5 ms·
I am worried that the net neutrality rules the president is now pushing will eventually kill the free and open internet. ISPs will be required to not block tra
by sschueller 12y ago
I am worried that the net neutrality rules the president is now pushing will eventually kill the free and open internet.
ISPs will be required to not block traffic that is lawful but what is the definition of lawful? Would wikileaks be considered lawful? What about the Snowden documents? What about encryption?
This is a dangerous road we are going down.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI'm in favor of Net Neutrality, but from what I've read and discussed, Title II sounds like a bad path to go down. Basically it would give the FCC all sorts of regulatory powers we'd just have to trust they wouldn't enforce. Yeah, I got no faith on that topic.
- click170 12y agoYou've got a very good point. I guess the reason I'm not as worried about it as you is because I feel like it will be easier to get the FCC to bow to public pressure (eventually?) if they do something stupid, more than I trust any of the ISPs which IMO have been behaving stupidly for quite a while now. Edit: typo
- zyxley 12y agoSame. I generally trust the FCC to be stupid rather than (as ISPs are right now) actively malicious.
- webXL 12y agoSo we give more power to an incompetent agency to solve what, exactly? To get what we pay for? Is the level of service going to improve, or will prices fall to match the current level of service? Or will service degrade and prices increase?
- nunyabuizness 12y agoISPs act the way they do because they've bought the right from the "publicly accountable" people we're expecting "bow to public pressure." I personally trust GoDaddy to bow to public pressure way before the FCC.
- landryraccoon 12y agoComcast is the least popular company in the U.S. right now. I hate them and yet I still use them because the Internet options in my area are nonexistent. Why would a monopoly care at all about your public opinion?
- shmerl 12y agoAt least president's proposal includes the forbearance restrictions, same which EFF proposed. I.e. FCC would get only limited scope power to regulate net neutrality issues, and not a wild card power to regulate Internet.
- mac01021 12y agoI still don't get it. Who is currently experiencing the problems that the proposals for net neutrality aim to solve?
- Igglyboo 12y agoNo one yet, other than maybe the netflix throttling that some experience. The problem if this isn't nipped in the bud now it could become much worse.
- quanticle 12y agoAre you forgetting about how Comcast heavily throttled BitTorrent before the same sort of public outcry caused them to walk back their strategy?
- Igglyboo 12y agoNo, but that was under the guise of preventing piracy while netflix is clearly not illegal so it's more applicable to the net neutrality debate.
- shmerl 12y agoRecent Netflix problems were caused by ISPs behaviour that otherwise could be prohibited. Other examples of ISPs violating net neutrality is charging different rates for different traffic on mobile networks. For instance, T-Mobile says your plan is unlimited as long as traffic goes to / from the primary device (such as your handset). But if you connect secondary device through it (for example through WiFi hotspot), your traffic will be treated differently and you'll have a monthly cap. Discriminating traffic is exactly the problem that net neutrality rules are supposed to prevent.
- splitrocket 12y agoThe legality question is pretty much where we have always been: DMCA, FBI seizing of servers etc. etc. If it's illegal, the government can, has, and will continue to try to stop it.
- brandonmenc 12y agoThe question is, will the FCC take it upon themselves to add their own rules to the definition of "legal content." For instance afaik the FCC - not Congress - defines "profanity."
- digi_owl 12y agoI don't see why the FCC should treat the ISPs any different from the phone companies of old. Common Carrier, anyone?
- hristov 12y agoWhat exactly is so dangerous? The free transmission of information?
- bmelton 12y agoThe idea that government regulation enables freedom is no necessarily one that holds water. If that were the case, the government regulations protecting car companies wouldn't be denying Tesla access to certain markets, and the regulations that govern taxi companies wouldn't be denying Uber and Lyft access to their markets. Admittedly, these aren't apples to apples comparisons, but it strikes me as somewhat ironic that after all of the hullabaloo with the NSA spying and such that we still hold the belief that the government is every trying to do the "right thing".
- nitrogen 12y agoThe parent comment is probably referring to wording that says that "lawful" or "legal" content should not be blocked. The argument seems to be that the definition of "lawful" or "legal" will be stretched as appropriate to make whatever ISPs or the government wants to block "unlawful" or "illegal", like, say, Wikileaks.
- sschueller 12y agoCouldn't these new rules be applied to the Chinese ISPs and have no affect on how that internet is run? What is filtered now would still be filtered and I don't think you can say that the Chinese have net neutrality. Or am I missing something?
- tzs 12y agoWhat rules would you suggest?
