7 ms·
It's time for this crap to stop. systemd haters have gone Too Far. Get over it. It's childish and pathetic now. Death threats to the creator. Personal attacks
by Alupis 12y ago
It's time for this crap to stop.
systemd haters have gone Too Far.
Get over it. It's childish and pathetic now. Death threats to the creator. Personal attacks to volunteers. You have carried a debate into the extreme to where it is no longer noble.
Just leave. Just stop. You are not welcome anymore in the community.
- NANDXORNOR 12y agoI don't have a horse in this race, but isn't it a good idea to as they say: 'don't give them a reason to hate you'. From what I've seen the good intentions behind systemd were marred by the fact that when it was announced the (mostly skeptical) responses to it were met by systemd supporters who held the attitude 'we're saving nix, join us or nix dies', and this has created the current atmosphere of debate. While these death threats and the like are in no doubt horrible, it seems that some bridges need to be built between the people who support systemd and those who do not, because the attitudes on both sides of the argument are rather poor, and this makes the open source community look even worse. Edit: I said nothing about systemd users currently making threats, rather that their attitude at the beginning of the project at some level caused the response that we see today. They are not completely to blame, as are not the people who are against systemd and do not send death threats. Regardless, it seems that recently, HN only supports the idea of 'there is no gray, only black and white'. People like these are the reason why the systemd creators cannot engage in debate, because on both sides the people who shout the loudest win out over the reasonable voices.
- Alupis 12y agoI'm pretty certain that when someone actually tries to hire an assassin to murder the creator of a free software project simply because they disagree with said software project, things have gone way, way too far. People who support systemd are not launching personal attacks, calling for physical harm against non-systemd supporters. This is a unidirectional attack. And it needs to stop.
- tedunangst 12y ago> when someone actually tries to hire an assassin What???
- nandhp 12y agohttps://plus.google.com/+LennartPoetteringTheOneAndOnly/posts/J2TZrTvu7vd https://plus.google.com/+LennartPoetteringTheOneAndOnly/post... http://logs.nslu2-linux.org/livelogs/maemo/maemo.20130215.txt http://logs.nslu2-linux.org/livelogs/maemo/maemo.20130215.tx... (Ctrl-F hitman)
- ctz 12y agoIs an IRC chatlog the best evidence we have that "this really happened"?
- desdiv 12y agoFrom the horse's mouth: Recently, people started collecting Bitcoins to hire a hitman for me (this really happened!). https://plus.google.com/+LennartPoetteringTheOneAndOnly/posts/J2TZrTvu7vd https://plus.google.com/+LennartPoetteringTheOneAndOnly/post...
- tedunangst 12y agoOh! I assumed "tried" implied "tried and failed", but it seems the effort is ongoing? I guess the shutdown of Silk Road 2.0 will delay things for a while.
- felixgallo 12y agoWhat was it that Gandhi said? First you sneer at people, then you lie to people, then when caught out you make up stories to try to get sympathy? Wasn't that it?
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoHis name was on a fallacious bitcoin "assassination market" only accessible over Tor, basically just a website you could submit names to, with an associated bitcoin address. An obvious scam to glean free bitcoin. The hit man claim is complete horse shit.
- eksith 12y ago"While these death threats and the like are in no doubt horrible..." Then let's stop there. No bridge is sacred enough to warrant physical threats when burned. No attitude poor enough to elicit the response that this did. It's bloody software.
- rbanffy 12y ago> It's bloody software. Worse. It's bloody open-source software. You don't like it, you fork the last version you did and start from there. If enough people agree with you, you'll be fine. If not, you are probably wrong.
- eksith 12y agoAmen. Actually that would have been the better outcome anyway since it adds entropy to the gene pool. Cross pollination of ideas could have benefitted both parties. And even if your side doesn't take the cake, enough people would have flocked to the source that we could have fixed some bugs and resolved potential security issues due to the addition of more eyes. Looking from afar, you'd think this was some tiff over imaginary lines on a map or something. Now that would be silly.
- techdragon 12y agoIt happened. Gentoo is waiting to welcome all the systemD haters. OpenRC is going strong. We also support systemD as well because USE flags rock. In fact being able to see the sysV and systemD init files side by site was what finally convinced me it is an improvement. An improvement with many questionable additions... Like free money attached with losing my 25/20 eyesight to normal 20/20 or some other minor debilitating affliction.
- rbanffy 12y agoThe Debian exiles will miss apt badly. Apt was what made me move from Red Hat.
