3 ms·
> The consensus interpretation is that FTL is not possible in normal space I don't think this really makes sense, because "normal space" is not a well-defined
by pdonis 12y ago
> The consensus interpretation is that FTL is not possible in normal space
I don't think this really makes sense, because "normal space" is not a well-defined term.
What our current relativistic theories say is that spacetime contains a causal structure marked out by light cones, and nothing can move outside the light cones. In certain spacetimes (like the one that describes our expanding universe), it is possible to assign coordinates to events so that it looks like objects are moving apart "faster than light", but when you look at the light cones in those same coordinates, you can confirm that the objects are still moving inside the light cones.
> new space in between these points is being created
This isn't really part of the physics of the expanding universe; it's an interpretation that some people put on it. There's nothing in the actual math that corresponds to "new space being created".
> space can "flow" faster than the speed of light on the far side of event horizons
This isn't really part of the physics either; it's an interpretation (part of what's often called the "river model" of black holes) that can help with visualization, but again there's nothing in the actual math that corresponds to "space flowing faster than light".
> ways of doing these manipulations may well exist
According to our current theories, any such manipulations would require what is called "exotic matter". There are good physical reasons to think that it is not possible to create exotic matter, especially in the quantities we would need to "hack spacetime" (nice phrase!) on the scales we would want to do it. Given that, I don't think it's fair to say that "FTL is most likely possible in theory"; I would say it's most likely not possible on our best current theories.
- Udo 12y ago> I don't think this really makes sense, because "normal space" is not a well-defined term. You are of course technically correct. > There's nothing in the actual math that corresponds to "new space being created". True, and this might end up being a horrible crutch, but right now it helps me to conceptualize what's (possibly) going on. I'm sorry for having exported this hypothesis into a context where it shouldn't have been said without additional qualifiers, but it's too late now to edit it out. > This isn't really part of the physics either; it's an interpretation That's actually one I stand by. In the end, this seems really more about how you choose to express ideas in a language that doesn't have any exact words for things going on in an object that lies far outside of our normal experience. You might (and I suspect you do) choose to not say anything at all and let equations speak for themselves, but that doesn't really work for most people. So you're stuck with choosing lenses that render this foreign reality on a canvas you can actually picture. I also think there is nothing wrong in principle about choosing this particular representation. > I would say it's most likely not possible on our best current theories. Well, we know spacetime is not rigid. We know that interesting dynamics exist at the extreme limits of physical values. We also know that there is a large chunk yet to be discovered about the nature of the substrate on which reality rests. You are completely within your rights to look at everything we know and have ruled out so far and proclaim a high likelihood of impossibility, but along the same line of thought I reserve the right to declare the glass half full ;) The truth is that neither of us are likely to live to see a definite answer play out.
- pdonis 12y ago> That's actually one I stand by. If you mean, you like using it as an interpretation, no problem; a lot of people do. If you mean you think it's more than an interpretation, then you're going to have to show me explicitly where in the math the "flow of space" is represented.
- Udo 12y agoYes, I'm using it as a mental representation of a process which I can't picture directly. How do you deal with such things? I mean aren't you ever tempted to use a tool like that? I don't think there is anything wrong with the idea. I'm having some trouble picturing how it could be more than an interpretation.
- pdonis 12y agoThere's nothing wrong with using interpretations, as long as you realize they are interpretations. I do it too.
- shepardrtc 12y ago> According to our current theories, any such manipulations would require what is called "exotic matter". Fun read: http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20110015936.pdf http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2011001...