3 ms·
So which propaganda are you specifically trying to ban? >It's unlike it because it's far easier to establish emotional connections and paint a rich world full
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
So which propaganda are you specifically trying to ban?
>It's unlike it because it's far easier to establish emotional connections and paint a rich world full of counter factuals. Fiction can easily establish itself as a reference point for future ideas, such as on AI.
The thing about rich worlds full of counterfactual events is that, being completely unrealistic, they have no influence on real life. There's a reason the people who accomplish big things in real life usually spent a lot more of their time reading textbooks than novels.
If you want to raise artificial intelligence as an example, the very ridiculousness of the body of fictional evidence from which to generalize has probably set back the field by decades, because people keep running around chasing nonsense ideas out of the sorry imaginations of philosophers of mind and science-fiction writers rather than following the obvious research leads that stare into the face of anyone who bothers to actually look with a clear head.
But I'm sure that anyone complaining about how speculative fiction is dangerous would probably say the opposite: that giving people bad models to work from somehow makes them more likely to discover real, working science.
Anyway, point being, the thing about having movies where pandimensional posthumans open wormholes to save mankind from omnivirulent crop blight is that they don't make space exploration dangerous.
- MichaelGG 12y agoThe article mentions how fiction has convinced people that cars explode, leading bystanders to drag people out of car accidents, injuring them. Another example could be crime or terrorism shows that make people think LE should have extraordinary powers. Fiction, even unrealistic, certainly effects people. As the article mentions, brains believe everything they hear, at first. The understanding that something is a lie comes after. Additionally, we cache thoughts, for efficiency and do not always reevaluate thoughts for truthiness. So being bombarded by many counterfactuals can certainly change our minds in the "real world". This is only mentioned because it points out that reading fiction can be actively harmful, so we can't just sum it up as just potentially positive.