- infinity0 12y agoI too will offer solidarity and hopefully absorb some of the downvotes. I don't know who is downvoting you; your points seem quite reasonable. It is unclear that actual death threats have been made. In either case, this is irrelevant to the technical merit of systemd. We should not let valid criticisms of systemd be derailed by inappropriate focusing on death threats, which is a separate issue from hating systemd for technical reasons. I can see that systemd as a piece of software has many benefits. However, as a software project, the attitude as you mention, is a major problem. In my one single minor interaction with systemd people, I already agree with this criticism: "My experiences with systemd's Debian maintainers (and, indirectly, systemd's upstream) have been far from satisfactory in this regard. Instead of taking a flexible approach, and being willing to provide a range of glue facilities and approaches for different daemon upstreams, the systemd community seems doctrinaire. Daemon authors are expected to do as they are told by systemd upstream, rather than systemd upstream making things comfortable for daemon developers. This is IMO the opposite of the proper attitude." (from https://lists.debian.org/debian-ctte/2013/12/msg00182.html https://lists.debian.org/debian-ctte/2013/12/msg00182.html) This counts as a "technical reason". Though not directly about the software itself, a project with such an attitude should not be relied on because the people in control do not have your best interests in the long run.
- esaym 12y agoWish I could get over it. But every time some random process fails to start at boot time I...well I cry a little knowing this is what we are now stuck with.
- SwellJoe 12y agoWith all of the valid criticisms of systemd, you've chosen an imaginary one. Systemd provides better process handling and failure reporting than the initscripts it replaces (and mostly better than upstart, as well).
- esaym 12y agoI really wondered whether people would sympathize with me or just flame me. I guess I can explain my 'imaginary' problems a bit. Like normal people, I had several random things thrown in rc.local(set drive power settings,disable blue tooth on laptops, set raid sync rates,ect). The first issue was, systemd never even executed this file. I had to go do random googling just to get it to execute. After that, it was hit or miss on whether everything within the file would even get successfully executed. I'm guessing because some dependencies or modules aren't loaded yet, which shouldn't matter since rc.local is normally ran last. Sure, I could take each individual command and make its own init file which is what systemd docs recommend over rc.local. But seriously, why should I have to go to that length to fix something that has been working fine for 15 years?
- esaym 12y agoIn the end, I have had to rewrite my init scripts for custom stuff and do extra work and I am left wondering why I even tried it in the first place. The only speed difference (which from what I can tell is the only reason anyone uses systemd) I have seen is on my desktop machine. Start up is way faster, and shut downs too. Although strangely shutdowns hang randomly for over a minute sometimes. But on my laptops, I have noticed no difference. In summary, systemd has not simplified my life. I am not really sure what the rave about it even is. And no, I am not the one threatening the developers. I really don't care enough. I just find it odd that so many praise it so heavily, and I don't feel that way at all. I also know of no sysadmins that are looking forward to its global rollout....
- icebraining 12y agoThe problem is that the decent people who dislike systemd don't deserve that criticism, and the deranged people who issue death threats will ignore it.
- georgemcbay 12y agoSame issue as #GamerGate in that game "journalism" really is completely broken but now you can't talk about that without being lumped in with a bunch of vocal minority crazed misogynists.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's very easy to talk about game "journalism" without being lumped into the "vocal minority". Just talk about game "journalism" without sticking up for the hopeless "GamerGate" brand, and be careful not to bring up game "journalism" in discussions about gender parity.
- kristofferR 12y agoI get your point, yet I also see why that would be impossible from the GamerGate point of view considering how the media for the most part covered GamerGate in a biased one-sided way. Don't get me wrong, I don't support GamerGate (or the other side) at all. Yet, all gamers aren't women-hating misogynists, despite the reporting.
- tptacek 12y agoSee, you stuck up for "GamerGate", and now I think you're one of those people who believe that Zoe Quinn's private life is everyone's business because "ethics in journalism".
- kristofferR 12y agoAnd is that my fault or is it the fault of the coverage of GamerGate? Please note that I don't side with either of the sides, both sides are acting stupidly and I would rather spend time browsing TMZ than to engage in the stupid flamewar.
- jqm 12y agoI assume you mean the hatred and ugly talk needs to stop. With that I will agree and can see no reason anyone would think it a good idea to engage in this kind of behavior. But this is not necessarily the dislike and rejection of systemd. These are not the same thing. Nor does the fact some people are behaving badly make systemd any more preferable to me. Pottering's accusations that Linus somehow is responsible for the all the ugliness is over the top also IMHOP. Again, not condoning ugly talk and specifically ill wishes. This is far behind acceptable behavior. But I don't like the idea behind systemd. I am worried about it growing. I don't need systemd. I don't want systemd. But as long as there are alternatives, I don't really care if others do.
- imanaccount247 12y ago>systemd haters have gone Too Far. No, they have not. Some random asshats have done what random asshats have always done. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle got death threats when he killed off Sherlock Holmes. This is not some new thing or some internet thing. These are not people who were ever involved in a debate for them to carry over into something more extreme. They were never part of the community. This desire to blame other people for someone else's actions is immoral and dishonest.
- agumonkey 12y agoBeside the maintainer painful time, I find it interesting. We always see that FOSS is about freedom, if you don't agree, you can pick your own, fork, adapt ... except when a change impacts too much. The whole ecosystem is now changing forcing people to accept something too different, that's how things ends up emotional.