5 ms·
> Common ligatures are essential to professionally typeset text. I like the idea, and they're aesthetically great, but I think they're too rare now for it to b
by baddox 12y ago
> Common ligatures are essential to professionally typeset text.
I like the idea, and they're aesthetically great, but I think they're too rare now for it to be wise to use them. People will be confused and distracted. I have only one anecdatum, which is that Slack chat uses a font with ligatures, and I have heard several confused comments about them. For niche professional documents, like research papers, I'm sure it's accepted and expected, but you're probably already using LaTeX for those anyway!
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> For niche professional documents, like research papers, I'm sure it's accepted and expected, but you're probably already using LaTeX for those anyway! I think by LaTeX you mean Microsoft Word. For social sciences, at least.
- saryant 12y agoBack in college I would typeset my polisci and literature papers in LaTeX. Professors would write notes about how great my papers looked, they were so used to Word.
- baddox 12y agoOh, that could be. Mathematics and computer science are the only fields for which I've read many papers, and they tend to be LaTeX.
- TTPrograms 12y agoThat's pretty presumptuous to assume all research papers are like those in social sciences...
- Sharlin 12y agoIn hard sciences LaTeX is pretty much the de facto standard. So much that most people in those fields automatically assume papers that don't have the LaTeX look to be subpar science. Of course, one of the reasons for its prevalence is the math support that's lightyears beyond anything Word can offer.
- chronial 12y agoDid you have a look at word's math support in recent years?
- analog31 12y agoI find using the equation editor in Word to be physically debilitating. Pretty much any software involving tiny graphics and fine mouse work triggers severe eyestrain headaches and neck fatigue. There's a document here, describing keyboard entry: http://www.chem.mtu.edu/~tbco/cm416/EquationEditor_main.pdf http://www.chem.mtu.edu/~tbco/cm416/EquationEditor_main.pdf It's basically a markup language of sorts, and I'd use it if I were presently writing a lot of text with equations. For better or worse, working in industry, my reports are free of equations! I've formed the hypothesis, that when managers and non-technical people see an equation, they assume the report is "incomplete," i.e., the equation needs to be turned into an actual result. I've been to academic talks where, instead of typeset equations, the author just copies the source code from their MatLab file to a PowerPoint slide.
- ygra 12y agoIn university I used Word 2007 to type math lectures in real-time. I never had to resort to the mouse at all for equations. You seem to be thinking of the stripped-down MathType equation editor that was bundled with Office for a while (before it had native math support). The PDF you linked is for Office 2007 onwards and shows that the markup language you mention is mostly like TeX with a few simplifications, e.g. smart handling of things like x^12 which is then actually x¹² instead of x¹2. Basically it uses parentheses where TeX uses braces and needs a lot fewer of them because of more natural tokenizing.
- analog31 12y agoI think you're right. I plan on trying it, next time I need to enter equations into Word. For me, the key to ergonomic use of the computer is being able to look away from the screen. For instance, I can type text forever without constant focused eye contact with the screen, which greatly reduces the eyestrain issue. And I suppose a useful thing is that if you do misspell one of the keywords, it just sits there until you correct it, as a reminder of what you were trying to write.
- fosap 12y agoI get a teaching degree. Every discipline as it's own formating requirements. For CS and Physics things have to look good, but there is not too much specified. Everybody uses TeX, length is measured in characters, not pages, usually there is no minimum length, but a maximum length. For pedagogics there are huge (like 30 pages) formating requirements. The formating requirements itself are incredible ugly and often quite objectively bad. Such as lots of widows and orphans (even in tables!). The document is distributed as a .doc file, and yes it does look like this even in Word, it's not a fault of LibreOffice. Length is measured in pages and the critical limit is the minimum length. On the subjective side they IMO made the worst possible choices. Arial (or similar), 12 points, almost no margins, 150% spacing between the lines, italic and bold headings. It looks very bad, is MS Word centric, but they have the nerve to make a style guide longer than a page. Also, looking at psychology papers, it seems to me that non technical fields have a thing for shitty typography.
- analog31 12y agoI have to laugh when my kids are assigned a "five page" paper, that will never be printed.
- girvo 12y ago> On the subjective side they IMO made the worst possible choices. Arial (or similar), 12 points, almost no margins, 150% spacing between the lines, italic and bold headings. So that's why my high-school's formatting requirements for assignments and papers were exactly what you've listed there.
- TacticalCoder 12y ago"...but I think they're too rare now for it to be wise to use them" The ligature of 'f' and 'i' is not "rare" and it is not "unwise" to use it. Actually many professionally typeset books are using it: it's not an "idea" as you wrote. It is something very real and often used. It is so common and so good looking (I'd even say "so perfect") that you probably never noticed it but I can assure you that it's used in many of the books / newspapers / magazines you've read during your life. I've written and typeset about a dozen book (one with LaTeX, all the others with QuarkXPress: it was before the InDesign days) and I can tell you that when I see a non-ligature "fi" I directly notice it because it is really poor looking. Of course in addition to LaTeX, both QuarkXPress and Adobe's InDesign and several other professional typesetting software do the common ligatures.
- baddox 12y agoI'm usually fairly cognizant of ligatures when I'm reading, but obviously I can only comment on the things I have read with my imperfect memory. The book I'm reading now (Harmonic Experience by Mathieu) is certainly what I would consider to be professionally typeset, and it does not use the "fi" ligature. Godel, Escher, Bach, on the other hand, does use it from what I remember. The Lifebox, The Sheashell, and the Soul does not use it (I just checked). From my memory, few of the physical novels I've read used it, but I'm not too confident in that memory because all of my novel reading has been done on a Kindle for several years (the portability and convenience won out over typography). I've read almost no physical newspapers or magazines since I was quite young, so you might be very correct about that. It really comes down to who your audience is, and perhaps it's true that most things you would even consider using LaTeX for are intended for an audience savvy enough to not be distracted by ligatures.
- taeric 12y agoI would actually go further. For the most part it makes frightfully no difference. Last I checked, the majority of fiction books out there have ligatures. As do many "professional" publications. Magazines are an odd mix. Last I recall, the expensive ones use them, the cheap ones don't. All of this is to say that sure, you may notice and be cognizant of ligatures. Most people aren't.
- suchow 12y agoThat's surprising because if you pick up any professionally typeset book or magazine, you'll find ligatures all over. Some of them are quite subtle (e.g., the fi -> fi ligature). I have to imagine then that your colleagues are getting distracted not by the presence of ligatures in general, but by a few decorative ligatures or characters present in the Slack font, which looks to be Lato. For example, Lato's ampersand is missing a chunk in the upper loop (https://www.google.com/fonts/specimen/Lato https://www.google.com/fonts/specimen/Lato).
- baddox 12y agoI don't find the "fi" ligature to be at all subtle. I commented on my reading experience in this other reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8615657 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8615657. You're right that Lato has some peculiar glyphs, but there have definitely been specific comments in my office about the "fi" ligature.
- krig 12y agoI also don't like the ligatures that Slack uses, but it's entirely a problem with the font they use, not with ligatures in general.