3 ms·
I see nothing counter-intuitive about quantum entanglement. Photons travel at the speed of light--time does not exist for them. Alter one, the entangled one is
by karmakaze 12y ago
I see nothing counter-intuitive about quantum entanglement. Photons travel at the speed of light--time does not exist for them. Alter one, the entangled one is instantaneously connected.
- readerrrr 12y agoThat does not work because light speed has a limit. It is true that the photon does not experience time. Imagine a photon traveling a distance of 1 light year towards us( we are stationary). In it's reference frame it will do so immediately but in our it takes 1 year. For the photon to travel to us in zero time in both frames, the speed of light would have to be infinite, which we know it isn't.
- krapp 12y ago"If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don't understand quantum mechanics." - Richard Feynman
- readerrrr 12y agoI wish you comment were downvoted instead of karmakaze's one. He is expressing an opinion and even if he is wrong, it is still an interesting idea, and shows some effort. A decent short explanation could show the mistake, and make a good comment->answer combo. Instead you quoted a comment which is out of context ( Feynman's comment is intended for physicists of his level ), contributing nothing. ( Please don't take this as a personal attack ( it isn't), but more a thought what's wrong with HN in light of recent debate )
- krapp 12y agoNo, you're right - it was snide and I should have reconsidered it.
- jostylr 12y agoThe issue is with instantaneous. What does that mean in a relativistic context? Depending on the speed of the observer, "instantaneous" changes. This is fine in reconciling some story in the future, but if there is an action happening instantaneously with something else, then we need a notion of same instant. This is easy to add to have something working, but it is extremely hard to add it in a principled way.