3 ms·
That's just it though. A video rental represents a physical object, a stream does not. There is no first sale doctrine on OD streaming content. Are you arguing
by Karunamon 12y ago
That's just it though. A video rental represents a physical object, a stream does not. There is no first sale doctrine on OD streaming content.
Are you arguing that selling access to an ephemeral thing shouldn't be allowed? The physical copy of a movie and a stream of a movie are two different items, with the second one having far less value due to its nature.
Here's where we diverge. If I go buy a movie, then as the first sale doctrine and common sense implies, I should be able to digitize it, format/time shift, etc.
Rentals confer none of those rights, either legally or morally. You are paying for temporary access to a thing under the limited terms offered you by some third party. If you want more rights, buy instead of rent. This is not a new or troubling development!
As to whatever you perceive Netflix's ambitions to be, I prefer to castigate them if/when they start abusing their position and become enemies to a free internet. They have shown zero evidence that they are doing this, quite the opposite in fact.