3 ms·
> As long as he has not physically harmed anybody, he should be a free man. This is an interesting theory of law, but I could go quite a way naming crimes that
by wpietri 12y ago
> As long as he has not physically harmed anybody, he should be a free man.
This is an interesting theory of law, but I could go quite a way naming crimes that don't result in physical harm. Fraud, theft, harassment, threatening physical harm, rape, slander, kidnapping, slavery, forgery, theft of military plans, obstruction of justice, treason, drugging someone, criminal negligence, impersonating a surgeon, arson, blackmail, trafficking in stolen property, child abduction, and basically attempted anything, including attempted murder, conspiracy to commit murder, incitement to murder, and solicitation of murder.
Setting aside your novel legal theories, you apparently don't believe harassment, stalking, rape threats, and death threats cause real harm. But neither victims nor perpetrators agree with you: often the explicitly stated purpose is to cause harm.
The "just ignore the trolls" position is fine advice for a very specific sort of troll, the ones that are motivated by attention. But for the ones who are motivated by harm, it doesn't work. Indeed, it helps them operate by giving them cover.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoA portion of those do cause physical harm, or are virtually guaranteed to result in physical harm, if not inherently implying it. I think you meant to say that they might not leave any physical marks. That's quite different, though.
- wpietri 12y agoI understand that we are all programmers, and so we love to nitpick things. But the point of that list is not to say that none of them ever cause physical harm, but that in the cases where those things don't cause measurable physical harm, they are still often crimes that would merit punishment.
- matthewwiese 12y agoIt's not about being "programmers" but rational human beings. You knew beforehand that you were making a generalization and were subsequently called out on it, so to speak. Your clarification here should have been in the parent comment to begin with.
- wpietri 12y ago> It's not about being "programmers" but rational human beings. I mention programmers because of the forum. And no, programmers tend to nitpick more. We are trained to nitpick more, because that's part of how you get bulletproof code. And that's great when dealing with code. But it can be problematic in discussions because it easily leads to derailing off into little niggling points. Like this one. > Your clarification here should have been in the parent comment to begin with. No. No, no, no. One does not have to put every possible caveat into one's initial statement, especially when the context is established. That just makes for very long, boring things that nobody reads. I trust that most readers will approach things with smarts and goodwill. When there are multiple ways to read something, I trust that they will find the most useful one. If all that fails, I hope they will say, "Hey, did you really mean X?" Which in this case happened.
- matthewwiese 12y ago> I mention programmers because of the forum. And no, programmers tend to nitpick more. There are users here besides programmers. Just because it's called "Hacker News" and run on YCombinator's site doesn't immediately mean it's exclusive. Programmers may be trained to nit pick, but you could argue that about any technical profession. Engineers? Better make sure we accounted for every possible detail. Doctors? If we don't check each scenario the patient may worsen. Research scientists? Better be sure the study is conducted appropriately to the scientific method and that our data is statistically significant. > One does not have to put every possible caveat into one's initial statement Of course not, that would be absurd. However, you contradict yourself from the parent: "This is an interesting theory of law, but I could go quite a way naming crimes that don't result in physical harm" To the following child comment of: "But the point of that list is not to say that none of them ever cause physical harm, but that in the cases where those things don't cause measurable physical harm" I have no issue with the point you are making, but I do have issue that you say one thing but defend yourself with a position claiming it was the one you originally made. Which evidently was not the case due to the way you worded it. You may argue that you just thought someone would be smart enough to read it the way you liked, but that shouldn't be the case with arguments. To illustrate this, I have quoted another section of your comment below. > I trust that they will find the most useful one. If all that fails, I hope they will say, "Hey, did you really mean X?" Which in this case happened. Assumptions are bad! In any case a reader could just have easily not done so.
- kordless 12y agoIgnoring things rarely makes them go away and usually ends up causing cognitive dissonance. The primary issue with remote-based crimes is that they may cause the victim to become emotionally unstable because of the dualistic state forced upon them. Someone saying you are a bad person, and enough of their cronies saying it as well, can leave a lasting impression on the most resilient of us, even if we believe we're awesome inside. I had a troll attack me on Twitter last week. No clue what his motive was, but the topic in question was Bitcoin related. He attempted to escalate the conversation by asking if I liked Obama. Instead of replying to this leading question, I took about 5 minutes to do a whois on his domain, find his name, find a few posts about him attacking others on a Bitcoin forum, and publicly DM'd him the links making the observation that he didn't appear to be a trustworthy source for levying blame. Never heard back from him. We all have a choice on how we handle blamers. Becoming a blamer ourselves when dealing with them will only serve to increase the suffering related to the relationship. I encourage others to learn more about non-violet communications and learn to wield the power of the pen when it comes down to confronting and combatting these poor types of behaviors.