3 ms·
I got to thinking about this the other day when I blogged, then posted the article on HN. One of the posters made a great comment and our back-and-forth I thoug
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I got to thinking about this the other day when I blogged, then posted the article on HN. One of the posters made a great comment and our back-and-forth I thought helped explain the article (which was hastily written) So I copied his comment and my reply over to my blog. (This was noted in the comment thread and I offered to remove it if it bothered the poster)
What was interesting was the commenter's reply when he found out his comment had been copied. "I thought that was just a feature of his blog"
Got me to thinking: why couldn't it just be a feature of my blog?
I understand some folks might have a problem with that -- I haven't sorted through how I feel about it ethically. But from a value proposition to the user it is an interesting idea: the web (to me) is about conversations with people of different views. Wouldn't it be great to be able to harvest feedback on your articles, wherever the feedback happens, and share it with readers right alongside the article itself?
It's just an idea I'm kicking around. The legal part of it looks tricky, though. And then there's the fact that it turns some people off, which isn't good either.
- jacquesm 17y agoI think that if you post a blog and someone comments on it 'elsewhere' that their comments are fair game for citing, with attribution (which is how I would do it).