheaper to kill someone with perhaps 20 percent chance of being a terrorist, than not doing that (I think that's their attitude towards this). Autonomous killer drones will only make this problem 10 times worse, as they can kill many more such people, faster. And with every innocent life taken this way, 10 more people ending up hating America (but not for its freedoms). But so far there's no evidence that this mass spying would actually help with its promoted and intended goal - "stopping the next 9/11". If anything, there's probably evidence against it. A bigger haystack is just that - a bigger haystack in which to find the needle, and way more false leads, with biased algorithms that lead to the harassment of tens of thousands, if not millions, and without them ever knowing why they are even harassed in such a way.
- drcomputer 12y ago> and way more false leads, with biased algorithms that lead to the harassment of tens of thousands, if not millions, and without them ever knowing why they are even harassed in such a way. If there is one thing I feel like people should understand about algorithms and computers, it is about this. Just because something is computed does not make it more accurate. It just means greater precision based on the specifications and initial assumptions. More inaccurate calculations does not equal better. Greater dependency on machines to do our reasoning for us, I am partially concerned, has our species ignoring their own capacity to reason for themselves. The thing I can't understand is how these people who do spy have any sense of self of which to reason with. The more they focus on that which exists outside of themselves, the harder it is to discern between what they are and what they fight against. I wish people would just honestly, sit down for like a year or something, and take a good long look in the mirror and introspect, rather than everything being action action action. Just because everything looks like it's moving doesn't mean it actually is.
- acqq 12y agoJust as the historical perspective, the automatic data processing was used even before electronic computers, and even by the Nazi regime to support genocide: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_during_World_War_II http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_during_World_War_II That's why it's important to actively care and to organize the society to minimize the potential for the undesired use of the possibilities given by the technology: the technology can amplify both the good and and the bad acts. The society has the chance to influence that easier before the tipping points and only after a lot of harm already being done after them. On another side, once the tipping point is reached, even if some system didn't exist before, it would be implemented fast. The position of the "consumers" in the digital world is also something that has some interesting comparisons: http://www.wired.com/2012/11/feudal-security/ http://www.wired.com/2012/11/feudal-security/
- drcomputer 12y agoIn theory, I absolutely agree with you. In practice, every choice as to how to care and organize society become a question of what to control and what not to control. Who can be trusted, and who can't trusted. Then it just seems to go in a circle. Regulation on top of regulation. People make judgments and claim they are assertions rather than assumptions, based on correlative and observationally biased inferences. The system becomes deterministic based on individual impulse, rather than caution, patience, and 'opened' trust. With individual impulse, it becomes a question of who decides to shape society, rather than how society is shaped. Whoever makes a move first has an advantage in the short term. But this has the potential to be twisted by greed, selfish desire, and delusions of grandeur, or the idea that "what works for me will work for you". Then things get directed towards tipping points. People start believing in power hierarchies, groups, differing orders and levels of intelligence and ability as intrinsic and permanent properties of their existence. And so the pendulum keeps swinging.
- diydsp 12y ago> my interest in the technology world is degraded > brings on a serious depression Yes I feel this way, too. It's come a long way from learning GR and HGR in Apple Basic. Telephony modems were fun... Usenet was interesting, the Internet over ethernet was fun but people started to take it seriously... Spam was an amusing nuisance. Around the time of LAMP and RealAudio, circa 1997-2000, things got a little shaky for me. The seriousness level increased. Eternal September then ubiquitous cellphones, business and lifestyles started to depend heavily on the internet. Now, toddlers with tablets, worldwide death threats, mass surveillance, daily international cyberwar, full-on regimented, intense web development and marketing, gate-of-the-month... It's no longer a strange, miraculous garden full of surprises, but more like other mediums, an appropriated, militarized and polluted playground of propaganda, a staging ground for real-life violence. An electronic Jungian shadow. I suppose most of the NSA's work is the result of our own base, human natures, a reflection of our failures at international reconciliation. We can't have a naive internet, because the real world is still too violent. With international hatred and war, massive inequality, we can't set up a sweet, pleasant, fun, interesting electronic bridge between one another because too many people want to use that bridge to board and destroy the rest. But we're so damned determined to have this internet before we civilize humanity, we have to have the NSA build all these paranoiac watch points to prevent our own destruction. It just wears me out...
- nishonia 12y ago> I suppose most of the NSA's work is the result of our own base, human natures... It is in the best interest of the state to cripple the internet as much as possible. This isn't to protect you, it is to control you - ranchers don't build fencing to protect cattle. Why would any state want you to be able to freely communicate with the "violent, hating, warlike, unequal" others? Aside from generating tax revenue through commerce, there is no reason.
- gfrench27 12y agoLet me focus on one phrase you mentioned: "people started to take it seriously". it was serious from the beginning. Experts on both sides disagree and this disagreement will continue.
- serve_yay 12y agoI can understand that. For me this is just what I already assumed them to be doing and find it all rather unsurprising. I would rather have your mindset, I think.
