3 ms·
> I think we have a mismatch of "zoom" levels where you appear to be arguing both "Everyone in the same grade took the same classes" and the opposite of that sc
by rdtsc 12y ago
> I think we have a mismatch of "zoom" levels where you appear to be arguing both "Everyone in the same grade took the same classes" and the opposite of that scheduling. I
Sorry that does seem confusing. Let me try to clear it up.
The point was that the main thing students should be doing -- getting an education, whether it prepares them for college or not was at the top of the list. Students being able to pick classes and specialize was not a top priority.
Then another point was that _optionally_ many had opportunity to further their interests by joining an external "club" or organizing one around the school. But these were optional and everyone did it if they wanted it. I didn't for example, my friends beleonged to a airplane modeling club and so on.
My argument was that the choice and ability to specialize starting in middle school as well as having to switch schools teachers, having different classmates every class is stressful enough and a uniform set of classes everyone takes is better. If anything just because it reduces the emotional stress of having to fit in different cliques or getting used to new schools and so on.
The reason I make personal annectodes is that I participated in both systems and can compare the two, based on how it felt for me.
Not to say I am extolling or saying all things were better and one should just copy that system of education -- there was lots of corruption and cheating or instance. But something I believe were better.