4 ms·
At a high level the thing that bugs me about this entire thread of conversation is that in my mind, there are really only a few areas of things worth working on
by gfodor 17y ago
At a high level the thing that bugs me about this entire thread of conversation is that in my mind, there are really only a few areas of things worth working on:
1. Alleviating human suffering.
2. Scientific exploration and discovery.
3. Building tools or technology that enhances others' abilities to do 1. or 2.
Notice that "bug tracking system", "personal finance management", and "company collaboration software" are not on the list. (And no, I don't want to hear about a stretched analogy about how they actually are alleviating human suffering. Please.) Also notice "social networking" is mysteriously absent as well. (Edit: To be fair, Twitter has had a few days where I really think it is making a positive difference in the world. Crapplications on Facebook, not so much.)
The only excuse to not be working on one of these things is if you are working towards building some capital in order to do so. Flipping a startup is a great way to do this.
At the end of the day, all these neat software tools people are building are not all that important in the grand scheme of things. What they are good for though, is enabling visionaries to start to address real problems by removing financial constraints. I am hoping that Aaron will now turn into another Elon Musk now that he has got a big chunk of $140M to work with. While he is solving real problems 37Signals and everyone else who has a lower bar for what it means to be a real contributor to society will be running their "Italian restaurants" for the next 20 years.
- petercooper 17y agoFWIW, I voted it up because I think you made the best comment on this post so far. I tend to think in similar terms to you regarding that list and thinking in that way got me out of a slump. I thought being a techie or an entrepreneur was a waste of time because of all the disadvantages, but I realized that if you're creating technologies or anything that helps others push the species forward, you're part of the good side of life.
- greyman 17y agoI happen to work on development of the software, whose aim is to alleviate human suffering (it is used in hospitals.) But we also use bug tracking system, as well as company collaboration software during our development. So those actually fall in your point 3).
- barrkel 17y agoYes, exactly. Efficiencies like bug tracking systems are like derivatives, in the calculus sense. Point 3 in the list is the first derivative of the first two points, while bug tracking is the second derivative for specific cases.
- jacquesm 17y agoIsn't it the other way around ? A derivative needs something to be derived from. So a toolset allows people to build neat stuff, making the neat stuff the first derivative of the tools it is built on.
- barrkel 17y agoAn analogy of the mathematical analogy I had in mind is acceleration, velocity and displacement: making a difference (displacement) in the world requires velocity, and tools can increase your velocity.
- jacquesm 17y agoExcellent points. That's why Elon Musk scores very high with me and 'dandies' (that will go unnamed here, but I'm sure you can picture the kind of person I have in mind) are a net loss. Given the chance to really change the world you should grasp it with both hands and run with it. Too many people still treat money as a goal in stead of as a tool, there really is no point in being the richest guy in the graveyard, if you do not apply it to something useful you might as well never have had it in the first place.
- petenixey 17y agoReducing carbon output using electric vehicles is thousands of times less financially efficient than providing people with better loft insulation. I think what Elon Musk is doing is great but he's trying to build an electric supercar - it's not the most philanthropic of pursuits.
- jacquesm 17y agotesla is one of the smallest things he's doing, have a look at this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk specifically spacex.
- dca 17y agoIsn't that pretty much setting you up to be a non-profit? One would typically have to use a similar "stretched analogy" to turn those few areas you mention into a for-profit company in most cases. I guess in my greedy little capitalist mind, its also worth working on if it solves any problem important enough for people to pay for it. Read "I, Pencil" by Leonard Reed sometime. Its available online for free. http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/rdPncl1.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/rdPncl1.html Then give some thought to how the invisible hand is really doing your point 3 on such a massive scale across all of society that it enables not only points 1 and 2, but also just about everything else anyone might think is worth working on. Its not a stretch really. Its a natural by-product of people having freedom to choose and pay for the things that are most important to them. If that's what's most important to you then that's great. But that doesn't mean nothing else is worth working on.
- hyperbovine 17y agoThat's a noble argument, but I think it's wrong. Someone has got to make the trains run on time. What I mean is, there will always be people in this world whose function it is to flip hamburgers, drive forklifts, raise livestock or work in HR. Without them the whole edifice comes crashing down. Rather than demeaning those callings, you should acknowledge that it's because of the hard work of untold millions that a few of us have the freedom to devote ourselves to higher causes. A lot less research would get done if we all had to grow our own food. Also, I have always found the get-rich-so-I-can-do-good mantra to just something people tell themselves to rationalize their blind pursuit of wealth. The chance of this happening is hilariously remote. Anyone who is playing the odds would be far better off taking a job as a social worker, teacher or relief worker. Not to mention the fact that you don't exactly need millions to make a difference. I have a friend (http://www.qfund.org/ http://www.qfund.org/) who took $50,000 and built a school for 500 children in Africa. She has made more of a difference in people's lives than the next 500 nerds in they Valley who are trying to strike it rich so they can build a spaceship, combined.
- gfodor 17y agoI guess my post was toned incorrectly if it came off as demeaning. My point was that if you have the freedom to work on anything, and its your choice, it's not really worth working on anything that isn't either a means to an end for a higher goal or on that goal itself. I'm not saying you can't have fun doing other things, or that its not necessary for people to do things like keeping the trains on time. Just saying if you have freedom, you should use it wisely.
- Confusion 17y agoWhat alleviates more suffering: when I do volunteer work in Africa or when I work as <whatever> here and donate a substantial amount of my income to the Red Cross? Me comforting some children dying of AIDS or me supplying the means for a hundred blankets in a refugee camp? Just saying if you have freedom, you should use it wisely. Who's going to be the judge of that? It would suck pretty bad if Elon Musk had decided to spend his life in Africa as a volunteer, now wouldn't it?
- theBobMcCormick 17y agoI agree with you that #1 and #2 are the most important areas of human endeavor and achievement (although I'd also add Art to #2). But I think #3 includes a lot more than you might at first think it does. The guy behind the counter at the local fast food joint is, in a very real way, part of #3. After all even scientists, doctors, etc. sometimes need a quick lunch right? As for working toward building some capital in order to do grand things... I'd love to see someone work up some stats on how many of the people who get rich from flipping a start really go on to spend a significant part of their time/wealth on #1 or #2? Or is that just some bullshit line that people tell themselves to justify all the time they're spending pursuing the almighty dollar (or euro, yen, etc). Once they're rich, do they try to make the world a better place? Or do they just buy a big "crib" with a pool?
- petenixey 17y agoI don't believe that statement is true. It's a noble statement but it misses the point in life. The point in life is not to avoid suffering and discover but to live and procreate. If you're not sure whether this is true do a split test on two families and measure which sets of characteristics do best in 100 generations. Science and medicine may be what separate us from the animals but for most people they are enablers for the rest of life, not the point in life itself. Working in entertainment and anything that furthers our ability to enjoy and "live" life is just as valid as your first two. It may not sound as good in a manifesto but making people happy is an extremely worthy pursuit.
- Confusion 17y agoAnd no, I don't want to hear about a stretched analogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well Read it and never again use that kind of sentence, unless you actually want to make constructive discussion harder.