3 ms·
Actually a binary format (designed to be machine-friendly) is better for MITM injections as it's easier to parse and manipulate... the only benefit of HTTP2/SPD
by mschuster91 12y ago
Actually a binary format (designed to be machine-friendly) is better for MITM injections as it's easier to parse and manipulate... the only benefit of HTTP2/SPDY is that iirc it requires TLS.
I'm waiting for the first carrier to perform SSL MITM.
- guelo 12y agoHTTP2 doesn't require encryption but it does compress the headers. I'm guessing compression makes it too CPU-intensive for telecoms to manipulate the headers on the fly.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoI wish they'd require encryption. Perhaps make http:// http:// be TLS but without certificate verification.
- kaoD 12y agoThen the telecoms would MITM it anyways.
- nitrogen 12y agoCertificate pinning and web-of-trust verification would make that difficult to maintain for long.
- kaoD 12y agoIt's unlikely they'll ever get mass usage because both are uncomfortable to work with. If a certificate is compromised, changing it means all pinned clients will get a huge warning. Either the user ignores the warning (in which case pinning is useless) or he doesn't and the site is harmed. Keeping a compromised certificate is even worse. For WoT you first need a web of trusted individuals. Unfortunately key distribution over insecure channels is still an unsolved problem.
- TD-Linux 12y agoThis is in progress. HTTP 2.0 does exactly what you specify. The tcpinc working group at the IETF is also looking at adding this at a lower level for all TCP connections.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoUh, they removed the TLS requirement.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jankassens 12y agoThey're already planning it: "Involve the user: Obtain user consent to trust service provider to decrypt select HTTPS" Quote from someone working for a satellite internet provider for airlines. Source: http://www.atis.org/openweballiance/docs/OWAKickoffSlides051414.pdf http://www.atis.org/openweballiance/docs/OWAKickoffSlides051... page 27
- meowface 12y agoAs bad as it is, at the least it should be easy to opt-out of that (unless they do something ridiculous like charge you extra if you refuse to opt-in). Just remove the certificate your ISP gives you.
- girvo 12y ago> I'm waiting for the first carrier to perform SSL MITM. Nokia, funnily enough, did this on certain dumbphone models. Not a carrier, I know, but still interesting. http://gaurangkp.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/nokia-https-mitm/ http://gaurangkp.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/nokia-https-mitm/
- higherpurpose 12y ago> the only benefit of HTTP2/SPDY is that iirc it requires TLS. Yeah...except the NSA-agent-hiring IETF [1] gave up on that at the last minute. http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/01/nsa-employee-will-continue-to-co-chair-influential-crypto-standards-group/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/01/nsa-employee-will-co...