- gojomo 12y agoBreak up regional or national monopolies, especially those created by poor city franchise policies. Otherwise let engineers, customers, and businesses figure things out for themselves competitively – as has worked just fine so far without involving the FCC's powers of censoring, taxing, delaying, price-fixing, wiretapping, and favoring-incumbents.
- revelation 12y agoLet's start with ISPs can't manipulate any data in layers over IP. Seems like the majority already fails that very, very simple requirement to a communications provider.
- tptacek 12y agoISPs do extensive "manipulation" at layers above IP for operational reasons that have nothing at all to do with favoring particular content providers.
- sschueller 12y agoThe carriers are not permitted to perform any filtering. Legal or illegal content needs to be dealt with at the consumer and provider end. Like it is done now. I don't want a Chinese firewall. I though we already have legislation in place to define them as "Common Carreires" absolving them of any legal responsibility when illegal content crosses their pipes. However it requires them to not perform any filtering. I have the feeling we are making a new law to permits ISP to filter and not be legally responsible if illegal content crosses their pipes. Why can't we just define carrier's as common carriers?
- DanBC 12y agoCompare ISPs (not common carriers) to USPS (common carriers). USPS has a whole bunch of law saying what can or can't he sent via postal mail. They absolutely do filter the post - not very well but it happens. https://postalinspectors.uspis.gov/aboutus/laws.aspx https://postalinspectors.uspis.gov/aboutus/laws.aspx What it seems people are asking for is that ISPs never filter any traffic at all for any reason and also never suffer any consequences for not filtering that traffic. Giving Internet carriers "common carrier" status is likely to include laws that make them gather evidence and prosecute people involved in online gambling; child sexual exploitation; pyramid schemes; lottery tickets; credit card fraud; extreme pornography; etc. giving them common carrier status is likely to lead to more, not less, intrusive monitoring and filtering.
- ryanhuff 12y agoI would strongly prefer a path that allows a competitive market to emerge.
- techsupporter 12y agoThe kicker and worst part is that we HAD competitive market under the 1996 Telecommunications Act (and Title II) before it got killed off in 2004/2005. At one point, in a craphole suburb of north Texas, I had the choice of no fewer than 8 DSL providers (including SDSL 3Mbps bidirectional, which was amazing at the time) and 3 cable providers. Now, in the smack middle of a major city with a large technology presence, I have 0 of the first kind and 1 of the second kind. This is _not_ progress.
- guelo 12y agoStop spreading this FUD.
- cheald 12y agoPlease explain why it is FUD rather than just being condescending.
- Prolorn 12y agoThese concerns sprouted from the White House's comment that ISPs should not block legal content. Logically, this does not imply that ISPs have to start filtering for illegal content, but that is nevertheless what people started worrying about.
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoLike all questions of regulation, it comes down to who you trust more - the FCC, or the telecoms. One of those two is going to end up dictating policy, since the current ISPs are a de facto if not natural monopoly or, at best, oligopoly, depending on where you live. No matter how cynical you want to be about the FCC, Comcast, Verizon, et al. have already proven themselves to be actively harmful. Anything restrictions the FCC creates can hardly be worse than the "fast lane" plans. The FCC is also answerable to elected officials, for better or for worse - even at worst, I think that's better than being answerable to no one but a pocketbook.
- cheald 12y agoI "trust" the telecoms more, because it's illegal to start a competitor to the FCC if I don't like how they're doing their job. That's not to say that the current batch of telecoms are trustworthy, but at least there is recourse in the form of competition (see: Google Fiber), while if the FCC goes off the deep end we're irrevocably pooched. And...we have immediate history demonstrating that the FCC is corruptible for external agendas. I don't know why people think they would suddenly become above reproach if net neutrality legislation were enacted.
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoGoogle Fiber - and any competition, for that matter - do not exist in the vast majority of the country. My point is the FCC regime is not guaranteed to be better in the long run, but it can hardly be worse, and has the potential to be excellent.
- johndevor 12y ago>it can hardly be worse I'd check that assumption. There's plenty of evidence to show that government does a poor job regulating companies. Often times it's the companies that control the regulations.
- fleitz 12y agoUmm... Isn't Title II regulation of these providers what produced the current cell phone and cable market? Have you ever used a telco or cable company in the US? It's not exactly 'free and open'
- learc83 12y agoFrom what I've read, the regulation prohibits ISPs from blocking lawful traffic, but it doesn't require them to block unlawful traffic, or give them any greater ability to block unlawful traffic than they already have.
- frederickf 12y agoBut couldn't the government establish regulations like that even without net neutrality type rules/legislations?