4 ms·
Good points I'll grant, but it naively seems to me that this issue with batteries running low is a perennial problem with spacecraft. Unless the RTG/solar mass
by jessriedel 12y ago
Good points I'll grant, but it naively seems to me that this issue with batteries running low is a perennial problem with spacecraft.
Unless the RTG/solar mass ration is very high, your points about having most of the experiments already ran in the first day, or about RTGs not helping with other failure modes, don't matter too much. Either way when you include a power source (RTG or solar) you are doing so for the purpose of getting data after the first day.
Besides avoiding the shading problem, I believe RTGs are also more robust to unfurling issues and to impact damage.
- micampe 12y agoLooking at pictures, I believe Philae solar panels are on the external shell, they don't need to be extended.
- 3am 12y agoYou have a better physics background than me, but it seems like the Philae mission would be particularly concerned with weight because of the velocity it had to achieve. Considering it took 10 years to reach its destination, maybe the shielding required for an RTG would be prohibitively heavy. Maybe the overhead in increased costs due to limited availability of PU238 and additional launch preparations/safety were better spent elsewhere. I figure the ESA made the best decision for the mission, though, and were well aware of the tradeoffs involved, don't you?