4 ms·
Space exploration was always very dependent on politics. As Neil deGrasse Tyson says, NASA was founded on the fear factor of USSR's Sputnik which was launched
by acqq 12y ago
Space exploration was always very dependent on politics.
As Neil deGrasse Tyson says, NASA was founded on the fear factor of USSR's Sputnik which was launched using the intercontinental ballistic missile technology.
BTW: According to the comments here, the solar power generation on Philae weights at least 20 times less than the nuclear generator would.
- guscost 12y agoAny hypothetical RTG for this mission would almost certainly weigh less than the one on the Curiosity rover. This lander does not need 100+ watts of power for 10 years. Consider that the RTG from the Pioneer 10 mission weighed less than 16kg: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_for_Nuclear_Auxiliary_Power#SNAP-19 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_for_Nuclear_Auxiliary_P...
- acqq 12y agoThanks. That still makes some 10 times less weight for solar panels. Still, once US makes a mission, I can imagine they would consider using that, launching much heavier probe etc. This was an European mission, not having access to the US resources.
- guscost 12y agoWow, I just looked into it and it turns out the ESA actually hasn't used RTGs before, but planned to use one with this very mission[0:p78]. The only ESA mission I can find which used an RTG is the Cassini-Huygens probe[1], a collaboration with NASA. [0] http://www.ianus.tu-darmstadt.de/media/ianus/pdfs/arbeitspapiere/5-1998.pdf http://www.ianus.tu-darmstadt.de/media/ianus/pdfs/arbeitspap... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassini–Huygens http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassini–Huygens
- acqq 12y agoWhere do you see that ESA actually planned to use a RTG for Rosetta mission? On the p78 is only "The consortium formed of leading institutes of Europe includes the scientific organisations of Germany, Finland, Italy, Hungary, Great Britain and Austria, which have not the technological capacity to manufacture RTGs. It was therefore decided to develop new high-efficiency solar cell for this deep space mission."
- guscost 12y agoHere's the passage as it appears on page 78 of the IANUS paper[0]: "Up to now there exists a number of projects developed by ESA which plan to use radionuclide power or heat sources. One of the most far progressed is the 'Rosetta' project." [Update: When this paper was written, it looks like they might have been only planning to use an RHU to heat the lander: "'RoLand' includes not only the solar power generator but also RHU on plutonium-238 of the RHU 'Angel' type. By the opinion of the project experts, the RHU use is the most desirable, sensible and reliable means for achieving the main goal of the mission."] [0] Energy supply for deep space missions: Risks of nuclear power in space and prospects for solar alternatives. From http://www.ianus.tu-darmstadt.de/media/ianus/pdfs/arbeitspapiere/5-1998.pdf http://www.ianus.tu-darmstadt.de/media/ianus/pdfs/arbeitspap...
- acqq 12y agoYes it's only RHU (Radioisotope heater unit) is mentioned, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_heater_unit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_heater_unit never RTG (Radioisotope thermoelectric generator). "While both RHUs and RTGs use the decay heat of a radioactive isotope (usually Pu-238), RHUs are generally much smaller as a result of omitting the thermocouples and heat sinks/radiators required to generate electricity from heat."
- guscost 12y agoBut then there seems to be a contradiction here. If the ESA was planning to use an RHU powered by plutonium-238, which resource (your word) or technological capacity (from the IANUS paper) were they missing that prevented them from using a plutonium-238 RTG? Money?