5 ms·
I hope Daala will put an end to this mess. But even though Opus is mandatory now, it didn't yet translate into support by Apple and MS for instance for regular
by shmerl 12y ago
I hope Daala will put an end to this mess. But even though Opus is mandatory now, it didn't yet translate into support by Apple and MS for instance for regular music and Web audio. Their historic sickening opposition to open codecs is not easy to dismantle. Apple still doesn't even support FLAC, just because they like to make things messy for everyone.
By the way, what happened with Nokia's attacks on VP8? Were they refuted by Google or they were validated by some courts?
- derf_ 12y agoCisco hired a law firm to write a summary, which they made public: http://www.duanemorris.com/memo/VP8Compilation.pdf http://www.duanemorris.com/memo/VP8Compilation.pdf TL/DR: VP8 was found not to infringe one patent. The other proceeding in the German courts was stayed until it was determined if the patent was valid. Before that could happen, Nokia and HTC settled all of their outstanding suits for some undisclosed amount. All remaining actions between those two parties were dismissed without prejudice (including the VP8 lawsuits). Separately, Google is still proceeding with two lawsuits in Germany to get the Nokia patents declared invalid.
- shmerl 12y agoThanks, that sounds pretty promising.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoNokia just announced an Android tablet, running Lollipop 5.0 (which requires VP8 and VP9), it also uses an intel chipset with VP8 encode and decode. Does that trigger any of the reciprocal patent grant thingies that VP8 (and 9?) have and remove Nokia's patents from the picture?
- eridius 12y ago> Their historic sickening opposition to open codecs What are you talking about? I'm not aware of any historic opposition to open codecs at Apple. Hell, they're still big into AAC, which is an open codec. And even ALAC is now open source and royalty-free.
- gcp 12y agoHe meant patent-free codecs, not open codecs. i.e. Vorbis, FLAC, Opus, Theora, VP8.
- shmerl 12y agoYes, free codecs probably would be a better term. Open here refers not just to the availability of open source tools, but them being open for entry for any participant (including for example projects and individuals who can't pay any license fees).
- shmerl 12y ago> And even ALAC is now open source and royalty-free. Nothing stops them from supporting FLAC as well except their nasty attitude in general. FLAC is actually used by many services which sell music, unlike ALAC. AAC is nowhere patent free.
- anon1385 12y ago>Nothing stops Mozilla from supporting JPEG2000 except their nasty attitude in general. JPEG2000 is actually supported by many image editors, unlike APNG. I think in most of these cases the real reasons are more mundane - spending the resources on supporting extra formats would give them no competitive advantage (and a significant cost in terms of maintenance and security). It sucks, but that's the capitalist system for you.
- gcp 12y agoThat analogy seems to ignore that FLAC is literally the lossless format that is used everywhere - except on Apple devices, and has not and never had patent concerns. On top of that, ALAC is clearly based on FLAC but has effectively been worsened. It is pure and 100% literal NIH. The same can't be said for JPEG2000. Not even close. Nobody's complaining Apple doesn't support actual MPEG ALS, for example.
- 12y ago
- bhaak 12y agoDespite the gazillions of dollars they have earned, Apple is really constrained when it comes to software development. They don't have the man power to stray far from their focused feature set. Just look at the mess that iOS 8.0 is. I don't know if they are not willing to hire more capable people or if they just don't care as long as the money pours in (that could bite them in the long term though). FLAC is a niche feature and those features are usually only supported if someone at Apple has a personal interest in supporting it and if it doesn't get vetoed by the power that be. In the case of FLAC it might even have been the latter as you could describe FLAC (not entirely correct) as the codec that let's you digitize your CDs losslessly. That view would put it in competition with iTunes (320kps AAC/MP3 ought to be enough for anybody?) and additionally, if you are a true Apple follower, you don't have a CD drive anymore anyway.
- Osmium 12y ago> That view would put it in competition with iTunes (320kps AAC/MP3 ought to be enough for anybody?) Apple has its own lossless audio codec that's supported by iTunes called ALAC. Created in 2004, it was initially propriety but as of 2011 it is now open source and royalty free under the Apache License. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Lossless http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Lossless
- coob 12y agoNo idea why you're getting downvoted, we use ALAC in production workflows. Prior to being open sourced it was also successfully reverse engineered in 2005: http://craz.net/programs/itunes/alac.html http://craz.net/programs/itunes/alac.html
- yjm 12y agoFor the record VP8 sucks for anyone who needs to support it because it eats up to 7 times more resources than h264 does for transcoding.
- gcp 12y agoSomeone is confusing (crappy) implementations with standards.