- nishonia 12y agoThis whole thing has made for some interesting people watching opportunities. I think the only people who were completely unsurprised by all this are those who: 1) Understood the technical requirements to pull this level of surveillance off. 2) Understood that the government does not love them. You combine the two to arrive at the conclusion that if something is within the government's ability, and it furthers its own interests, it will do it. The reaction from the folks in group 1 have been the most entertaining, as it is apparently easier for people in group 2 to adapt to changes in technology.
- keyme 12y agoYou had to have been very naive for these revelations to be so shocking to you. You use Google for email? Don't be surprised that someone else is reading it. You have willingly and continuously divulged your personal data to an unknown number of people. You use someone else's cables for data transfer? You are willingly broadcasting your information to anyone who's willing to listen. You're blindly trusting an encryption system made by some strangers? Be aware of the consequences. You're merely trusting someones unwillingness to risk their reputation (if anything at all). True security and privacy are achievable, but you need to put effort into that. If you're walking around 24/7 with a GPS tracker and listening device in your pocket willingly, don't go crying over someones ability to collect this information for their own gain.
- mike_hearn 12y agoWould love to know more about the "Pairing and Crypt attacks" along with "Cryptovariable management". Probably the pairing here is referring to the pairing between client and server rather than the cryptographic technique of using pairings ... but it seems this hasn't surfaced in any of the other snowden docs. I often wish the journalists working on that story had released more source material.
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoThey're only slides. We don't have audio of the presentations. :) I did wonder about that, but no "common" internet encryption protocols use pairing-friendly (in the open source cryptographic community sense) primitives. I think you're about right and it probably refers to matching public and private keys for CAs in SSL/TLS, looking up suitable intermediate CAs, for which they may have a few keys stashed away. They don't seem enthusiastic to wave them around much, however. I believe they probably have long-term cryptologic cracking capability (HPC) including 1024-bit RSA, but probably not 2048-bit. Maybe MD5? Maybe SHA1? Look at the long list of trusted CAs in a browser, and try to map all the intermediates they've ever signed. You may find a few likely candidates.
- EthanHeilman 12y agoTo extend your statements: * breaking 1024-bit RSA is believed to be well within the resources of the NSA given public research/attacks.[0] * MD5 is already completely broken in the public research and the NSA has used MD5 collisions in malware attacks that are independent of public methods[1]. * RC4 has been attacked for a number of years, and someone who has seen unreleased Snowden documents claimed that the NSA has the ability to break RC4 in realtime[2]. Plenty of HTTPS traffic is protected by RC4. [0]:"One estimate is made by Shamir & Tromer (2003) in their hypothetical TWIRL device. They suggested that for "a few dozen million US dollars", a hardware device could be built to break a 1024-bit RSA key within around a year. Franke et al (2005) similarly estimate a cost of 200 million dollars2 for a machine to factorise a 1024-bit number in one year. If these cost estimates are accurate, it's safe to assume that the NSA has built such a machine (unless they have another way of breaking RSA more efficiently). And by Moore's Law alone, we'd assume that their machine takes considerably less than a year." http://www.javamex.com/tutorials/cryptography/rsa_key_length.shtml http://www.javamex.com/tutorials/cryptography/rsa_key_length... [1]: "He discovered that for this spy malware an as yet unknown cryptographic attack variant of his own MD5 attack is used." http://www.cwi.nl/news/2012/cwi-cryptanalist-discovers-new-cryptographic-attack-variant-in-flame-spy-malware http://www.cwi.nl/news/2012/cwi-cryptanalist-discovers-new-c... [2]: "RC4 is broken in real time by the #NSA - stop using it." https://twitter.com/ioerror/status/398059565947699200 https://twitter.com/ioerror/status/398059565947699200
- r0h1n 12y agoSo if you're a VPN user, you get extra special attention from the NSA. > In the case of VPN traffic, a system called HAMMERSTEIN identifies the traffic and sends the metadata to a database called TOYGRIPPE. The TOYGRIPPE database is a “repository of VPN endpoints”14 that is used by targeting officers to determine if that computer should be a target for further exploitation 13. The TURMOIL VPN module also looks up the IP information in a database called KEYCARD to determine if the target should be tasked for targeted SIGINT collection or to recover the VPN key. Of special note is that this VPN traffic passes through a system called “TE-VPN PIQ Blade.” PIQ refers to the PICARESQUE ECI marking 38, which is associated with BULLRUN 16. The BULLRUN program is NSA’s effort to weaken and exploit encryption that protects digial SIGINT, whether by finding bugs in cryptographic algorithms or by manipulating standards bodies or companies into weakening encryption tools. It is safe to assume that PIQ is a compartment that contains the details of a cryptologic attack against a specific VPN technology (or technologies), which the NSA/GCHQ either found or paid for.
- hammock 12y agoC.f. stenography, hiding in plain sight, etc. Drawing less suspicion generally, and if you are in the "mainstream" e.g. a crowded place, your signal becomes more difficult to parse out of the chaos.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- justcommenting 12y agoif you've ever seen TLS Error: local/remote TLS keys are out of sync or Authenticate/Decrypt packet error: packet HMAC authentication failed while using openvpn, you can expand the list of potential causes.