3 ms·
What rules would you suggest?
by tzs 12y ago
What rules would you suggest?
- gojomo 12y agoBreak up regional or national monopolies, especially those created by poor city franchise policies. Otherwise let engineers, customers, and businesses figure things out for themselves competitively – as has worked just fine so far without involving the FCC's powers of censoring, taxing, delaying, price-fixing, wiretapping, and favoring-incumbents.
- revelation 12y agoLet's start with ISPs can't manipulate any data in layers over IP. Seems like the majority already fails that very, very simple requirement to a communications provider.
- tptacek 12y agoISPs do extensive "manipulation" at layers above IP for operational reasons that have nothing at all to do with favoring particular content providers.
- sschueller 12y agoThe carriers are not permitted to perform any filtering. Legal or illegal content needs to be dealt with at the consumer and provider end. Like it is done now. I don't want a Chinese firewall. I though we already have legislation in place to define them as "Common Carreires" absolving them of any legal responsibility when illegal content crosses their pipes. However it requires them to not perform any filtering. I have the feeling we are making a new law to permits ISP to filter and not be legally responsible if illegal content crosses their pipes. Why can't we just define carrier's as common carriers?
- DanBC 12y agoCompare ISPs (not common carriers) to USPS (common carriers). USPS has a whole bunch of law saying what can or can't he sent via postal mail. They absolutely do filter the post - not very well but it happens. https://postalinspectors.uspis.gov/aboutus/laws.aspx https://postalinspectors.uspis.gov/aboutus/laws.aspx What it seems people are asking for is that ISPs never filter any traffic at all for any reason and also never suffer any consequences for not filtering that traffic. Giving Internet carriers "common carrier" status is likely to include laws that make them gather evidence and prosecute people involved in online gambling; child sexual exploitation; pyramid schemes; lottery tickets; credit card fraud; extreme pornography; etc. giving them common carrier status is likely to lead to more, not less, intrusive monitoring and filtering.