4 ms·
Is the Heimlick really the most effective way to dislodge something caught in a person's throat, or is it just the most convenient? I ask because, thinking abou
by derefr 12y ago
Is the Heimlick really the most effective way to dislodge something caught in a person's throat, or is it just the most convenient? I ask because, thinking about the mechanism behind e.g. water-boarding torture, the first thing I'd want to do to someone who is trying to get something up that's trying to go down their throat, is to flip them over or incline them such that the gravitational force on the object will be aiding them rather than fighting them.
I mean, nobody would think of trying to perform CPR on a drowning victim with the person propped up instead of laying flat, right?
- gregd 12y agoWith babies, this is a recommended method (cradling them upside down, letting gravity work, while also giving minor back blows). However, this method would be entirely impossible with a fully grown adult. The problem is also that the object can get lodged wanting to neither move up OR down, so getting them upside down only, probably wouldn't dislodge it. That's why it becomes necessary to push it out with what little air is below the object.
- DanBC 12y agoThe first aid for toddlers I learnt many uears ago recommended picking them up by the legs and whacking their backs. This is impractical on adults.