4 ms·
The targets have to change during the mission. The initial plan was even the another comet. It shouldn't matter. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_%28spacec
by acqq 12y ago
The targets have to change during the mission. The initial plan was even the another comet. It shouldn't matter.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_%28spacecraft%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_%28spacecraft%29
"Rosetta was set to be launched on 12 January 2003 to rendezvous with the comet 46P/Wirtanen in 2011.
This plan was abandoned after a failure of the Ariane 5 carrier rocket during a communications satellite launch on 11 December 2002, grounding it until the cause of the failure could be determined."
No reason to blindly stick to the initial target when you're doing something for the first time ever. It's not that you planned to drive from your home to the shopping mall and have to excuse to your other that you went drinking beer instead. You would probably complain that it's not an initial comet now too?
The device landed on the darn comet! After travelling 6 billion km in 10 years. Managed to work a few days and send the data! First time ever! Powered only by the solar energy! (+) In the outside temperature of absolute zero. How many firsts do you need?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEY58fiSK8E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEY58fiSK8E
Nothing built by humans was ever on the comet surface before. This thing even worked.
+) Edit: Thanks to jdiez17 for pointing that the lander used a non-rechargeable battery on the comet surface. It was all the time planed to do the main work with that battery. The solar powered work wasn't the primary objective.
- jdiez17 12y agoTo be completely fair, it was not powered by solar energy - the experiments were run on power from the non-rechargeable battery. Which is fine, this is what Philae was designed to do. It looks like they completed all the objectives in the First Science Sequence (FSS), which was the lander's primary mission.
- acqq 12y agoAnd also to be fair, the whole mission didn't depend on any RTG technology, used only by the US and Russia in space: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8610585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8610585
- jdiez17 12y agoWhile it would have been convenient to have a RTG onboard, it would have made the lander too heavy (with the current RTG technology. Smaller nuclear generators are possible in theory but none have been built yet.)
- acqq 12y agoYes, the lander was around 100 kg, whereas RTG would weight around 40 kg alone. And it would anyway be needed only in this case of unfortunate landing in the shadow. Once we talk about details it's clear how a lot of the complaints are based purely on a huge ignorance. It's good to ask to learn. But when somebody starts from the position that people who managed 25-year mission missed something to him "simple and obvious"...
- hrjet 12y ago> It's good to ask to learn. In that spirit, I have a question. How heavy are the solar panels? If their weight is comparable to 40kg then it makes RTG more attractive.
- gtirloni 12y agoI'm not sure about the exact weight but perhaps an estimation can be derived from the specifications available in the fact sheet [1] - Contractor: Galileo Avionica SpA - Cells Type: Si, Hi-ETA LILT - Cells Size: 3x3 cm2 - Power equiv. @ 3 AU: 32W - Total Size: 2.2m2 - Lifetime: 10 years [1] - http://www.dlr.de/rd/Portaldata/28/Resources/dokumente/rx/Philae_Lander_FactSheets.pdf http://www.dlr.de/rd/Portaldata/28/Resources/dokumente/rx/Ph...
- acqq 12y agoThe weight of solar cells used on the Earth comes from making them protected from the environment, the material that produces the power itself is very thin. http://sbir.gsfc.nasa.gov/SBIR/successes/ss/3-027text.html http://sbir.gsfc.nasa.gov/SBIR/successes/ss/3-027text.html Note "1 kW/kg" specification but it's probably in the Earth's orbit, using the inverse square law, it should be an order of magnitude less where Philae now is. Still, it appears it can remain quite light to have 2 m^2 of cells there. Anybody has more exact details for the weight of the cells on Philae?
- justsee 12y agoI'm just raising the kind of precise, detail-oriented questions that typically emanate from this community. Your response relies on an appeal to emotion rather than logic, and doesn't seem particularly interested in engaging with the substance of the questions raised?
- acqq 12y agoThe logic is: to get something at least approximately close to your goals done for the first time ever, you have to adjust your targets as you go. Every other strategy simply doesn't work. You are welcome to just stick to your initial goals in your endeavours. Write now absolutely exactly what you plan to do for the first time. Than please report in some time and stick to describing your failures. Observe how motivated for more you'll be. And to paraphrase Louis, since when the 25-years lasting mission that you've learnt it existed only recently owns you exactly seven days of function on the darn comet? To be more serious: of course the scientists will learn a lot even from every thing that went wrong. That's exactly how science works. It still doesn't mean that the public attention should concentrate on that now. See also my comment response to the "mistake" claim.
- johnchristopher 12y agoOf course you adjust your targets. But it doesn't imply you must rewrite your expectations to fit with reality after the facts as if those expectations never fluctuated. You actually lose data points by doing so.
- acqq 12y agoData points? The poster justsee actually complains about the FAQ page which didn't even have to be precise in the first place and doesn't have to be now. It's a web site directed to the uninformed public. Honestly, who do you expect to use the FAQ page for anything serious? Among other questions on that page are "Why is it so important to study comets?" "What is the difference between asteroids and comets?" You don't bother public with engineering stuff like "we have 1000 Wh power budget from the primary batteries, which will last depending on what happens when, and the different devices have different energy needs and we aren't actually sure what can happen but we prepare for as much as possible with the hope of at least something giving us some good results." They just switch off. We at least know where justsee switched off in being interested in the details: the expression "during a week" he understood as somebody promised him "exactly at least a week of entertaining news from the lander."
- jeffdavis 12y agoHistorical revisionism is not honest and it raises serious credibility issues. That's bad for science. It's quite similar to adjusting your hypothesis to fit the data. Not as bad as manipulating the data, but not ethical, either.
- pcrh 12y agoNot at all, unless the "hypothesis" was that you would reach a particular comet. I think the scientific hypotheses were more likely related to the composition of comets, than the abilities of the engineering teams, reliability of Ariane, etc.